Misconceptions people have about the Catholic faith...

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rising_Suns

'Christ's desolate heart is in need of comfort'
Jul 14, 2002
10,836
793
44
Saint Louis, MO
✟24,335.00
Faith
Catholic
Ok guys, I want you to list anything that you can think of that is not understood by the masses...anything that people have the wrong idea about with regards to the Catholic faith..

please make your statement and answer short and sweet.

If you have a concern about the Catholic faith, just post it and someone will try and help you out.

This thread is meant to clear things up for people who may have been misguided in a few areas. Please refrain from arguing or debating too much, or writing lengthy threads.

Thanks!
 
The issues listed are just listed.  Could we have some explanation i.e. the misconception about each and the truth of each?  My question:  How are you saved? 

This is a helpful thread.  I go by the official positions of the Church.  However, maybe not all Roman Catholics do.  Thanks for the help in understanding.
 
Upvote 0

Wolseley

Beaucoup-Diên-Cai-Dāu
Feb 5, 2002
21,131
5,623
63
By the shores of Gitchee-Goomee
✟276,838.00
Country
United States
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
Purgatory is a second chance at salvation

There have been Popes who taught error/heresy

The Catholic Church slaughtered 99,999,750,263 proto-Protestant "Bible believers" during the Middle Ages

The Catholic Church kept the Bible from the people in the Middle Ages, either by locking it up or keeping it entirely in Latin

Catholic worship was copied from ancient Babylonian sun worship

You have to pay a priest to pray for you

Catholics worship Mary

Catholics worship saints

Catholics worship statues

Gimme some time, I'll think of some more. I've heard 'em all. :)
 
Upvote 0

Rising_Suns

'Christ's desolate heart is in need of comfort'
Jul 14, 2002
10,836
793
44
Saint Louis, MO
✟24,335.00
Faith
Catholic
Ok, here's a little cut and paste action:

2. Why do Catholics believe that their church is the one true Church?

Catholics believe that theirs is the one true Church of Jesus Christ because theirs is the only Christian Church that goes back in history to its founder, Jesus Christ.

3. Why are Catholics so devoted to Mary?

Catholics are fully aware that Mary was human and therefore not entitled to the honors reserved to God alone. What many non-Catholics mistake for adoration is a very profound love. As Christians, we are called to model Christ and his behavior, including his deep love and veneration for his mother. Catholics do feel that Mary is entitled to exaltation because, in choosing her as the mother of Jesus, God exalted her— more than any other person before or since. Catholics know that the glory they give Mary, they actually give to Jesus… just as Mary magnified God, not herself, when Elizabeth blessed her.


In elaboration to this paragraph, I want to note that we pray to Mary and the saints to ask them to pray for us, since we believe in the power of prayer. This is not to be confused with worship.

4. Why do Catholics believe the Pope is infallible?

Jesus appointed Peter the first Pope who would then select his descendent with the help of the Holy Spirit to help make that decision. The doctrine of papal infallibility does not mean the pope is always right in all his personal teachings. Catholics are aware that, despite his great learning, the pope is a human being and therefore liable to commit human error. The doctrine simply means that the Pope is divinely protected from error when, acting in his official capacity as chief of the Catholic fold, he makes a decision which is binding on the conscience of Catholics. In other words, his infallibility is limited to his specialty – the faith of Jesus Christ.

5. Why do Catholics believe Holy Communion is the actual body and blood of Jesus Christ? Why don’t they believe that Christ is only present symbolically?

Holy Communion is the actual body and blood of Jesus Christ because that is what Christ said, "This is my body…This is my blood" (Matt:26:26-28, Luke 22:19-10 and Mark 14:22-24). Jesus did not say it was a symbol. The grace and power of Christ that enables us to go out and do His work cannot be conferred from a symbol.

6. Why should I go to Mass every week?

The heart of our faith is a relationship of love with Jesus Christ. Going to Mass regularly is an expression of our love for Jesus, who gives to us 24/7. This love means we want to be nourished by his body and blood in the Eucharist and helps us keep His commandments. Although Saturday is the Sabbath for the Jews, the early Christians changed it to Sunday to commemorate Jesus’ rising from the dead on Sunday.

