• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

  • CF has always been a site that welcomes people from different backgrounds and beliefs to participate in discussion and even debate. That is the nature of its ministry. In view of recent events emotions are running very high. We need to remind people of some basic principles in debating on this site. We need to be civil when we express differences in opinion. No personal attacks. Avoid you, your statements. Don't characterize an entire political party with comparisons to Fascism or Communism or other extreme movements that committed atrocities. CF is not the place for broad brush or blanket statements about groups and political parties. Put the broad brushes and blankets away when you come to CF, better yet, put them in the incinerator. Debate had no place for them. We need to remember that people that commit acts of violence represent themselves or a small extreme faction.
  • We hope the site problems here are now solved, however, if you still have any issues, please start a ticket in Contact Us

An EXTREMELY long story

tryingsohard

Member
Feb 17, 2004
8
0
✟118.00
Faith
Christian
My hands might fall off while I'm typing this, so if you get a bunch of jumbled words like aoginaoidnaoidn, then just wait for me to reattach my hand. :)

Ok, well about a month ago, 2 days before Valentine's Day, my girlfriend broke up with me. I'm 20, she's almost 21, we're both in college. She's in a physical therapy program and I am studying to be a history teacher. We weren't "engaged" in the sense of having a ring and having a wedding date, but we told each other that we wanted to be with each other forever. We had been together for 1.5 years.

A little background info: I come from a family which is Catholic. For most of my teen years, I'd say from 13 to 18, I was pretty into the Catholic faith. Then, in the summer of 2002, I went to Europe, and my mind was opened by a lot of things over there. That experience helped me open my mind about Christianity too. Needless to say, my mom is one of those moms who is very into the Catholic Church. She's not crazy or anything, but she wants me, as long as I live under her roof, to go to church with the family at a Catholic mass. I had no problem with this, although my interest was beginning to increase regarding non-demoniational churches. Then, I met this girl.

It was September 2002. Let's call her "Sandy," for protection's sake. My name is Cole. We met in September 2002. We both were pretty much alone in the world...most of my friends had moved away for college, and I had lost contact with those of my friends who had stayed. Some of her best friends left for college as well. She, at this time, had two best friends, one who lives near her, and another about an hour away, who had found "the one." They were giddy, excited, and all happy about it. Sandy was happy for her friends, but also, she was mad because she wasn't spending as much time with her friends as she used to. I mean, anyone who has been in any relationship knows that your friendships are bound to suffer a little. Not necessarily suffer...just have less time devoted to them. Know what I mean? Anyway, so Sandy and I become really good friends. For about 4 weeks we hang out with each other every weekend and most every weekday/night.

I'm beginning to fall for this girl...really love her. But I'm afraid as to what she really is feeling. So I figure I'll hold off for a while to kind of feel things out. Well out of nowhere on AIM one night, she tells me she feels that we are so alike and that we are soulmates. This is great! I feel the same way! We talk, and immediately we tell each other that we want to marry each other.

I know, I know, a lot of you are probably thinking there's your mistake right there, you're 18, she's 19, you're jumping into things too early. But hey...it's natural to feel that way when you connect with someone as well as we did.

Anyway, her parents are oddly all for this. They like me a lot and say good for you when we tell them that we feel this way about each other. My parents, of course, are shocked and they tell me they don't think it's a good idea to be married off at this point in my life. And also, Sandy is non-demoniational, and she doesn't really understand Catholicism all that well. Her mom is the same way. AND SANDY AND HER MOTHER WORK WITH MY MOM. That's how we met in the first place.

So the days, weeks, months go by...and we are blossoming in our relationship. I notice something, though. Every time we discuss when we want to get married, she gets upset when it isn't within the next 2 years. She gets almost depressed about it when I try to be realistic. When we first met, she wanted to be married by the fall of this year. I would be a junior and she would still have one year to go in school. So we pretty much just kind of went with the flow. Christmas came and went, the new year started, we were doing better than ever. So in April, she really wants to go look at rings. We go look at rings together, and I end up buying one for her. I tell my parents about it and they, understandably, flip out. Buying an engagement ring is a huge thing. So I return the ring, and I tell her about it, and we cry, and we decide that we should just take it a lot slower and wait a little longer, at least until one of us is out of school, to get married. We get promise rings for each other.

So the spring semester is over, the summer semester gets through, and we begin to enter fall of 2003. Well, she suddenly has the opportunity to enter the physical therapy program at school. So she takes it and she loves it. Anyone who has been or is in a medical program knows how intense it really is. As a result, we spend less time together than before, and she is more concentrated on school than anything else...which is great, it's what she needs to do. Still, however, she says she wants to be married by the time she graduates in the spring of 2005.

About October of 2003, she tells me that she's unhappy with our relationship. Doesn't really give many specifics, just that she doesn't feel as happy as before. Now, I'm pretty sure that the reason for this is that we don't spend as much time together, and when we do, school is always on her mind. So we talk, and we decide we are going to work on things...but we never mention God.

