[Catholic Forum] Contraceptives and Me

HoneyBee

Prodigal Daughter
Site Supporter
Feb 19, 2017
610
1,222
West Coast
✟198,853.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Republican
You know, sometimes I make some really stupid decisions within my own life. This might be one of them, but I'm not in it for the wrong reasons, I can promise you that.

About a month ago, I decided to go see my gynecologist about getting medicine for my Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome (PCOS). Up to this point, I had been steadily gaining more and more weight, and I thought that maybe it was all because my hormones weren't working as they should. I thought that maybe taking "the pill" would help me, but I'm honestly not so sure.

I remember when I was first diagnosed with PCOS. The gynecologist who saw me was pressuring me to take the pill and I adamantly refused to take it, knowing it would be like a band-aid solution to a problem that had a deeper root. She tried guilting me into taking it, saying that if I don't want to have kids in a few years, then it would be fine for me not to take it. She knew just how important it meant to me to be able to have children someday, and I feel like she was just using that to get me to take the pill. It really messed with my head and made me feel like I was doing something wrong or counter-productive by not taking it.

About a month ago, I caved in and decided I'd try taking the pill to see if it would help with my health issues. At first, it felt a little exciting embarking on this journey with a new medication, and yet... something felt really off about all of this. It felt like I had just admitted defeat by taking these pills, and not only that, but there was some real guilt that I started to feel too. The pills, themselves, began to make my body ache in certain places and may have made my current depressive episode even worse.

Right now I'm on the "sugar pill" section of my packet, and I couldn't feel more relieved at this point to be on them. I wasn't in as much pain today and it feels like now I'm leaving my poor body alone and not overloading it with pills that it might not really need. This should be a clear indication that maybe I shouldn't be taking these pills after all, but part of me is stubborn. Part of me wonders if maybe I should stick this out for two more months (which is when my next appointment is) before quitting or if I should just stop the pills cold-turkey and never look back.

All the while, I have been desperately looking online for things to talk me out of taking the pill. I'm trying to look for really negative things that would make me not want to take the pills, but it all just seems like general risk sorts of things. I want a reason to stop. I don't like this medication. It doesn't feel normal or natural, and it makes me feel like I quit on my body. It makes me feel broken and ashamed that I wanted to start taking these stupid pills in the first place. I know I was doing it for medical reasons, but I still feel so shameful, like I committed a nasty sort of sin. I can hardly even bear to talk to God about it at this point. I feel like He's be too ashamed of me to even listen, but I'm sure that's just me projecting my insecurities onto God. There's a lot that God can handle, and I don't think some itty bitty pill is going to be enough to ward Him away.

I just really needed to say this somewhere where other Catholic folks could hear me. It feels very lonely taking this sort of medication with no one close to me knowing about it (they'd be so judgmental and ashamed of me). It's like a dirty secret that I've been keeping, and I don't want to have to keep that secret anymore.
 

Stabat Mater dolorosa

Jesus Christ today, yesterday and forever!
Site Supporter
Jun 18, 2014
17,708
8,068
Somewhere up North
✟294,001.00
Country
Norway
Faith
Traditional. Cath.
Marital Status
Single
Relax sweetheart :) taking the pill for medical reasons is not sinful at all. Please remember that Christ saved the bandit next to him at the cross. He had (most likely) killed people and/or commited great theft while he was an active criminal (the romans didn't crucify people without good reasons, except from Christ which Pontius pilate tried to free).

God understands your motivation for taking the pill. Its not as if you're engaging in improper sexual acticity and tries to get out of pregnancy by taking the pill. It's fine to take the pill to relieve yourself of pain. Its actually medicine when used like that.

Christ came to heal sinners. You're a sinner and so am I. We need our doctor to be healed. Dont worry! Pray to God and leave your soul in his hands. He's merciful beyond our imagination! He's not like us wicked humans, he's not aiming to take you down, the great accuser is. Trust in him, love him and adore him becuase he loves you!

Bless your heart dear sister.
 
Upvote 0

Gnarwhal

☩ Broman Catholic ☩
Oct 31, 2008
20,398
12,089
37
N/A
✟434,190.00
Country
United States
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Libertarian
She knew just how important it meant to me to be able to have children someday, and I feel like she was just using that to get me to take the pill.

I feel like there's some serious irony in her actions right here...

