Questions on joining the UMC.

Apr 19, 2017
7
0
Independence , Mississippi
✟16,651.00
Country
United States
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Libertarian
Hello from a fellow Christian. I have a question joining the United Methodist Church. What would be a barrier to membership in the UMC ? The reason for my question is I have gotten my mom back into church and it's at a UMC near my house. We can walk to it . But anyway I like it and I like some of the Methodist beliefs but I disagree with somethings with the UMC. But in my opinion it's just secondary stuff. The main reason I don't join with is the Methodist view of the Eucharist/Holy Communion/ or Lord's supper. I hold to the belief that it is a vary intimate remembrance of what Jesus did for us and that we proclaim his death till he comes. I respect the methodist understanding and don't seek to fight over it. It's about the only disagreement I have but I think it's ok. I wouldn't be so dogmatic on the matter. I just don't want to cause problems and I like her (my mom) new church( I feel a family connection there ;) ). Just want to learn more and dialogue with fellow Christians.

In Christian love and from fried Chicken eating Southern baptist,

Aron or Wayfaring Cowboy
 

Big Drew

Believer
Site Supporter
Nov 10, 2009
1,883
541
Alabama
✟74,961.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Libertarian
I'm not a member of the UMC, though I did attend a church for a couple of years. The only thing that kept us from joining was a lack of activities for our kids to be involved in, in this particular church. My understanding is that the issue of the Eucharist is left up to interpretation in the UMC...the denomination has its stance that it's a Great Mystery (I believe that's the term) but they don't take a hardline approach like the Catholics do. This is why they allow for open communion, whosoever will, may come. Maybe if one were clergy they would have to agree completely, but not a layperson.

There's a few members of UMC clergy on here that will correct me if I'm wrong, but I think I have it right.
 
Upvote 0

Albion

Facilitator
Dec 8, 2004
111,138
33,258
✟583,842.00
Country
United States
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Married
Hello from a fellow Christian. I have a question joining the United Methodist Church. What would be a barrier to membership in the UMC ? The reason for my question is I have gotten my mom back into church and it's at a UMC near my house. We can walk to it . But anyway I like it and I like some of the Methodist beliefs but I disagree with somethings with the UMC. But in my opinion it's just secondary stuff. The main reason I don't join with is the Methodist view of the Eucharist/Holy Communion/ or Lord's supper. I hold to the belief that it is a vary intimate remembrance of what Jesus did for us and that we proclaim his death till he comes. I respect the methodist understanding and don't seek to fight over it. It's about the only disagreement I have but I think it's ok. I wouldn't be so dogmatic on the matter. I just don't want to cause problems and I like her (my mom) new church( I feel a family connection there ;) ). Just want to learn more and dialogue with fellow Christians.

In Christian love and from fried Chicken eating Southern baptist,

Aron or Wayfaring Cowboy
We have at least two ordained UMC ministers here on CF--Rev Wayne and circuitrider--so you might choose to ask them directly.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

circuitrider

United Methodist
Site Supporter
Sep 1, 2013
2,071
391
Iowa
✟102,534.00
Country
United States
Faith
Methodist
Marital Status
Private
If you have questions about United Methodism, I'll be happy to answer them as best I can.

Yes, we do believe that communion is a sacrament. But if you don't exactly believe that, that isn't a barrier to you being a lay member of the church. You probably couldn't be ordained if you did support the UM view of the sacraments. But it likely would be a barrier to membership.
 
Upvote 0

Raphael Jauregui

Episcopalian, liberal Anglican, Mdiv
May 3, 2017
574
376
Mesa
✟28,598.00
Country
United States
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Legal Union (Other)
Politics
US-Democrat
Hello from a fellow Christian. I have a question joining the United Methodist Church. What would be a barrier to membership in the UMC ? The reason for my question is I have gotten my mom back into church and it's at a UMC near my house. We can walk to it . But anyway I like it and I like some of the Methodist beliefs but I disagree with somethings with the UMC. But in my opinion it's just secondary stuff. The main reason I don't join with is the Methodist view of the Eucharist/Holy Communion/ or Lord's supper. I hold to the belief that it is a vary intimate remembrance of what Jesus did for us and that we proclaim his death till he comes. I respect the methodist understanding and don't seek to fight over it. It's about the only disagreement I have but I think it's ok. I wouldn't be so dogmatic on the matter. I just don't want to cause problems and I like her (my mom) new church( I feel a family connection there ;) ). Just want to learn more and dialogue with fellow Christians.

