Naomi4Christ said:
If you think that the alcohol in wine has a concentration of 12%. Drinking a whole bottle in a short amount of time (say an hour) would lead to a concentration in your blood of around 0.1% (just over the UK drink-drive limit of 0.08%). Then again, the baby doesn't usually drink 750ml in this amount of time.
It's obviously a personal choice as to whether you drink or not, and you can factor up or down my calculations. Bottom line is that it is still a small amount of alcohol that the baby would be exposed to and his liver is well able to cope with this.
I think the bf counsellor is wrong to say that the alcohol is directly responsible for making a baby sleep longer - studies are not clear on this, with the scales being tipped in the direction of the baby not sleeping as long, but with most saying it makes not one iota of difference.
One of the benefits of having an early evening drink it can reduce the liklihood of colic - calm mother, calm baby - and that may be what leads to a more peaceful sleep. It is also thought to help with milk supply when it starts to sap in that early evening time.
Your 1st paragraph is based souly on an estimate. If I drink a glass of wine or what have you (not being a drinker) my blood alcohol rises MUCH faster than someone who say drinks of wine a week.
I actually can get tipsy on 1 to 1 1/2 drinks. I would be above the legal limit I'm sure, and I'm a pretty big girl.
Your 2nd paragraph states that the small amount of alcohol baby gets can be broken down by his liver and that baby can cope. This really depends. A baby's liver is NOT fully mature at birth. This is why so many babies are born jaundice. The liver doesn't fully break down billiruben until after birth. So in a newborn, it may not be able to cope. After the first 3 months, it SHOULD be able to cope.. by why take the chance of hardship on an organ that just finished it's maturation.
I'd like to see some type of study, professional journal or article supporting your 3rd paragraph. LLL is one of my most trusted sources and says that "most" are unsure, not that most say it's okay.
LLL also says that studies do not show benefits, I haven't found reputable sources that say that it reduces colic.
I don't believe in wine being used as medicine. It's old wives tales that say to have a glass of red wine for this or that ailment. More often than not they are a Band-Aid not a cure.
With all this said, I have no problems with the mom who feeds baby, then heads out of baby's site to have a (ONE) drink, and waits a few hours to feed baby again... especially after the 3 month mark. However, I don't advocate for it at all. Most mom's haven't drank since pre-pregnancy, her hormones are still settling, and if she's breast feeding she's got a huge responsibility of making sure her child is taken care of properly. Once tipsy peoples impulses change and they react differently. I find it irresponsible once it passes a fine line.