“Every theater’s like, ‘No. We don’t feel like we have the audience for this movie,”
That makes sense, this is a very niche movie from the sounds of it from a virtual unknown, and is a dramatization featuring a bunch of actors nobody has ever heard of, and theater franchise owners do have a "gotta put butts in the seats" business model they have to adhere to.
For whatever it's worth, Matt Walsh's 2024 movie "Am I racist?" (Walsh is a well-known controversial figure in right-wing mediasphere) was in over 1500 theaters nationwide and made $12 million on a $3 million budget. So if those individual theaters had owners/managers that had an blanket anti-conservative bias, they would've quickly refused to carry his movie.
Point of reference, theaters are increasingly leveraging social media interaction and YouTube trailer stat metrics in gauging potential audience interest and box office performance forecasting.
This "Pardon Me" movie she's making...
The official YouTube account for it has only 440 subscribers, and has only had a total of 8000 views and 22 comments (ouch lol...I'm pretty sure I've posted .net Core tutorial/review videos that have racked up bigger numbers for views and comments...and those are boring screenshare videos showing me making simple example applications)
Whereas, Walsh's movie:
If her "Pardon Me" movie was drawing the same kind of social media interest as Walsh's movie, they would've been just as happy to carry her right-leaning movie the same way they were happy to carry Walsh's movie.
tl/dr version: "Money talks"
“It just drops on me — Boom! Use the churches!” she said. “There’s more churches in America than there will ever be theaters.”
This would be, quite literally, preaching to the converted.