Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
I for one think you are making very valid points and speaking the truth here. We need to be more in tune and connected long before a crisis ever comes. Prayer I would think would be a great start.I agree, I thought I'd mentioned that. I meant more in our day to day face to face lives. Frankly I don't know if anyone is doing that, not trying to judge anyone, I just don't hear of many examples of it outside the forums. What I tend to see is shock and dismay when people say "What, you're getting a separation/divorce" but not the faintest idea that anything was wrong. I am NOT judging here, not implying we ought to have telepathy. I just think that when it comes to our personal struggles we need perhaps to be more there before things come to a serious crisis.
In response to posts 301 and 302:
I agree entirely. I think that there's two things going on.
When it comes to serious problems I think that some people have a "it's no one else's business" type of attitude, for fear(usually unfounded) that they'll be judged.
But I think the bigger problem is that too many of us have a "it's none of MY business" attitude. We fear offering input or even fear developing the kind of relationship where that sort of input would even be "allowed". Or even if we do have that sort of close relationship, we fear that what we say will be taken the wrong way and the relationship will be ended.
I absolutely agree, except for one thing--people ARE being judged. I believe that is a BIG part of the problem--instead of coming along side and guiding with loving encouragement--there is judgment. I see a lot of pious attitudes...and a lot of people are hiding behind false facades. There is an appearance that is being reflected in a lot of churches...not all...that you DO have to have it all together to be involved and accepted. Through that isolation...conflict has a perfect breeding ground.In response to posts 301 and 302:
I agree entirely. I think that there's two things going on.
When it comes to serious problems I think that some people have a "it's no one else's business" type of attitude, for fear(usually unfounded) that they'll be judged.
But I think the bigger problem is that too many of us have a "it's none of MY business" attitude. We fear offering input or even fear developing the kind of relationship where that sort of input would even be "allowed". Or even if we do have that sort of close relationship, we fear that what we say will be taken the wrong way and the relationship will be ended.
That should be a plaque on our walls. I absolutely think that transparency is important. It is when someone has lost a job....lost a child.....has a child in jail...whatever, and the response is a cold and disconnected, "I will pray for you..and remember...God works all things out for good."That's true, people often fear being judged and many will hesitate or don't like that risk. I find though as I get older that little by little I long to be able to connect deeper with others and take little risk as we grow closer friendships.
We were talking about a persons burst in our SS class a few weeks ago, not gossip just a comment that things in class said really struck a cord with him that day. For me I said I felt I could relate to his emotional response made, because it seemed real and true to life. I prefer real or what I perceive as the real over some elaborate spiritual response. Example would be I prefer for someone to say outright hey this stinks or this is hard or losing a job makes them mad over another saying how they just praised over every hardship they ever had. I don't know if I am explaining it correctly, but hopefully get the gist of what I am saying.
Be real and pray for one another.
I absolutely agree, except for one thing--people ARE being judged. I believe that is a BIG part of the problem--instead of coming along side and guiding with loving encouragement--there is judgment. I see a lot of pious attitudes...and a lot of people are hiding behind false facades. There is an appearance that is being reflected in a lot of churches...not all...that you DO have to have it all together to be involved and accepted. Through that isolation...conflict has a perfect breeding ground.
I agree that the actual fear is the bigger problem. If it were just the judgement...then, in your case-- as an example-- you could have just gone to another church knowing that the only way it was going to get resolved was to bring it to light and deal with it.I don't disagree that people are judged. But I think the problem is made out to be bigger and more common than it really is in a lot of cases. Fear of judgement is what kept me from seeking help for my porn problem. But when I finally did seek help, there was ZERO judgement, which surprised me greatly. Maybe I've just found an exceptionally healthy church though.
In any case I think that often the fear of judgement is a bigger problem that any real judgement.
I just wanted to comment on this as a good reminder to myself. Both my wife and I have grown up in multi-generational Christian families, and we are also surrounded by people of similar familial and cultural patterns within our church. Both my wife's and my own parent's and my wife's family and friends certainly modelled a strong Biblical marriage and us seeing it as the norm probably gave us a good head start in what to expect in our marriage.I agree that a lot of the difficulty is because of a lack of community. Like you said, there is a lot of isolation behind those smiles at church. A lot of us are first generation Christians, and we need to see the Christian life walked out before us. Things sound simple and easy when we hear what is needed for a marriage to work...it often isn't until we hit a conflict that we then understand how complicated it can be.
I think that has given you a HUGE head start. It is one thing to listen to marriage conferences....read books of marriage....even attend pre-marital counseling, but you hear all that and think, "Okay...got it...we can do it...bring it on..." (maybe not in those words) and then a crisis hits, and none of that seems to make sense.I just wanted to comment on this as a good reminder to myself. Both my wife and I have grown up in multi-generational Christian families, and we are also surrounded by people of similar familial and cultural patterns within our church. Both my wife's and my own parent's and my wife's family and friends certainly modelled a strong Biblical marriage and us seeing it as the norm probably gave us a good head start in what to expect in our marriage.
Because some times that is the only option...not all of us had the blessing of growing up in a Christian home.So then why do we immediately tell people to read books and attend conferences
So then why do we immediately tell people to read books and attend conferences
I have to agree, McScribe. I had so many voices in my head, but I don't believe ANY of them were God. I know what you are saying about not giving the "whole picture". I can open my own library with all the books I have on marriage...but so many of them seem to be not really saying anything of any substance. The only books that I can highly recommend are Gary Smalley's books, Dr Henry Cloud's and Dr Townsend's. I do feel books and conferences are good...but, I don't think we should put them ahead of the Bible and God's counsel.Good question...how helpful do we find books and conferences? I have to say again, it was prayer and scripture and intense amounts of it that me to being able to work to save our marriage, not books and conferences. I mean...we must have read ten books, both of us! Wild at Heart, Love Languages, His Needs Her Needs, etc etc. They all sounded great, we even agreed with some of the principles. And in a way it was like talking to one of those blind men talking about an elephant. (you know, the parable) There were relevant experiences, but a lack of a whole picture somehow. I wonder if anyone else knows what I'm talking about.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?