The Antique Expert
This story took place in France.
On a cold winter night, in the quiet glow of the family library, Pierre Meyer sat beside his grandfather. Outside, frost clung to the windows, and the wind whispered through the shutters, but inside, the fire crackled softly. They were talking about their family history since their ancestors' conversion to Christianity. Then the conversation drifted to their lost heirloom clock.
“The clock,” the grandfather said. “Our clock—they took it from us years ago. It was an imperial commission, made in Alsace, 1881. Don’t let it disappear, Pierre. Promise me...”
“Yes, yes, I promise you, grandpa. Don’t worry.”
That night, Pierre could hardly sleep. The next day, he hired Dr Jean, an antique expert and historian known for his unwavering self‑confidence. Dr Jean placed an ad in a local Alsatian daily. A week later, a man named Monsieur Girard called from a cottage in the valley, claiming to have the piece.
When Pierre and Dr Jean arrived, Pierre was captivated by the clock, which could also play music.
“The clock is magnificent,” Pierre whispered. “The case looks old but still charming… it’s exactly what grandpa described.”
“Hold on... Look at the text, Pierre,” Dr Jean said. “It’s in French.”
“So what? It's not surprising.”
“Didn’t you know Alsace* was annexed by Germany in 1871? An imperial commission in 1881 would have been engraved in German, not French..."
Dr Jean continued: "And the grammar—there is a gender mismatch. No imperial engraver would make such a mistake. It’s a half-forgery... But the music doesn’t prove it’s a forgery---I think it’s a piece of 19th-century music.”
Pierre shook his head. “No, no, it’s an early 20th-century folk music from Lorraine.”
Dr Jean’s eyes lit up. “Another proof that it’s a forgery!”
As Girard ushered them out, Dr Jean noticed a faint scratch inside the case where the wood had been filed. Two letters: LW.
The next morning, they visited the National Clock Association registry.
“Ah, yes,” the clerk said. “Only one LW. Luc Wattrelot. Prestigious restorer. A true scholar.”
Dr Jean brightened. “Finally, a lead.”
They arrived at Luc Wattrelot’s home, but his wife told them he had gone overseas.
* Alsace belongs to France today, but was annexed by Germany in 1871.