• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

  • CF has always been a site that welcomes people from different backgrounds and beliefs to participate in discussion and even debate. That is the nature of its ministry. In view of recent events emotions are running very high. We need to remind people of some basic principles in debating on this site. We need to be civil when we express differences in opinion. No personal attacks. Avoid you, your statements. Don't characterize an entire political party with comparisons to Fascism or Communism or other extreme movements that committed atrocities. CF is not the place for broad brush or blanket statements about groups and political parties. Put the broad brushes and blankets away when you come to CF, better yet, put them in the incinerator. Debate had no place for them. We need to remember that people that commit acts of violence represent themselves or a small extreme faction.
  • We hope the site problems here are now solved, however, if you still have any issues, please start a ticket in Contact Us

  • The rule regarding AI content has been updated. The rule now rules as follows:

    Be sure to credit AI when copying and pasting AI sources. Link to the site of the AI search, just like linking to an article.

Atheist Thought: American Alienation

451ffan

Member
Dec 27, 2006
65
1
39
OC, CA
✟30,199.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Single
When I was back in high school, life was no picnic, but it was by psychiatric-methodology, abnormal to a lesser extent. Over the course of two years, me and my five friends grew apart as we pursued our individual pursuits for individual gains. We saw lesser and lesser of each other, each becoming ever-more gradually compartmentalized into various things: computer interaction, television, and lots of school and work.

Perhaps by no small coincidence, over the course of two years every one of my five friends in discussion came down with clinical depression, citing loneliness, apathy, and failures as reasons--which included myself, albeit my diagnosis was of bipolar disorder, a segment of the much larger classification of "depression," which comes in many shapes and sizes.

And now, perhaps merely a random thought, I begin to contemplate as to what happened to the old fables from middle and elementary school of "changing the world" and "fairness" and "peace?" Somewhere along the line, as did the interpersonal contact, ideals such as these were abandoned without even a second thought.

And so I offer a tentative conclusion for why the rates of depression are approximately one in five over a person's lifetime, and why my upper-middle class peers all, coincidently, were diagnosed by the "black dog" in a very short time span. I should explicitly state that my use of the word "coincidence" is nothing but open mockery towards various trends that I can see very well with my eyes, those of depression, worthlessness, apathy, laziness, stupidity, and alienation. As it was in American history that, subsequent to the Wagner Act, the mobilization of unions were forever bound and gagged, so it has been with the community life of the common men and women of this country.

Any sort of real progress in this country will be bound indefinitely if the people do not regain their collective power through actual, physical bonds in the local community. This certainly extends to those of secular backgrounds, such as we all are (here), for we do not have the luxury of the church as a community gathering. The closest thing we get is Fox News, or, if one is especially wary of corporate agendas, The News Hour, which we all watch alone and silent.

The question of whether America is an individualistic nation is almost a tautology, for America is known for it's "rugged, individualistic spirit." But as most ideals that we follow, the duality simultaneously emerges as one considers the benefits that arise from individualism, against its lesser known perils. To ignore this duality says nothing of its existence, which manifests itself in the negative traits and statuses of depression, anxiety, fear, and scarcity, as well as the so-called positive effects that are almost universally praised upon one hand as the traits that drive American success: hard work, very high standards of beauty, conspicuous consumption, long hours, and pulling oneself up by the bootstraps to self-actualization.

Being that I am one of the so-called "victors" in the American race: young, idealistic, hard-working, white, fit, wealthy, and above-average intellect--I feel as if I can shed some light as to where this rat race leads, albeit a subjective viewpoint in its entirety. I personally feel that all of you who are reading this exhibit some identification with the aforementioned paragraphs I have just written. The so-called paradigm of Americanism, in short, is a dangerously skewed view of the world that focused on specific, and limited, gains for the individual, while wholly neglecting the inherent evils automatically asserted with the affirmative viewpoint that we all were once told was what made us, the US, special and unique. I hold it now as self-evident through the senses that for every aspect of so-called "American success," in the "American way," there is an equally important counterpoint to be made for each of the assertions of the good of the value in question. With hard work comes stress, with success comes elitism. With materialism comes superficiality, and with the deification of the dollar comes the abject defication and objectification of human labor as a means to an end that does not even attempt to veil itself within the cloak of a sheep. We have been left with a monistic theory of value, that of monetary gain, as the soul and life of a country that we used to think held the key for open-ended prosperity with no malevalent consequences on any forseeable horizon. I leave it to this forum to decide whether or not, as I have concluded, the "American Dream" is nothing more than a mirage.

-MSB
 

EverlastingMan

Regular Member
Dec 7, 2005
438
12
36
HI
✟30,649.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
When I was back in high school, life was no picnic, but it was by psychiatric-methodology, abnormal to a lesser extent. Over the course of two years, me and my five friends grew apart as we pursued our individual pursuits for individual gains. We saw lesser and lesser of each other, each becoming ever-more gradually compartmentalized into various things: computer interaction, television, and lots of school and work.

Perhaps by no small coincidence, over the course of two years every one of my five friends in discussion came down with clinical depression, citing loneliness, apathy, and failures as reasons--which included myself, albeit my diagnosis was of bipolar disorder, a segment of the much larger classification of "depression," which comes in many shapes and sizes.

And now, perhaps merely a random thought, I begin to contemplate as to what happened to the old fables from middle and elementary school of "changing the world" and "fairness" and "peace?" Somewhere along the line, as did the interpersonal contact, ideals such as these were abandoned without even a second thought.

