• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Comment on the first impression

Billnew

Legend
Apr 23, 2004
21,246
1,234
59
Ohio
Visit site
✟42,863.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Politics
CA-Conservatives
Writing sights I have looked at said the first paragraph and first page were the most important in grabbing a publisher's/reader's attention.
So I thought I would submit my first half page and see what you think.

Dead Boring, slightly boring, weak start, not bad, got my attention please post more, kind of critique.

I guess I should ask those that are disinterested in Fantasy stories to limit thier comment, as it would probably be boring even if it
was written by Tolken, or other fantasy/Scifi acclaimed authors.
** ** ** ** **
The beginning

Aritae walks out into the crisp spring air. Humans might think it was cold but Aritae liked it a little cool. She even wore summer clothes when others wore heavy cloaks. Her friends in town said she was hot blooded. She wears a summer Elven dress, her legs were visible above her knees, some said the dress was to short, mostly the aristocratic townswomen, and even some married female commoners. She did not care. She dressed as she was comfortable. She was not brought up in town. Even today she is a loner, preferring to stay in the Swiftspine mountain caverns. She could research more magic in her lab, harvest the unique herbs that grew in the damp part of her caves, or climb to the peak of the mountain and stare out over the trees across the forest.
Just for fun she would scry the local town bar or other locations and for practice, Look with the assistance of her magic at what is going on in town. It kept her up on current events and gossip. She did not go into town much. The men, human and Elves were distracted by both, her and her sisters beauty. It mattered not what she wore, she tried wearing a monk’s burlap robe, and still they followed her. The only peace was found if she entered town with her hood pulled over her head, so no one would see her face. This was very uncomfortable and hot. So she only went to town to trade on special occasions.
Her sister lived just league to the north, a couple hours as the bird flies. She too, was a loner. She on occasions invites other weapons masters to her mountain home, to challenge her to a duel. She is a weapons master. She practices most of the day, and researches all the great leaders their tactics and fighting styles when she rests. Mage or spell master and Weapons master was no lost title on them. They were young, but had a life expectancy of five generations of humans. Her sister, named Katia, and Aritae had already been on many adventures and each had chests of gold and other treasures hidden in their homes. From the peak of Swiftspine mountain she could see the peak of her sister’s mountain.
Aritae loved her sister, but they did not visit often. They would annoy each other quickly. They were loners even to their family. Aritae and Katia’s mother, Vanimedle had visited once since Aritae had moved away. There was something about having another woman in her home, that. Just annoyed them all, even daughter or sisters.
Sons did not bother their Mother as much. But Aritae’s little brother was quickly approaching the time when he would be expected to go out in the world and find himself a homestead. It was the way of her family.
 
Nov 23, 2009
185
14
Ohio
✟22,865.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
I'm one of those 'disinterested in Fantasy' people, so I won't comment on hook, content or style. I do feel qualified to point out the tense issues, which would be a problem regardless of genre. (Make sure your verbs are all either past or present tense.) Commas were also frequently misused in this passage, and there were some grammar issues. Nothing a thorough edit couldn't fix, though. Best of luck!
 
Upvote 0

Billnew

Legend
Apr 23, 2004
21,246
1,234
59
Ohio
Visit site
✟42,863.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Politics
CA-Conservatives
I'm one of those 'disinterested in Fantasy' people, so I won't comment on hook, content or style. I do feel qualified to point out the tense issues, which would be a problem regardless of genre. (Make sure your verbs are all either past or present tense.) Commas were also frequently misused in this passage, and there were some grammar issues. Nothing a thorough edit couldn't fix, though. Best of luck!
Yes, this one has not been sent to my friend to edit out these mistakes, Word 2007 does point out alot of my mistakes but I guess not all are caught.
The proof reader did note that the first book, did have tense issues. That one I had reworked at least four complete times and did not catch it. This one is still in beginning stage.
For me beginning stage is the words flow out with the bare bones meat of the story, not perfect phrases just getting the story out.
Much like woodworking, stage 1;rough cut pieces coming together, 2;extremely rough sandpaper to get the major flaws, 3.medium sandpaper to smooth out the surface, 4.fine sandpaper; to get rid of most minor flaws, 5;the staining and finishing, polishing the final
The proof reader is 3-5.

Thanks
 
Upvote 0
Nov 23, 2009
185
14
Ohio
✟22,865.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
I don't know much about woodworking, but as a writer I definitely understand the importance of editing and revision. I didn't realize this was a rough draft. With so many revisions left to go through, your piece will undoubtedly be quite different by the time it's finished and will then make a different first impression on readers. Good luck.
 
Upvote 0

Billnew

Legend
Apr 23, 2004
21,246
1,234
59
Ohio
Visit site
✟42,863.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Politics
CA-Conservatives
This is about half way, #3 in the list.
Most sentence structure and errors that aren't obvious to Word
have not been removed. I am not great with that, that is why I have someone that is better at that look it over.

#1; is the words pouring out
#2: better description of the situation, correcting simple errors.
#3: begin better error removal, checking to see if positional or other obvious errors,
like saying someone is in one place then suddenly appears in a place they could not be, or saying eye color is blue in one green in another.

#4; working with the proof reader to knock out the less obvious errors.
#5; rereading the whole work to make sure changes did not change the story or create a problem, fine tuning words, and one last check before
considering sending it out...which I have not reached yet in any story.
 
Upvote 0