New video of Renee Good shooting surfaces from ICE agent’s perspective

Michie · Jan 9, 2026

New cellphone footage of the shooting death of Renee Nicole Good has surfaced, with Vice President JD Vance arguing that it vindicates the actions of the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent who shot her.

Good was shot and killed on Wednesday in Minneapolis by an unnamed ICE agent while she was in her vehicle, positioned sideways, blocking the road ICE agents were traveling on. While federal authorities have argued that the shooting was self-defense, critics contend that the act was unjustified and tantamount to murder.

A 47-second-long video, acquired by Alpha News and posted to X on Friday, shows the incident from the perspective of the ICE agent who fired the shots at Good.

Continued below.

New video of Renee Good shooting surfaces from ICE agent’s perspective

New cellphone footage of the shooting death of Renee Nicole Good has surfaced, with Vice President JD Vance arguing that it vindicates the actions of the U S Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent

www.christianpost.com

Elongated · Jan 10, 2026

Michie said:
New cellphone footage of the shooting death of Renee Nicole Good has surfaced, with Vice President JD Vance arguing that it vindicates the actions of the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent who shot her.

Good was shot and killed on Wednesday in Minneapolis by an unnamed ICE agent while she was in her vehicle, positioned sideways, blocking the road ICE agents were traveling on. While federal authorities have argued that the shooting was self-defense, critics contend that the act was unjustified and tantamount to murder.

A 47-second-long video, acquired by Alpha News and posted to X on Friday, shows the incident from the perspective of the ICE agent who fired the shots at Good.

Continued below.

New video of Renee Good shooting surfaces from ICE agent’s perspective

New cellphone footage of the shooting death of Renee Nicole Good has surfaced, with Vice President JD Vance arguing that it vindicates the actions of the U S Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent

www.christianpost.com

FWIW, it’s a case where the state and feds have an interest. If possible an independent investigation is desirable.

Helmut-WK · Jan 13, 2026

Michie said:
A 47-second-long video, acquired by Alpha News and posted to X on Friday, shows the incident from the perspective of the ICE agent who fired the shots at Good.

Continued below.

New video of Renee Good shooting surfaces from ICE agent’s perspective

New cellphone footage of the shooting death of Renee Nicole Good has surfaced, with Vice President JD Vance arguing that it vindicates the actions of the U S Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent

www.christianpost.com

It confirms what can be seen on other videos:

Several agents near the car, on in front of it. If Mrs. Good had intended to drive over him, she just needed to drive forward.
Instead, the drove backward, the turned the gear and went right of Him. At the very moment he was beside the car, he shot her.

The video may be used to argue that the ICE agent thought he should defend himself, but carefully looked upon (and compared to other videos) it confirms he was in no real danger.

iarwain · Monday at 12:01 PM

Helmut-WK said:
Several agents near the car, on in front of it. If Mrs. Good had intended to drive over him, she just needed to drive forward.
Instead, the drove backward, the turned the gear and went right of Him. At the very moment he was beside the car, he shot her.

If you look at all the videos, she clearly hits him with the car. Whatever she was trying to do, there's no doubt she actually struck him. The agent immediately fires on her, and by that time he is to the right of the car. It all happens very fast, almost in one motion. You're not allowed to ram a law enforcement officer with a car. A car is a deadly weapon, and that is legal justification for the shooting, like it or not.

Helmut-WK · 2026-01-21T10:53:44-0600

iarwain said:
If you look at all the videos, she clearly hits him with the car. Whatever she was trying to do, there's no doubt she actually struck him. The agent immediately fires on her, and by that time he is to the right of the car. It all happens very fast, almost in one motion. You're not allowed to ram a law enforcement officer with a car. A car is a deadly weapon, and that is legal justification for the shooting, like it or not.

Show me a video where I can clearly see that she hit him.

iarwain · 2026-01-21T16:40:17-0600

Helmut-WK said:
Show me a video where I can clearly see that she hit him.

I think this front view most clearly shows it. But some people will never see it. Show me a video that shows she clearly did not hit him, since the ICE agent is being accused of murder. The burden of proof is on the prosecution.

