In my 8 months of attending church fairly regularly and in my time lurking around here this is something I have noticed to be very common amongst many Christians. A large number of people I know(most of whom are not Christians) have made mention of this trait as well: this overwhelming self-righteousness and arrogance that just flows out of so many Christians that belittles and smacks everyone around them in the face.
You know, the Pharisees felt that Jesus was rather too big for his britches, too. Of course, he was the humblest of men, serving the sick, the hungry, the foolish without complaint. As humble as he was, though, Jesus never minced words. He spoke the truth - sometimes very bluntly - to the Pharisees, warning them of the evil and the danger of their religious hypocrisy. It seems to me that no matter how well Jesus conducted himself there was always going to be
someone who thought he was on his high horse and speaking down to everybody. This is more the effect of a guilty and convicted conscience on the part of those who were critical of Jesus, however, than real arrogance on Jesus' part.
I think the same thing often (though not always) happens with Christ's followers. The North American cultures have embraced uncertainty and moral relativity as a basic philosophy of life, which crashes violently against the moral absolutes and truth of the Christian worldview. As a result, those in the world find Christians far too confident in their truth and annoyingly clear on what is right and wrong. They often feel convicted in the presence of those who are really walking with the Lord and this prompts them to accuse Christians of being arrogant.
Now, sometimes Christians
are arrogant. But I don't agree with you that this is more the case among believers than it is among non-believers. I have lived within the evangelical Christian community for a long time and never seen that it is.
I do like the idea of having faith; but I really don't think I want it if it is going to result in me being this way..
CHristianity isn't about "having faith." It's about knowing and loving the Saviour and living in loving obedience to God. When you understand this and live it out, you will inevitably run into those who find your clarity and purity of living offensive to their own muddled and sinful existence. They will accuse you, too, of arrogance - not because you actually are, but because your accusers hate how badly they look in comparison to the godly life you're leading.
"They who do evil hate the light..." Jn. 3:20
Selah.