Christian only question on morality

[Matthewj1985]

Please only respond to this if you have a "Christian icon". Thanks free thinkers.

A man and a woman with a toddler are sitting on a bench in a park. A stone comes out of nowhere and strikes the woman in the head knocking her unconscious. Her toddler wanders toward a pond in the park, he falls in and starts to drown. The man sitting one the bench sees him and does nothing. The child dies and the mother wakes up.

Is this a moral man?

 

[BlackSabb]

Please only respond to this if you have a "Christian icon". Thanks free thinkers.

A man and a woman with a toddler are sitting on a bench in a park. A stone comes out of nowhere and strikes the woman in the head knocking her unconscious. Her toddler wanders toward a pond in the park, he falls in and starts to drown. The man sitting one the bench sees him and does nothing. The child dies and the mother wakes up.

Is this a moral man?

Huh????

Seriously dude, get more sleep.

 

[SiderealExalt]

Try posting in the all Christian sections, there are ones available to you.

 

[Sylvanspirits]

Huh????

It's one of several ways to start a discussion on the Problem of Evil.

If someone states that they believe that the man's action were not moral, then it brings up the question of why God, essentially being in the same position, would not stop the incident, and as such whether or not said God is fully good or truely omnipotent. *debate begins here*
But it's past midnight and I'm too tired.

You'd probably get a better response in some of the other forums, this one doesn't get much traffic.

 

[HighwayMan]

I'd say no, he's not a good man.

Next question: if a teenager impregnates 5 girls, get stoned and drunk at a party then runs over 2 homeless people and an elderly person while chewing tobacco...is he a socially responsible individual?

 

[Chesterton]

It's one of several ways to start a discussion on the Problem of Evil.

If someone states that they believe that the man's action were not moral, then it brings up the question of why God, essentially being in the same position, would not stop the incident, and as such whether or not said God is fully good or truely omnipotent. *debate begins here*

It’s a false and preposterous condition that God is “essentially in the same position” as a man. If anyone can demonstrate that “The God” and “a man” are the same thing, with the same responsibilities, same knowledge, wisdom, omniscience and plan, then and only then could that debate start.

 

[brinny]

Please only respond to this if you have a "Christian icon". Thanks free thinkers.

A man and a woman with a toddler are sitting on a bench in a park. A stone comes out of nowhere and strikes the woman in the head knocking her unconscious. Her toddler wanders toward a pond in the park, he falls in and starts to drown. The man sitting one the bench sees him and does nothing. The child dies and the mother wakes up.

Is this a moral man?

get the toddler, mon, in meantime have someone cal 911 to get help on the way for the woman...

you see how the toddler faces sure death...the woman is unconscious but is most likely breathing.....

the man is a dolt and needs his keyster kicked

 

[brinny]

I'd say no, he's not a good man.

Next question: if a teenager impregnates 5 girls, get stoned and drunk at a party then runs over 2 homeless people and an elderly person while chewing tobacco...is he a socially responsible individual?

ROFL!! are you asking a serious question?

 

[stan1980]

I'd say no, he's not a good man.

Next question: if a teenager impregnates 5 girls, get stoned and drunk at a party then runs over 2 homeless people and an elderly person while chewing tobacco...is he a socially responsible individual?

I'd say so. Okay he killed 3 people, but two of them were tramps and the other was on his last legs anyway, and when you balance it up against the 5 new lives he has created, you'd have to say it was a pretty successful night out all in all.

 

[B'alaam]

...while chewing tobacco...is he a socially responsible individual?

Well, if he was chewing tobacco, I sure wouldn't kiss him

 

[brinny]

Originally Posted by HighwayMan
I'd say no, he's not a good man.

Next question: if a teenager impregnates 5 girls, get stoned and drunk at a party then runs over 2 homeless people and an elderly person while chewing tobacco...is he a socially responsible individual?

I'd say so. Okay he killed 3 people, but two of them were tramps and the other was on his last legs anyway, and when you balance it up against the 5 new lives he has created, you'd have to say it was a pretty successful night out all in all.

my friend has done lost hiz mind

 

[brinny]

Originally Posted by HighwayMan
...while chewing tobacco...is he a socially responsible individual?

Well, if he was chewing tobacco, I sure wouldn't kiss him

i think yu missed the point

 

[B'alaam]

i think yu missed the point

On purpose...Hence my smiley

 

[stan1980]

my friend has done lost hiz mind

Thanks to him, the population will increase by 2, not to mention he's rid us of 3 wasters, so it's a good day for society!

 

[brinny]

Originally Posted by brinny
my friend has done lost hiz mind

Thanks to him, the population will increase by 2, not to mention he's rid us of 3 wasters, so it's a good day for society!

nooooo no throw-away people...haven't yu ever felt like useless heap or been maybe what people would consider a waste of human flesh and then risen from the ashes of destruction?

nooooo no throw-away people....

 

[flicka]

Maybe the man was paralized, would that make a difference?

And since the OP was posted in this section I'm responding even though I lack the desired icon

 

[brinny]

Maybe the man was paralized, would that make a difference?

And since the OP was posted in this section I'm responding even though I lack the desired icon

LOL well i won't say anything if yu don't haha nevermind yu just did

if he's paralyzed he's not held responsible......he's helpless to do anything...

 

[stan1980]

nooooo no throw-away people...haven't yu ever felt like useless heap or been maybe what people would consider a waste of human flesh and then risen from the ashes of destruction?

nooooo no throw-away people....

Is that a song?

 

[brinny]

Originally Posted by brinny
nooooo no throw-away people...haven't yu ever felt like useless heap or been maybe what people would consider a waste of human flesh and then risen from the ashes of destruction?

nooooo no throw-away people....

Is that a song?

LOL well maybe it should be

 

[stan1980]

LOL well maybe it should be

Well don't forget the little people when you're famous!