Yarddog · 2026-01-21T19:53:02-0600

iarwain said:
I think this front view most clearly shows it. But some people will never see it. Show me a video that shows she clearly did not hit him, since the ICE agent is being accused of murder. The burden of proof is on the prosecution.

There are videos in other threads, on this subject, which clearly show that she did not hit the officer. The officer switches the phone drone his right hand to his left hand. He then reaches out and strikes her hood with that hand, which allows him to keep his lower body away from her car.

BPPLEE · 2026-01-21T20:11:14-0600

Yarddog said:
There are videos in other threads, on this subject, which clearly show that she did not hit the officer. The officer switches the phone drone his right hand to his left hand. He then reaches out and strikes her hood with that hand, which allows him to keep his lower body away from her car.

It's not clear. The ICE agent may have been in the wrong but the videos are inconclusive. It's not clear if Good hit him or not. People are seeing what they want to see

Yarddog · 2026-01-21T20:23:32-0600

BPPLEE said:
It's not clear.

It's clear.

BPPLEE said:
The ICE agent may have been in the wrong but the videos are inconclusive.

I'm not saying that he was in the wrong. He just didn't get hit by her vehicle. The first shot would still be justified because it depends on what he was thinking. If he thought she was trying to hit him, courts would grant him qualified immunity.

BPPLEE said:
It's not clear if Good hit him or not. People are seeing what they want to see

No, you are seeing what you want to see. Videos from two different angles were synchronized to show what the other didn't clearly show. When synchronized, they show exactly where his body and legs were at at all times.

The left hand, with the phone in it, does make contact and the sound is heard in the video.

BPPLEE · 2026-01-21T20:31:46-0600

Yarddog said:
It's clear.

I'm not saying that he was in the wrong. He just didn't get hit by her vehicle. The first shot would still be justified because it depends on what he was thinking. If he thought she was trying to hit him, courts would grant him qualified immunity.

No, you are seeing what you want to see. Videos from two different angles were synchronized to show what the other didn't clearly show. When synchronized, they show exactly where his body and legs were at at all times.

The left hand, with the phone in it, does make contact and the sound is heard in the video.

I've seen the synchronized videos and they're inconclusive.
I agree with the rest of your post

BobRyan · 2026-01-21T21:59:28-0600

Helmut-WK said:
It confirms what can be seen on other videos:

Several agents near the car, on in front of it. If Mrs. Good had intended to drive over him, she just needed to drive forward.
Instead, the drove backward, the turned the gear and went right of Him. At the very moment he was beside the car, he shot her.

So then she did not strike him with her car ???

Helmut-WK said:
The video may be used to argue that the ICE agent thought he should defend himself, but carefully looked upon (and compared to other videos) it confirms he was in no real danger.

No real danger other than the internal injuries he suffered when she rammed him

ICE agent struck by Renee Good's vehicle suffered internal bleeding to torso, DHS says

An ICE agent suffered internal bleeding to his torso after Renee Nicole Good's vehicle struck him during the Minneapolis shooting last week, an official said.

www.foxnews.com

]

iarwain · 2026-01-22T12:08:14-0600

Yarddog said:
There are videos in other threads, on this subject, which clearly show that she did not hit the officer.

I have certainly not seen any video that clearly shows that she did not hit him. If you have one, post it.

Yarddog · 2026-01-22T12:37:17-0600

iarwain said:
I have certainly not seen any video that clearly shows that she did not hit him. If you have one, post it.

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/15/video/ice-shooting-renee-good-minneapolis-videos.html?unlocked_article_code=1.E1A.XmvD.bLhtJs_blkOu&smid=url-share

BPPLEE · 2026-01-22T12:49:36-0600

Yarddog said:
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/15/video/ice-shooting-renee-good-minneapolis-videos.html?unlocked_article_code=1.E1A.XmvD.bLhtJs_blkOu&smid=url-share

That just shows that he didn't get run over. It doesn't prove that he wasn't struck by the vehicle.
They even conceded that they couldn't tell

iarwain · 2026-01-22T13:33:44-0600

Yarddog said:
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/15/video/ice-shooting-renee-good-minneapolis-videos.html?unlocked_article_code=1.E1A.XmvD.bLhtJs_blkOu&smid=url-share

The narrator in that video actually says that you cannot tell if she struck him or not.

