Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
What's the difference?
Are you getting defensive? I wasn't making accusations, I was just making a statement of what I believe.
The difference is what the bible identifies. The word "subjective" does not identify a source, whereas the bible does.
Could you elaborate at what you are getting at? I'm uncertain what you are trying to say.
Great point! At the end of the day it is not going to matter how much I know or what I have accomplished, what will matter is...did I love my wife, did I take time out with my children to be with them, did I speak to the person everyone else was ignoring, did I help others when I saw them in need and I had what they needed, did I do it out of obligation or from a giving heart? Did I spend more time talking about love or more time giving, receiving and experiencing it?
I'm preaching at myself now.
Brady: and that is really what I am reffering to...an experience from God that results in revelation.
Well spoken.The roles of experience and intellect are neither one primary in our knowledge of God, but are both incorporated in it.
What's primary is revelation from the Father through the Holy Spirit, and allowing that to be what we hold onto in our knowledge of God. Peter knew Jesus was the Christ because Father revealed it to him. Had nothing to do with his own intellect. Many in Israel at that time studied the scripture, which speaks of Jesus, yet they didn't recognize Him because they didn't receive the revelation of the truth.
Intellect on its own is just darkness. Why do you think there's so many different interpretations of the bible?
It breaks my heart that there is a whole generation coming up around me that never experienced a really strong move of God. Why isn't God showing up in churches today? It certainly seems like the presence of the Lord is becoming more and more rare. I think we are substituting programs for truth, a party for the presence of the Holy One. It's very sad.
The problem with experience is that it is completely individual in nature. I can't share your experience and you can't share mine.
Even if we are standing in the same revival at the same time singing the same song, it is entirely possible that you and I would have completely different experiences of it.
When you attempt to share your experience with me via description, language, all I can do is relate it to my own experience, or to a certain degree attempt to imagine it, which will also probably be rooted in my own experience.
Thus, on a certain level, we either have to believe that other people's experiences are like our own, or we are simply unable to truly know anything about them.
Thus, to a certain extent you have to expect that, if you are attempting to relate your experiences to other people, they will relate them to their own experiences.
I have had great experiences of God in charismatic worship. However, when considering that I spent 30 years going to a charismatic church, they were relatively few and far between.
Granted, most sundays were 'good' experiences, but they were not special really. (which is of course true by definition because if every sunday was 'special' then special would lose its meaning).
Even back when I was fully immersed in that particular church, back when I was a teen or in my early twenties, I saw LOTS of people who had experiences and raved about how wonderful they were etc. But I knew that many of them were not true for two reasons.
#1 - the way people acted during said experiences was contrary to godliness
#2 - (more importantly) the people remained unchanged
In fact, I have to admit I might not be accurate in saying that their experiences weren't true... they may have been genuine experiences, but what I'm getting at is despite those experiences, the people really didn't know God, at least not very well. Thus even if they had a genuine experience, they really didn't encounter God in that experience in a lasting way. In which case I must ask, what good is it?
By far the best experiences I have had with God have been since I left that church and started pursuing the historic, original, faith.
They were not in revival services, but rather in prayer and meditation. I actually tear up even remembering some of them. Times where I would literally just burst out into song, or tongues because I literally felt like it was the only way I could express the joy and wonder in my spirit. Other times where I was moved to weep because of the sheer beauty of God that he was revealing to me, it was more than I could take.
I don't mean to undermine, or belittle your experiences because honestly, I don't know what they are, only you do.
However, I can only speak based on my experiences. What I can tell you based on my own experience is that the things I remember from back in my younger days in my old church were moving, sometimes to joy, other times to tears etc, they were inspirational... but they were in a sense only an introduction. The appetizer if you will. As my knowledge of God and my understanding has increased, by God's grace and guidance, it has lead me onward to deeper, more moving experiences. Not the opposite.
However, I also offer up this caution. God has always kept this in the forefront of my mind as well... do not seek experiences. Seek God.
Seeking experiences is fundamentally selfish in nature. Its like the lover who constantly demands that their lover provide them with romance... they really aren't focusing on their lover, but rather on themselves and their own desires.
Seek God, seek his desires. Be willing to go without experience if that is what is required to know God.
I should also clarify that when I talk about knowing God, I'm not talking merely about study. That is only one small part. Much more important than study is prayer and meditation.
Joh 14:12 Verily, verily, I say unto you, He that believeth on me, the works that I do shall he do also; and greater works than these shall he do; because I go unto the Father.
Simon Templar,
Both your posts here reminded me of Brother Lawrence, have you read his book (very small account of his life and conversion) of 'Practice the Presence of God'?
Brother Lawrence
I also agree that prayer and meditation accomplish more in the renewing of my mind and a deeper understanding of the awesomeness of God. It's hard to put in words. I guess you struck a cord in me with your comments. Thanks.