In Christian love and from fried Chicken eating Southern baptist,

Aron or Wayfaring Cowboy
Thank you for sharing your story! I had a similar experience, although from the opposite end of the spectrum, when I became an associate member of the UMC. My partner and I, and other family, summer in the mountains and, by our home there, there is no Episcopal church or Lutheran church. So, the only mainline Protestant church in the area is a UMC congregation. As Anglicans, we have the view that the body and blood of Christ is really present in Communion while the Methodists have a somewhat less 'high church' view. Even though that is a difference, we love it up there! The services are nice and I love the hymnal.
 
Upvote 0

circuitrider

United Methodist
Site Supporter
Sep 1, 2013
2,071
391
Iowa
✟102,534.00
Country
United States
Faith
Methodist
Marital Status
Private
Rachael, actually the official view of the sacrament of communion is the same between the UMC and the Episcopal Church. We both officially believe in the real presence of Christ at the table. Unfotuanately not all United Methodists express that well.
 
Upvote 0

RomansFiveEight

A Recovering Fundamentalist
Feb 18, 2014
696
174
✟9,665.00
Faith
United Methodist
Marital Status
Private
How would you answer the following questions?

Do you renounce the spiritual forces of wickedness,
reject the evil powers of this world,
and repent of your sin?


Do you accept the freedom and power God gives you
to resist evil, injustice, and oppression
in whatever forms they present themselves?

Do you confess Jesus Christ as your Savior,
put your whole trust in his grace,
and promise to serve him as your Lord,
in union with the Church which Christ has opened
to people of all ages, nations, and races?



How about the following two?

As members of Christ's universal Church,
will you be loyal to Christ through The United Methodist Church,
and do all in your power to strengthen its ministries?

As members of this congregation,
will you faithfully participate in its ministries
by your prayers, your presence,
your gifts, your service
and your witness?


If you can answer "I do" to the first three, and "I will" to the last two, and have been baptized or are willing to be Baptized. (If you've been Baptized before, we won't re-baptize you, so long as you were Baptized in the name of the triune God), then you can be a member of a United Methodist Congregation. These come from "The Baptismal Covenant", which is our official liturgy regarding reception into the United Methodist Church. When a child is Baptized, those questions are asked of that child's Parents or Guardians. Baptized children are not considered 'professing members', but are 'Baptized Members'. They're Baptized into the church with the promise that they'll be raised in and grow in their Christian faith. When they're older, they'll go through 'confirmation classes', growing deeper in their faith, and will become 'professing members', and those very same questions that were once asked of their parents will be asked of them. In your case, as an adult, they'll be asked directly of you.

SOME Churches will require new membership classes or some sort of education prior to those questions being asked. But ultimately, those are the questions being asked.

Membership is solely the responsibility and authority of the appointed Senior Pastor in the United Methodist Church, there is no congregation wide vote; for example. So largely, meeting with the Pastor is how you'll determine exactly what you need to do. Doctrinally, however, that's all you need to 'affirm'.

Where your beliefs go beyond those basic, foundational questions determine, perhaps, the level to which you can serve the church. I once had someone share a desire to teach Confirmation, but whose beliefs staunchly differed with the United Methodist Church, being opposed to the Episcopacy (Bishops), the appointment system, viewed sacraments as 'symbols' among other things. They were more than welcome to be a member of the church. Unfortunately, teaching Confirmation would be off the table. As my colleague, @circuitrider pointed out, the qualifications for becoming a Pastor in the UMC are far stricter and while even THEY don't require complete and total affirmation of the Book of Discipline (though must comply with it, but we don't prohibit clergy from stating a belief that they disagree with part of it. Within reason), there's a great deal more continuity with the UMC that's required there.

I'm curious about your statement with the sacraments, could you say more? The United Methodist Church affirms a "Real Presence" doctrine, and affirms Holy Communion to be a Sacrament. Unlike our Baptist Brothers and Sisters, and some other Evangelical and Charismatic churches, who view Communion as an Ordinance or a Symbol. We are, essentially, Anglican/Episcopal in our view of Holy Communion.

A closing thought: Why do you want to be a Member? Being a non-member doesn't preclude you from any part of the life of the church. In fact, you can even serve on certain committees as a non-member. If you're unsure about membership, don't sweat it. Continue to worship, participate in the life of the church, et al. You don't need to be a member in the UMC. In fact, though culturally it's changed, Methodism has historically been a denomination where only the congregations leaders and most faithful were members. There is no expectation that everyone who attends regularly become members.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: tampasteve
Upvote 0