7. If God loves us, why do bad things happen?

God doesn’t cause accidents or tragedies. God allows things to happen because he has given us free will. He doesn’t control us. As people exercise that free will and make choices, there are consequences to their actions that can hurt us. God allows for the natural course of events to occur – he does not cause them, he simply permits them.

8. What is Purgatory?

Christians have always believed in the existence of a place between heaven and hell where souls go to be punished for lesser sins and to repay the debt for sins that have been forgiven. Purgatory is a place for the cleansing of the soul. Metaphorically, if you were working out and were dirty and came home to a surprise party, you would want to take a shower to cleanse yourself to be prepared to meet your guests. Because God is so perfect and we come to him with human sins, we need to prepare ourselves before meeting Him. Purgatory provides that cleansing before meeting God.

9. What is a sacrament?

A sacrament is an "outward sign instituted by Christ to give grace" (holiness) to the soul. That is, a divinely prescribed ceremony of the Church in which the words and action combine to form a sign of divine grace. We are a physical people and a spiritual people and a sacrament bridges our physical and spiritual sides. Christ is always present in sacraments. Even if you "don’t feel like being there" (as many people say about Reconciliation), you will always encounter Christ spiritually in sacraments. No matter how we feel, he is always there to meet us.

10. Why do Catholics confess their sins to priests?

Catholics confess their sins to God. The priest is there as a channel for Jesus’ grace and forgiveness. To the apostles, the first priests of His church, Christ said, "Whose sins you shall forgive, they are forgiven them; and whose sins you shall retain they are retained." (John 20:21-223). When Catholics confess their sins to a priest they are actually confessing their sins to God, for God hears their confessions and it is He who, in the final analysis, does the forgiving. The sacrament of reconciliation also gives us special graces, helping us to go on and not sin again. Verbally expressing sins is different than just thinking about them and in reconciliation, we can know we are forgiven.

11. Why can’t priests marry?

Celibacy is viewed as a better example and model of Jesus’ priesthood. Catholic priests are married to the church and its people. If they are married, they cannot give 100% of their attention to the church. Without these obligations, they are free to relocate as the church needs them, be more objective in counseling (eg, their own married problems will not be projected), require (and receive) only minimal salaries and they are examples of sacrifice and self-control.

12. Why is ordination to the priesthood reserved only to men?

The church’s teaching that only men can be ordained to the ministerial priesthood arises from identity to the example of the Lord as witnessed by the New Testament and to the constant tradition of the Eastern and Western churches. The church considers this constant t and universal tradition to be in accordance with God’s plan and to constitute a permanent norm. Jesus chose only men as members of the twelve. This example was followed in the apostolic community; and by means of a Tradition of practice, the church acquired a certainty about this norm. The issue of the possibility of ordaining women was first raised in the second century and has been raised and addressed by theologians down to the present day.

13. Why does the Catholic Church believe in abstaining from sex before marriage?

God created sexual intimacy and it is wonderful and the most intimate expression of human love. He chose the sexual act as the means by which humans (with an invaluable soul) are created. But when sex is used indiscriminately, it can be a source of diseases, unwed pregnancies, broken hearts, hardened hearts and low self-esteem. True love is based on sacrifice and fidelity. Self-control is one of the fruits of the Holy Spirit and we need to exercise self-control in our lives. If you are not faithful to God’s laws, what evidence is there that you can be faithful to each other? Is it really love if a couple is willing to put each other at risk for early pregnancy, devastating diseases and emotional stress? Sexual intimacy is a wonderful gift from God that needs to be part of a lifelong commitment that is blessed by God and open to having children.

14. Why does the Catholic Church oppose the use of artificial birth control?

The Catholic Church opposes any form of artificial birth control (Natural Family Planning is accepted) because it takes God out of the marital act. One of the most awesome gifts God gave us is the ability to generate new life in His image. We are co-creators of that process with Him. Contraception deliberately thwarts this God-given gift. Additionally, the birth control pill can cause spontaneous abortion, where a woman becomes pregnant and abort the baby without even knowing it has occurred. Natural Family Planning (NFP) is a morally acceptable means to avoid pregnancy by restricting sexual intercourse to the infertile times of a woman’s cycle. People who practice NFP feel especially blessed because they are doing God’s will and their relationship is never in the dark but exists in the light of God’s blessing. NFP is NOT the same as "rhythm" – it is far more scientific and proven more effective.

