Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
I don't think that that follows.Since he alone is uncreated I think he can create anything.
Since he alone is uncreated I think he can create anything.
I don't think that that follows.
When I was a Christian, I migrated to the ex Deo concept.What does follow is that the choice of construction materials would be somewhat limited though.
That has all sorts of interesting ramifications.
When I was a Christian, I migrated to the ex Deo concept.
I'm talking above my pay grade here. But I think it does follow because I think God is akin to Aristotle's Prime Mover. Even his name, Yahweh, has been translated by scholars as "He Brings into Existence Whatever Exists" (from Yahweh | Translation, Elohim, Meaning, & Facts). So I think he is responsible for existence itself. Could he have created a different set of elementary particles at the start of this universe? Sure, because he himself isn't made of them. He "dwells in unapproachable light", which I take to be the fountainhead of existence. Who am I to put limits on the source of existence itself? Not me.I don't think that that follows.
I might be true that if such a being were to exist and it were the only such being then there might be a time when nothing else existed. As such, such a being would be the only being that could create *something*. But, it doesn't follow that it could create *anything*.
When I was a Christian, I migrated to the ex Deo concept.
Thanks for the reply.Orthodox Theology seems to come down on that side as well (ex Deo, out of Self) vs (ex Nihlio, out of Nothing) or Buffy (ex Squilla, out of Shrimp)
"Rather than say that he created the universe out of nothing, we should
say that he created it out of his own self, which is love. We should think,
not of God the Manufacturer or God the Craftsman, but of God the
Lover. Creation is an act not so much of his free will as of his free love.
To love means to share" ~The Orthodox Way, Kallistos Ware
(Think of a 3D object, e.g., a sphere, projected onto a 2D plane, e.g., a circle). Thus, he experiences time differently than we do but analogously to how we do. It accounts for a certain free will, his knowledge is different and more complete but perhaps allows for a certain lack of knowledge that gives us free will while he almost knows perfectly what we will do.
When God created the universe, did He create a universe that is the only one that He could have created or did He choose to create this universe over other different universes knowing all that would happen in this universe?
How can they not be all predetermined if God could have made a different universe but chose to create this one? Did God create the universe not knowing what would happen in it?No.
Evidently, and also according to the scriptural text read more fully and carefully, God apparently has made us able to at least sometimes do an unpredictable choice/change in direction.
By design, as it were.
Or more simply: He made us like Himself:
John 10:34 Jesus replied, "Is it not written in your Law: 'I have said you are gods'?
God made us to be like Himself, able to make choices (meaning those choices are not all predetermined).
So you are saying you don't know? Which is a perfectly fine answer.That's my opinion, yes -- I don't think a wholly different kind of reality/universe would accomplish the same.
Your OP is asking for speculations. The answer isn't plainly stated as I read it, unless you count such things as "all things work for our good".
Ok, then if God created this universe knowing what would happen in it how do you have free will to choose God?Since he alone is uncreated I think he can create anything.
I don't know is an honest and acceptable answer.For me, this question is the same as "Is the universe, as it is, the only way that the universe could be?" There are lots of events that could be otherwise -- I could plant an oak tree instead of a maple tree in my backyard, or (more significantly) a species in the ancient past could have survived instead of going extinct, etc. -- so in that way, the universe could definitely be different from what it is. But for more fundamental elements -- could the speed of light be different from what it is? could mathematics itself be different from what it is? and so on -- I really don't know how much fundamental differences like these are possible.
Sure, I would be interested understanding they are speculations.God hasn't spoken on that issue that I can think of. So I can only speculate. If you'd like to hear my speculations, I can share my thoughts.
Is this turning into another "God is unfair" thread? I hope not.Ok, then if God created this universe knowing what would happen in it how do you have free will to choose God?
for love to exist, evil had to be possible, and so would happen plenty, right along with the good things.
I know. That is not the point. If God has the foreknowledge then He knew what would happen if he created this universe. If he could choose to create different universes then he chose everything that would happen to you and you have no free will.Is this turning into another "God is unfair" thread? I hope not.
Just because God has foreknowledge doesn't mean that everything is predestined. See 1 Samuel 23:1-14 for an example of this, where God prophesies a future that never happens. This means that God can see not only the future that happens, but other ones as well. Thus, foreknowledge doesn't necessitate predestination.
More about that here, from a scholar of the Hebrew bible:
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?