By the way, I have heard that the reason he was filming with his cellphone was because he had not yet been issued a bodycam.
Also, the reason the gun was drawn was because at that point Good was being placed under arrest for obstructing law enforcement. Besides which, it's illegal to block traffic.
The agent shouldn't have been in front of the car, but that doesn't give her permission to run into him. When you are behind the wheel, you are responsible.

Yarddog · 2026-01-22T13:41:45-0600

BPPLEE said:
That just shows that he didn't get run over. It doesn't prove that he wasn't struck by the vehicle.
They even conceded that they couldn't tell

The video shows that the sound, which the DOJ claimed to prove that he was run over was actually Ross reaching out with his left hand and placing it on the vehicle. Did the vehicle strike him as it moved away, probably, but that doesn't change anything that I've said.

I've said that the first shot was justified, though we don't know what Ross was thinking. The case can be made that he feared for his life.

What I've also said is that the 2nd and 3rd shots probably are not justified, because they came as the vehicle was pulling away from him and he stuck his gun in the open window. The 2nd shot aimed at an angle matching the head shot and the 3rd shot at a lower angle matching the wounds on her side.

Yarddog · 2026-01-22T13:45:31-0600

iarwain said:
The narrator in that video actually says that you cannot tell if she struck him or not.

By the way, I have heard that the reason he was filming with his cellphone was because he had not yet been issued a bodycam.
Also, the reason the gun was drawn was because at that point Good was being placed under arrest for obstructing law enforcement. Besides which, it's illegal to block traffic.
The agent shouldn't have been in front of the car, but that doesn't give her permission to run into him. When you are behind the wheel, you are responsible.

Nothing in any of the videos reveal ICE officers placing Good under arrest. Screaming get out of the car does not place motorist under arrest. She was not told that she was being detained or under arrest.

BPPLEE · 2026-01-22T13:55:58-0600

Yarddog said:
The video shows that the sound, which the DOJ claimed to prove that he was run over was actually Ross reaching out with his left hand and placing it on the vehicle. Did the vehicle strike him as it moved away, probably, but that doesn't change anything that I've said.

I've said that the first shot was justified, though we don't know what Ross was thinking. The case can be made that he feared for his life.

What I've also said is that the 2nd and 3rd shots probably are not justified, because they came as the vehicle was pulling away from him and he stuck his gun in the open window. The 2nd shot aimed at an angle matching the head shot and the 3rd shot at a lower angle matching the wounds on her side.

I thought it had been determined that Good had been shot twice in the torso and once in the arm.
If the agent fired in the open window of the vehicle while he was on the side of the vehicle, no, that is not justified unless there was someone else in front of the vehicle.
I thought that earlier you were claiming that the vehicle did not make contact with the agent.
I say that can't be determined from the available video but it does look like the vehicle struck him.
Obviously he was not run over, Trump says many things that I wouldn't try to defend but I said it looks like the agent was struck by the vehicle, he definitely was not run over

iarwain · 2026-01-22T14:17:12-0600

Yarddog said:
Nothing in any of the videos reveal ICE officers placing Good under arrest. Screaming get out of the car does not place motorist under arrest. She was not told that she was being detained or under arrest.

Nevertheless, she was being arrested. That's why she was trying to flee.

BPPLEE · 2026-01-22T14:19:13-0600

iarwain said:
Nevertheless, she was being arrested. That's why she was trying to flee.

"Get out of the car" is a lawful order under the circumstances

We hope the site problems here are now solved, however, if you still have any issues, please start a ticket in Contact Us

New video of Renee Good shooting surfaces from ICE agent’s perspective

Well-Known Member

Member

Member

Newbie

Member

Newbie

Senior Contributor

Well-Known Member

Senior Contributor

Well-Known Member

Junior Member

Newbie

Senior Contributor

Well-Known Member

Newbie

Senior Contributor

Senior Contributor

Well-Known Member

Newbie

Well-Known Member

Similar threads