15. Why does the Catholic Church oppose abortion?

The Catholic Church views abortion as the taking of an innocent human life. A baby is a separate human life distinct from his or her mother. Each child has its own genetic identity, its own heartbeat, brain waves, eyes, ears, mouth, etc. Of course women have rights over their own bodies (just as men do), but these rights are limited when they affect other people’s bodies. Abortion directly involves two bodies – the mother’s and the unborn child’s.

16. What is the Catholic Church’s view on homosexuality?

Jesus loves everyone and everyone deserves love and respect. Jesus tells us to love the sinner but not the sin. The church does not say that a homosexual orientation is a sin, but the sexual activity is because sexual acts are intended by God for husbands and wives joined in the sacrament of marriage, not unmarried persons, whether the same or opposite sex.
 
Upvote 0

Rising_Suns

'Christ's desolate heart is in need of comfort'
Jul 14, 2002
10,836
793
44
Saint Louis, MO
✟24,335.00
Faith
Catholic
Here's some more: 

Catholics pray to statues and images

Absolutely false. It is true that Catholics may bow before a Crucifix or kneel before a statue and pray. But this is not reverencing the object! This is showing respect to the person represented. In the Eastern Catholic and Orthodox churches you see more of this in their respect for icons. Again, the icon is not revered, but the person represented.

Catholics participate in "]ain repetition" (Mt 6:7) in praying

This is an accusation made regarding the Rosary. In the Rosary there are sets of beads on which certain prayers are said. On the sets of ten beads (decades) the "Hail Mary" is said ("Hail Mary, full of grace. The Lord is with thee. Blessed art thou among women and blessed is the fruit of they womb, Jesus. Holy Mary, Mother of God, pray for us sinners now and at the hour of our death. Amen."). But these prayers are said while one contemplates one of fifteen mysteries in the lives of Mary and Jesus. The prayer is more a single prayer--a "contemplative prayer"--than a number of prayers said with no purpose. The repetition is background to the contemplation, which is Christ centered, even when it concerns Mary, His mother.

Catholics worship a "]ead Jesus" (author gets a tad emotional with this one :))

That is really what some say! This concept comes from the differences between the Catholic and Protestant churches regarding crosses. Catholics display the Crucifix and Protestants display the empty cross. A careful thought here resolves the issue. The Crucifix/cross is simply something we have in our churches to make us think. No one is worshipping these objects. That Catholics feel they are more touched by the truth of what Jesus did by having Crucifixes does not mean we think He's still there! Yes, we worship a risen Lord!

           Let us not be bogged down with issues such as crosses vs Crucifixes! No Christian believes that Christ stayed on the cross. I have heard Protestant preachers say, "We don't worship a dead Christ. Our Jesus isn't still on the cross." Obviously the object has nothing to do with the fact that Jesus died and rose again. In fact the empty cross can mean he was simply taken down dead. Didn't the thieves on the other two crosses also get taken down and empty crosses remained? One was saved and one not. Did these empty crosses show salvation or resurrection? Neither object shows resurrection! What we have is an empty tomb! And this is what proves we worship a risen Lord! This is a petty issue that we must overcome!
 
Upvote 0

Rising_Suns

'Christ's desolate heart is in need of comfort'
Jul 14, 2002
10,836
793
44
Saint Louis, MO
✟24,335.00
Faith
Catholic
Catholics think they can work their way to Heaven

No. If that were true why would Jesus have come to save us? No one can work their way to Heaven. (Eph 2:8-9) We are all stained with original sin. Faith in Jesus, baptism by water in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, and living a life true to Him are what Catholics believe lead us to Heaven. No, we do not believe in eternal security. Someone can make a sincere decision to accept Christ and change their mind later (Heb 12:25) . We think this is not salvation. In life we see salvation as an ongoing process. We have been saved from original sin by faith in Jesus who died and rose for us (Rom 10:9). We are being saved when we live a life true to His commands (John 15:10). And we will be saved when our bodies rise and we are glorified with Him on the last day (John 6:39).

 Catholics do not use the Bible alone for their authority

Actually, the authority of the Catholic Church is threefold: Scripture, Sacred Tradition, and the teaching Magesterium of the Church. They do not exist as separate entities that may contradict each other. The three are seen as forming a three-legged stool.