I think things are going great after our talk...but then she emails me one week before her final exams, in December. She says she is unhappy, and that she wants to save our relationship but in order to do that we need to seroiusly change some things. So, she makes a list of things she likes about me, and a list of things she thinks I need to change, and I do the same for her. We both make a pact to seriously make an effort to change things, in order to save our relationship. Again...God is hardly mentioned.

So the day after her last exam is a Thursday. I had worked my butt off on that list, and I was proud because I felt a lot better by changing some of those things in my life. So I say to her, on Thursday, after she is done with school, I said "I really have been working on that list, what do you think of things?" And her reply is "I really haven't taken time to notice." Now, if you made the list, wouldn't you be the one who would be the most involved in it?

So I confronted her the next day, emotionally, not angrily, and she said she needed to take some time to figure out what she really wanted. I asked her if she loved me, and she said I don't know. So, about an hour after we hang up from talking on the phone about this, she calls me back. And she says "I can't take a break from you." So we again make a pact to change things, although I am worried now about what is going on because I have done that 2 times already. But, again, she never mentions God.

Christmas break comes, New Year comes, and I have to say, it was the best break and New Year's of my life. We spent almost every day together and it was like we had just met again and fallen in love all over again. Then, school starts again, and it's harder this semester for her than last. In late January, one of friends (one of the best friends who found "the one") gets married. She makes the comment to me that she'd like to be engaged within the next 6 months. I say that is perfectly possible because well, it just was. About 2 weeks before Valentine's day, we start talking about engagements. And when I mention that we would probably be engaged for 2 years or more if we were to get engaged within the next 6 months, she gets kind of depressed again, and says I don't think that we'll have to wait that long, we should be able to get married in a year and a half or so.

Ok, now's when it gets really weird. February 6th, it's a Friday, just over a week until V-day. We were talking about people being engaged and I say "Well, I don't want you to have your hopes up and get them crushed, but you won't be getting the ring for Valentine's Day...but you will get it soon, like we talked about...I am working on it." Keep in mind that I am all for this because I love the girl with all my heart and soul. When I tell her that I am working on the ring, she gets excited, she is beaming with smiles, and she is so fun the rest of the night.

For the next 4 or 5 days, we don't see each other at all because she has some major tests going on and she needs all the studying she can get. Plus, I have studying too, and school on days she doesn't have school, so we didn't get much time to see each other in the first place. So Thursday, the 12th, she comes over to my house. We watch Friends, and right after we get done, she tells me that with everything going on with school that she thinks we should just be friends for now. She says she doesn't feel an intimate bond with me, that she doesn't love me. And that she needs to get closer to God. Of course this is shocking to me...because not one week earlier she was giddy as she could be about getting engaged!!! So she says she needs some time to think if she is making the right decision...some time where we have no contact, and where she can just "get back to God." So I agree, because I love her and I want the best for her. But I'm still confused.

So she emails me the Monday after Valentine's day and says how she went to a youth group and she had people pray for her and how she realizes that she has to love herself before she can love anyone else and that she needs to get back to loving God before anything else. Then she says I am still sorting things out right now, I don't know about "us" yet. In that same email, she then says that she thinks her teacher is an "obnoxious prick." I'm not trying to judge...but for someone who claims to be on fire with God, isn't "obnoxious prick" a little harsh.

Later on in the week we talk briefly about something her mom did which was absoultely stupid (not important to this right now) and she says "I can't believe she f---ing did that!" Again...cursing? I don't get it.

So we wait the weekend and then on the next monday she emails me and says she thinks she made the right decision. I call her and ask her how she could have just fallen out of love with me, and what caused that. She says "I can't answer that, I don't know. I just know that I don't love you."

So what is it???? That's what I'm having trouble figuring out. Here I am, a month after this has gone on...and I'm doing surprisingly well. I'm just still troubled by the fact that I couldn't get a straight answer as to why she didn't love me. Was it because she just wanted to be like her friends and get married? Or was it because of someone else? I don't really buy the whole God thing because she has used that before to get out of other situations and has not gotten closer to God at all. Is it because school has made her so frustrated and upset that she views everything negatively? This is what I'm trying to figure out...and I know that you guys and gals here can't give me the answer...but is there any verse in the Bible I can look at for inspiration here?

Thanks for reading this, I know it's mega-long. I appreciate all your thoughts and prayers. God Bless.
 

John the Engineer

1 Cor 13:4
Dec 31, 2003
329
12
44
Woodland Hills, CA
✟23,030.00
Faith
Protestant
tryingsohard said:
Was it because she just wanted to be like her friends and get married?

I think this is what it all comes down to. I think she wanted to be engaged/married just like all her friends, so she put it all on. She was searching for it so hard. However that doesn't mean that what you shared isn't real, it's just that she realized why she got into it and she realized that it wasn't what fulfilled her in that respect. Call it God's inspiration or whatever that she saw that, but the fact is from everything it seems like she just wanted to be in a serious relationship. I have seen it happen a few times before with other friends. One of which was taken to "go see rings" shortly after starting to date.