As for the op, I think both, but as JE Brady mentioned - they are not primary
The problem with experience is that it is completely individual in nature. I can't share your experience and you can't share mine.
Even if we are standing in the same revival at the same time singing the same song, it is entirely possible that you and I would have completely different experiences of it.
When you attempt to share your experience with me via description, language, all I can do is relate it to my own experience, or to a certain degree attempt to imagine it, which will also probably be rooted in my own experience.
Thus, on a certain level, we either have to believe that other people's experiences are like our own, or we are simply unable to truly know anything about them.
Thus, to a certain extent you have to expect that, if you are attempting to relate your experiences to other people, they will relate them to their own experiences.
I have had great experiences of God in charismatic worship. However, when considering that I spent 30 years going to a charismatic church, they were relatively few and far between.
Granted, most sundays were 'good' experiences, but they were not special really. (which is of course true by definition because if every sunday was 'special' then special would lose its meaning).
Even back when I was fully immersed in that particular church, back when I was a teen or in my early twenties, I saw LOTS of people who had experiences and raved about how wonderful they were etc. But I knew that many of them were not true for two reasons.
#1 - the way people acted during said experiences was contrary to godliness
#2 - (more importantly) the people remained unchanged
In fact, I have to admit I might not be accurate in saying that their experiences weren't true... they may have been genuine experiences, but what I'm getting at is despite those experiences, the people really didn't know God, at least not very well. Thus even if they had a genuine experience, they really didn't encounter God in that experience in a lasting way. In which case I must ask, what good is it?
By far the best experiences I have had with God have been since I left that church and started pursuing the historic, original, faith.
They were not in revival services, but rather in prayer and meditation. I actually tear up even remembering some of them. Times where I would literally just burst out into song, or tongues because I literally felt like it was the only way I could express the joy and wonder in my spirit. Other times where I was moved to weep because of the sheer beauty of God that he was revealing to me, it was more than I could take.
I don't mean to undermine, or belittle your experiences because honestly, I don't know what they are, only you do.
However, I can only speak based on my experiences. What I can tell you based on my own experience is that the things I remember from back in my younger days in my old church were moving, sometimes to joy, other times to tears etc, they were inspirational... but they were in a sense only an introduction. The appetizer if you will. As my knowledge of God and my understanding has increased, by God's grace and guidance, it has lead me onward to deeper, more moving experiences. Not the opposite.
However, I also offer up this caution. God has always kept this in the forefront of my mind as well... do not seek experiences. Seek God.
Seeking experiences is fundamentally selfish in nature. Its like the lover who constantly demands that their lover provide them with romance... they really aren't focusing on their lover, but rather on themselves and their own desires.
Seek God, seek his desires. Be willing to go without experience if that is what is required to know God.
I should also clarify that when I talk about knowing God, I'm not talking merely about study. That is only one small part. Much more important than study is prayer and meditation.
That is a nice post. Not really what I was getting at, but I don't disagree.
I think God is someone we can experience daily and the reason we don't is very much because the world around us crowds our senses. I am not saying a person is less because their senses are crowded, its just the more they are, the harder it is to live the Christian life. Lot is a good example of someone's who's senses were severely crowded by the worldliness around him.
Are their deeply spiritual Christians who don't have supernatural experiences? Yes I am sure there are, but based on my own experiences it is not because we can't.
I believe we can supernaturally hear from God and Him move supernaturally in our lives on a daily basis, but very very few of us do (me included) because of the crowding of what it means to simply live in the world. True Spirit filled services are a way to touch base with that again on a regular basis through the gathering together of like minded people who build each other up and renew each other not just in the hearing of the Word, not just in corporate worship, but in the stirring of the anointing inside of each of us.
If we are to move supernaturally, it can't be just a one man show or a nice Biblical presentation...it takes the whole body working together in unity and oneness of purpose and spirit.
Consequently, if you do not listen to Theology, that will not mean that you have no ideas about God. It will mean that you have a lot of wrong ones - bad, muddled, out-of-date ideas. For a great many of the ideas about God which are trotted out as novelties today are simply the ones which real Theologians tried centuries ago and rejected. To believe in the popular religion of modern England is retrogression - like believing the earth is flat.
I agree with Arb's last post and yours Twiggy...the thing is, it is a hard road to walk, the journey of holiness. As Arb said, we get ridiculed for it.
It is very frustrating sometimes trying to communicate to people when they think they understand what your saying and really they don't.
Again, the problem with experiences.
The first question I would ask is.... what is a supernatural experience?
The second I would ask is... why do you want them?
If you could open your eyes beyond the world that you have been trained to see, you might begin to see that everything is a supernatural experience.
And at the same time, nothing is a supernatural experience...
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?