           As we know, a stool cannot stand on one or two legs. It can stand on three. But why a stool for an analogy? Well, any church, whether it accepts it or not, needs three things on which to stand. All use Scripture, so we agree there. And while Protestants say they have no Magesterium, they really do. Think of each denomination. Does it have seminaries? Does it have statements of faith? From where does this come? There are things that define each faith. Who says that is so? We know it's the leaders of that faith who are deciding how to interpret Scripture. So in fact, Protestants do have their own "magesterium".

           So Protestants have two legs on which they stand---Scripture, and the "Magesterium" of their denomination. But this stool doesn't stand on two legs. There is something that must be used to help interpret Scripture that is not used by Protestants, and that is the teachings of the Church fathers.

           Here is an example of why this is important. Our American government has it's "scripture", which is the Constitution. It also has it's "Magesterium" which interprets it, the Supreme Court. In the past, the Supreme Court referred to the writings of the founding fathers of our country to help them interpret the Constitution. This way they knew the intentions of those who wrote the document. When they stopped using the writings, we began having such laws as abortion on demand. Obviously this was not envisioned by the founding fathers.

           The Church fathers are like the founding fathers. They wrote of the Church of the early centuries. And this tells us much about what the Church was. Protestants, be forewarned! Many who read the Church fathers convert to Catholicism! You will find, if you read the fathers, that the early Church had masses, not services equivalent to today's Protestant services. (CCC 1345) Communion was believed to be the actual body and blood of Jesus.

           Those writings of the Church fathers help form the Tradition upon which Sacred Tradition is based. And this is that third leg of the stool. On these three our Church stands, and has stood for 2000 years.
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

Rising_Suns

'Christ's desolate heart is in need of comfort'
Jul 14, 2002
10,836
793
44
Saint Louis, MO
✟24,335.00
Faith
Catholic
Well I think the whole purpose of tradition is to keep consistency, without change. Even starting new traditions risks modifying existing traditions. The Catholic Church has made it a point to preserve its tradition, and has done quite a good job at it. People are put off by the Church today because they can't quite understand this tradition...it doesn't "fit" with the society of today so to speak. But that's fine...if the Church modified itself to fit the time, then it would have gone through countless modifications through thousands of years, where all meaning would be lost in the end. Tradition has preserved the church and its roots, and thus preserved its true meaning back to its origination.
 
Upvote 0

isshinwhat

Pro Deo et Patria
Apr 12, 2002
8,338
624
Visit site
✟13,555.00
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Some traditions can change... celibacy of the priesthood is a tradition of the Latin Rite that could change. It probably won't, but it could. That Mary was a virgin her entire life is a Tradition inherited from the Early Church, and we could not change that if we wanted to. We usually differentiate between the two by using a "t" for those that are changable, and a "T" for those things that are not. The Traditions are usually Dogmatic things, or matters of the original Deposit of the Faith. The all-male priesthood is a Tradition that is left from the original Deposit of the Faith, and that, too, we could not change if we wanted to. Hope that helped.

God Bless,

Neal
 
Upvote 0

Wolseley

Beaucoup-Diên-Cai-Dāu
Feb 5, 2002
21,131
5,623
63
By the shores of Gitchee-Goomee
✟276,838.00
Country
United States
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
Sacred Tradition (also known as Apostolic Tradition---Big "T") consists of the original oral teachings of the Apostles. The Church considers this to be divinely inspired and the Word of God. It cannot be added to, subtracted from, or changed in any way.

Other traditions (small "t") are things like ember days or veneration of the Holy Cross on Good Friday. They can be changed. New ones can be invented, old ones discontinued.

There's a huge difference between Tradition and traditions.
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

Defender of the Faith 777

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2002
1,121
4
Visit site
✟2,076.00
Faith
United Ch. of Christ
I got one, let's say

salvation. By far the most important, let's tackle that first. Glad to say, we agree on the main thing (who God is). :)

And this will include purgatory, since that is a REQUIREMENT for it, as you believe. It will include whether you believe that the Eucharist communion (the excusively Catholic tradition of believing it literally becomes His blood and body), is necessary, and since only the Catholic church does it, and it's supposedly required for salvation, only Catholics go to heaven.
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.