About a month ago, I caved in and decided I'd try taking the pill to see if it would help with my health issues. At first, it felt a little exciting embarking on this journey with a new medication, and yet... something felt really off about all of this ... The pills, themselves, began to make my body ache in certain places and may have made my current depressive episode even worse.

I've heard of this before. My ex-wife never wanted to go on the pill (we weren't Catholic then; she still isn't) because her sister had some similarly adverse reactions to it. I think some people's physiology are just sensitive to hormonal doses like that. Even subtle ones.

It felt like I had just admitted defeat by taking these pills, and not only that, but there was some real guilt that I started to feel too.

I'll preface this by saying I'm not a priest, canon lawyer, or a family planning expert, but from what I've gathered from reading other's advice over the years is that simply taking the pill for medical purposes and not contracepting isn't a sin, just like @Stabat said above. Now if you were married and you and your husband were engaging in the conjugal act while you were taking the pill, that would be a problem but that doesn't look to be the case here.

That said, if you don't feel good while you're taking it then perhaps you should stop and talk to your doctor about it. Maybe there are some alternatives. I dated a girl briefly several years ago who also had PCOS and took the pill as part of her treatment, as it were. It wasn't a perfect solution though, so if you have other options then it might be worth exploring them.
 
Upvote 0

narnia59

Regular Member
Site Supporter
Jul 17, 2007
5,751
1,265
✟332,411.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Married
You know, sometimes I make some really stupid decisions within my own life. This might be one of them, but I'm not in it for the wrong reasons, I can promise you that.

About a month ago, I decided to go see my gynecologist about getting medicine for my Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome (PCOS). Up to this point, I had been steadily gaining more and more weight, and I thought that maybe it was all because my hormones weren't working as they should. I thought that maybe taking "the pill" would help me, but I'm honestly not so sure.

I remember when I was first diagnosed with PCOS. The gynecologist who saw me was pressuring me to take the pill and I adamantly refused to take it, knowing it would be like a band-aid solution to a problem that had a deeper root. She tried guilting me into taking it, saying that if I don't want to have kids in a few years, then it would be fine for me not to take it. She knew just how important it meant to me to be able to have children someday, and I feel like she was just using that to get me to take the pill. It really messed with my head and made me feel like I was doing something wrong or counter-productive by not taking it.

About a month ago, I caved in and decided I'd try taking the pill to see if it would help with my health issues. At first, it felt a little exciting embarking on this journey with a new medication, and yet... something felt really off about all of this. It felt like I had just admitted defeat by taking these pills, and not only that, but there was some real guilt that I started to feel too. The pills, themselves, began to make my body ache in certain places and may have made my current depressive episode even worse.

Right now I'm on the "sugar pill" section of my packet, and I couldn't feel more relieved at this point to be on them. I wasn't in as much pain today and it feels like now I'm leaving my poor body alone and not overloading it with pills that it might not really need. This should be a clear indication that maybe I shouldn't be taking these pills after all, but part of me is stubborn. Part of me wonders if maybe I should stick this out for two more months (which is when my next appointment is) before quitting or if I should just stop the pills cold-turkey and never look back.

All the while, I have been desperately looking online for things to talk me out of taking the pill. I'm trying to look for really negative things that would make me not want to take the pills, but it all just seems like general risk sorts of things. I want a reason to stop. I don't like this medication. It doesn't feel normal or natural, and it makes me feel like I quit on my body. It makes me feel broken and ashamed that I wanted to start taking these stupid pills in the first place. I know I was doing it for medical reasons, but I still feel so shameful, like I committed a nasty sort of sin. I can hardly even bear to talk to God about it at this point. I feel like He's be too ashamed of me to even listen, but I'm sure that's just me projecting my insecurities onto God. There's a lot that God can handle, and I don't think some itty bitty pill is going to be enough to ward Him away.

I just really needed to say this somewhere where other Catholic folks could hear me. It feels very lonely taking this sort of medication with no one close to me knowing about it (they'd be so judgmental and ashamed of me). It's like a dirty secret that I've been keeping, and I don't want to have to keep that secret anymore.
If you are not familiar with Napro Technology, you may want to give it a look. I know they dig for deeper causes -- sometimes the Pill is just prescribed to help mask symptoms and doesn't address the underlying problem.

I agree with others, it's not wrong to use the Pill for medical reasons. But sometimes if all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.....

NaProTECHNOLOGY— A Major Breakthrough In Monitoring and Maintaining a Woman's Reproductive and Gynecological Health
 
Upvote 0