And so I offer a tentative conclusion for why the rates of depression are approximately one in five over a person's lifetime, and why my upper-middle class peers all, coincidently, were diagnosed by the "black dog" in a very short time span. I should explicitly state that my use of the word "coincidence" is nothing but open mockery towards various trends that I can see very well with my eyes, those of depression, worthlessness, apathy, laziness, stupidity, and alienation. As it was in American history that, subsequent to the Wagner Act, the mobilization of unions were forever bound and gagged, so it has been with the community life of the common men and women of this country.

Any sort of real progress in this country will be bound indefinitely if the people do not regain their collective power through actual, physical bonds in the local community. This certainly extends to those of secular backgrounds, such as we all are (here), for we do not have the luxury of the church as a community gathering. The closest thing we get is Fox News, or, if one is especially wary of corporate agendas, The News Hour, which we all watch alone and silent.

The question of whether America is an individualistic nation is almost a tautology, for America is known for it's "rugged, individualistic spirit." But as most ideals that we follow, the duality simultaneously emerges as one considers the benefits that arise from individualism, against its lesser known perils. To ignore this duality says nothing of its existence, which manifests itself in the negative traits and statuses of depression, anxiety, fear, and scarcity, as well as the so-called positive effects that are almost universally praised upon one hand as the traits that drive American success: hard work, very high standards of beauty, conspicuous consumption, long hours, and pulling oneself up by the bootstraps to self-actualization.

Being that I am one of the so-called "victors" in the American race: young, idealistic, hard-working, white, fit, wealthy, and above-average intellect--I feel as if I can shed some light as to where this rat race leads, albeit a subjective viewpoint in its entirety. I personally feel that all of you who are reading this exhibit some identification with the aforementioned paragraphs I have just written. The so-called paradigm of Americanism, in short, is a dangerously skewed view of the world that focused on specific, and limited, gains for the individual, while wholly neglecting the inherent evils automatically asserted with the affirmative viewpoint that we all were once told was what made us, the US, special and unique. I hold it now as self-evident through the senses that for every aspect of so-called "American success," in the "American way," there is an equally important counterpoint to be made for each of the assertions of the good of the value in question. With hard work comes stress, with success comes elitism. With materialism comes superficiality, and with the deification of the dollar comes the abject defication and objectification of human labor as a means to an end that does not even attempt to veil itself within the cloak of a sheep. We have been left with a monistic theory of value, that of monetary gain, as the soul and life of a country that we used to think held the key for open-ended prosperity with no malevalent consequences on any forseeable horizon. I leave it to this forum to decide whether or not, as I have concluded, the "American Dream" is nothing more than a mirage.

-MSB
I wouldn't call this "americanism" because it is in no way restricted to us. It's materialism or "me-first-ism", and it is indeed absolute bogus. Of course, getting rich is a part of the American dream--I mean after all it is a dream, but I think in ages past there was a lot more to the dream.

Other than that, right on. I don't understand materialism, and personally think it's the biggest humanity will face this century.
 
Upvote 0

Robbie_James_Francis

May all beings have happiness and its causes
Apr 12, 2005
9,317
661
36
England, UK
✟35,261.00
Faith
Humanist
Marital Status
Single
I definitely do identify with what you've talked about, and I think it is one reason why a lot of depression (mild and more serious) occurs in adolesence. In an individualistic and materialistic culture, as you grow up there is always 'something'. Where at one point I for one thought it possible to change the world (not single-handed, of course), where there was hope and certainty that the future would be better, now there is so much that such ideological dreams fade away.

As the expectations of others increase throughout adolesence, it seems to me that we consequently fall into the same patterns as previous generations. At some point between, I'd guess, roughly the ages of 11 and 16, there is certainty that your generation can bring about peace, and everything else that humanity so desperately thirsts for. There is a total unquestioned belief that your friends will always be very close to you, and always be the most important thing.

Then there are private interests, that we pursue to the point that it starts to break down friendships that seemed rock solid before. And there's exams, coursework, jobs, cars, university...eventually there's rent, taxes, mortgages etc. Who has time to change the world when there's a million and one things that need to be done/paid for/organised etc. by tomorrow?

It seems to much that such individualistic 'dreams' are almost like self-fulfilling prophecies. Humanity cannot work together as a group, the theory goes, so we need to have things, jobs, money, houses...to satisfy us. So we create a system whereby this is a possible. This system in turn becomes so demanding that it is forced upon people as they grow up, and it fills our lives so much that it destroys any possibility of what it sought to replace. Similarly, we are told every day that ideologies will fail, and so, ultimately, they do.

It's not so much a dream as a nightmare. And it does not resemble, to me, 'freedom', but a type of slavery, a burdening with the failures of the past that leave us with nothing but despair for the future.

I wouldn't call this "americanism" because it is in no way restricted to us. It's materialism or "me-first-ism", and it is indeed absolute bogus.

I agree. I don't think the phenomenon is unique to America by a long shot, though perhaps it is more common there than in a lot of other countries. I think it is a serious problem around the globe.

peace
 
Upvote 0

EverlastingMan

Regular Member
Dec 7, 2005
438
12
36
HI
✟30,649.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
Then there are private interests, that we pursue to the point that it starts to break down friendships that seemed rock solid before. And there's exams, coursework, jobs, cars, university...eventually there's rent, taxes, mortgages etc. Who has time to change the world when there's a million and one things that need to be done/paid for/organised etc. by tomorrow?
You see, one of the advantages of always pursuing academics above friends--like me, is that you never have to deal with all that. Except, I've always pursued academics now so I have time to change the world later.
 
Upvote 0