Let her go, let it all go. Just give it time, maybe it will come back, maybe it won't. But just let God sort her out, and you can't judge based on what she says. May not be the Christian thing, but even Christians don't do Christian things all the time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tryingsohard
Upvote 0

tryingsohard

Member
Feb 17, 2004
8
0
✟118.00
Faith
Christian
Thanks, that was good stuff John.

Right now I'm confused because I really don't want her out of my life...but I want her to be in my life in a way she doesn't want to be. I've isolated myself completely from her for 3 weeks tomorrow...no contact period. It was my choice, she says she's open to talk to as much as I want to and as much as I can handle. But it's just too hard for me right now...I still can't see her as just a friend right now...that'd be a bit too idealistic. If given the chance I would probably give our relationship another try, at least at this moment. But I think that might be just because it's my first real breakup in my first real relationship, and maybe I'm just being afraid of being lonely. It's hard, especially since you put someone in your life for almost 2 years and then out of nowhere it's taken from you. And you want that person to be in your life so badly...it's just that they don't want what you want. I'm doing the best I can to move on with my life. I've hung out with my friends a lot more and that keeps my mind off of it, but when I'm alone it weighs on my mind. What hurts even more is that I'm sure she isn't really thinking all that much about it right now...she seemed like she had made this decision a long time ago.

:sigh:

I just don't know what to do. Maybe there will be a point in the future where I can be her friend...but in the fall I am transfering to another school which is 4 hours away from here...so there isn't that much time to save the friendship...I'm really down right now.

Thanks for reading what I have to say.
 
Upvote 0

jenptcfan

My cup runneth over
Jun 15, 2002
9,999
568
47
✟14,996.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
Wow...I know you're really confused and frustrated and hurt. I'm really sorry you're having to deal with this.

Sometimes people fall in love with 'love'. It's not so much that they're in love with the person they're with, it's just that they love all the benefits of being with that person, getting the attention, feeling secure, etc.

Sometimes it takes people awhile to realize that this is the case. It could be that she's just now realizing this.

It's totally understandable for you not to be able to be friends with her right now. You need a little time to grieve the relationship. You've been hurt, and you have every right to feel hurt right now. But don't wallow in it and stay hurt. This wound can heal over time. In fact, you don't have to be friends with her in the future if you don't feel like it. You just have to love her as a fellow Christian and not nurse any grudges against her.

Use this time to seek God. Get his direction about your future relationships because his counsel is far superior to anyone's counsel here. He loves you and wants to heal your heart.

Good luck to you.
 
Upvote 0

tryingsohard

Member
Feb 17, 2004
8
0
✟118.00
Faith
Christian
jenptcfan said:
Wow...I know you're really confused and frustrated and hurt. I'm really sorry you're having to deal with this.

Sometimes people fall in love with 'love'. It's not so much that they're in love with the person they're with, it's just that they love all the benefits of being with that person, getting the attention, feeling secure, etc.

Sometimes it takes people awhile to realize that this is the case. It could be that she's just now realizing this.

It's totally understandable for you not to be able to be friends with her right now. You need a little time to grieve the relationship. You've been hurt, and you have every right to feel hurt right now. But don't wallow in it and stay hurt. This wound can heal over time. In fact, you don't have to be friends with her in the future if you don't feel like it. You just have to love her as a fellow Christian and not nurse any grudges against her.

Use this time to seek God. Get his direction about your future relationships because his counsel is far superior to anyone's counsel here. He loves you and wants to heal your heart.

Good luck to you.

Wow...that was great.

That's some of the best advice anyone's given to me this whole time. That part about falling in love with "love." I was thinking that but I just didn't know how to say it. Great advice and I will definetly take yours and John's to heart. God Bless you both!
 
Upvote 0

Breetai

For I am not ashamed of the Gospel...
Dec 3, 2003
13,939
396
✟38,820.00
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
I don't think that I can give nearly as good advice as the other two posters did at this point. I will say this: I had gone through something very similar with a girl right before exams last Nov/Dec 2003. I thought that I could stay friends with her and maybe then we would get back into a relationship. I found it impossible to remain friends with her and I don't even talk to her any longer. She has become dead to me. I hope that it works out better for you, but I just thought I'd share my story quickly with you. At least you'll know that your not alone.

I don't know why girls do this kind of stupid stuff, and it seems like girls do it way more then guys do. It's idiotic and it makes me mad.

You're in my prayers.
 
Upvote 0

n3w3xp

Active Member
Jan 28, 2004
33
0
West Coast
✟143.00
Faith
Protestant
trying so hard,
I completely agree with jenptcfan... people in love with being in love rather than falling in love with that person. I still haven't found the "solution" to fixing a situation like yours. What's best or right to do? Get over the ex, and get to know yourself and who you really are and what you are really wanting out of life; or try and hold on to that ex and work things out? Sometimes when we move that ex out of our life and we focus on who we are as a person, that can possibly be the person that you were actually in love with. Then by the time that is realized, it may be too late... so that's why I think it depends on what you want in the long run. Wanting to keep a relationship that is already iffy, or risk letting go of it?... (just thoughts I get confused about sometimes too).
 
Upvote 0