The story of how I got to this point is long and can be easily drawn out. But her I am utterly confused as to why my husbands' brother and wife appear to dislike me very much. I have always tried to make conversations with her, and help her, and give her things but it's always met with silence, literally. After two years she just stays clear of me. And out of fear I've started doing the same thing. It's hurtful when she plays the snot toward me. Over the years they've been very rude to me and done some unkind things to me, and they've been very hurtful at times. But they're so subtle about it that no one notices it's a real problem other than my husband. I'm not saying I'm perfect, I'm sure I've done annoying things, but I'm still here ready to be kind if they ever notice I'm in the same room as them again. I've started questioning my faith, a true follower of Christ would keep forgiving and continue to show kindness towards them, but in my thoughts I an not kind to them. Their unkindness towards me has physically affected my nerves to the point of illness. Every time an event rolls around that I know I have to go to with her I literally get physical symptoms of my illness. I can't fathom having to spend holidays with them and how awkward it's going to be to hold their baby, my niece. I love babies, by the way, I always am the one to hold everyone's. The hardest thing for me is Jesus wants us to love EVERYONE. I feel I've never had this much trouble withstanding the blows of hatred before. We were such a happy family before he practically eloped with this woman. My other sister-in-law although also 10 years younger, we're not best friends but we get along fine when family gatherings are in place. Is there any advice on how to constantly forgive someone. Note there's no talking to them they are not a communicative family and again she's ignored my texts (of encouragement) before, there's really no use taking that route. This is something I have to change on the inside I believe.