Recent content by HatGuy

  1. HatGuy

    Disciples of Christ - The first non denominational church?

    I think you raise some excellent points here borne from experience. Yes, there is *some* confidence that a denomination can give you in that, theoretically, if it claims to uphold doctrine x and practice y then you can assume with a clear conscience that this is what is being practiced / taught...
  2. HatGuy

    Disciples of Christ - The first non denominational church?

    Even denominational churches with books of discipline (look at UMC right now) and creeds and confessions have similar problems. For example, as much as I love the LCMS (Lutheran) in principle, in practice one LCMS church could be very different from another. They have the same confession, but in...
  3. HatGuy

    The Five Fold Ministries Cannot Function In Our Current Factionalised Church

    I think what is being addressed here is motive and ambition. Luther was a fiery character for sure. Yet quite brilliant. Straightforward and sometimes crass. But his ambition appeared to be to see the truth set people free, and find unity in that truth. The situation with Zwingli was...
  4. HatGuy

    The Five Fold Ministries Cannot Function In Our Current Factionalised Church

    Oh, I get it now. Thank you! I agree!
  5. HatGuy

    The Five Fold Ministries Cannot Function In Our Current Factionalised Church

    In 1 Corinthians 9:2, Paul says: 2 If to others I am not an apostle, at least I am to you, for you are the seal of my apostleship in the Lord. Indicating that some did not see him as an apostle in his time. Not everyone will recognize someone's ministry. I don't think this is a bad thing...
  6. HatGuy

    Christian Ghost Writer

    I am a ghostwriter, so I can tell you from my perspective. You're welcome to ask me anything :) It all depends how it's done. If the pastor (or client) has the ideas, the content (sermons, presentations, outlines etc.) it makes perfect sense to hire a professional writer who knows how to put...
  7. HatGuy

    Living With True Hope in a Dark World

    Photo by Hennie Stander on Unsplash The stories most of our cultures are telling us right now—which we see played out in our politics—consist of corruption, backwardness, fear, and massive confusion about identity. Evil is pernicious. And today, it has gradually worn down the hope and vitality...
  8. HatGuy

    Replacing God with AI

    I disagree with this assessment. As complicated as the computational process is; and as closely it might try to mimic a human neural network; it's still "garbage in, garbage out." AI will not be able to make unbiased decisions as it is entirely dependent on human input and always will be. It's...
  9. HatGuy

    Single predestination?

    I have noticed a ton of Lutherans admit it's illogical and be quite proud of that. I tend to agree with them. The Lutheran Confessions try and only present what the Bible says - and the Bible itself acknowledges some sort of predestination, but never acknowledges double predestination. The...
  10. HatGuy

    The Making of Ministers: Seminaries and Spiritual Formation

    Some insist on formal education at their college / seminary before ordination (Assembly of God, for example). Many others rely on informal routes. The local church is where training and spiritual formation happens, as ultimately it would be viewed that it is the local church's responsibility to...
  11. HatGuy

    Faith Alone?

    Yes, but I think this starting point already implies that the end point will be a "polishing up of the Old Man". I think, at this point, it goes a little awry for me. I mean, there are some points of agreement - but the language about what is "natural" for man, I believe, can be a little...
  12. HatGuy

    Faith Alone?

    Not to be argumentative, but it's a debate so I guess that can't be helped... Lol... But the way this is presented makes it sound like God comes to polish up the Old Man a bit, give him a bit of a boost so he can reach righteousness. It seems to me the gospel is not a message about how we can...
  13. HatGuy

    Faith Alone?

    Faith is essentially a relational word. It's a way of describing a relational dynamic. Trust, belief, these are ways of describing this relational dynamic. Which is why it requires both head and heart. Some people enter into the relationship with their head, others their heart, and over time...
  14. HatGuy

    Can LCMS date church member?

    Ah, I see where you're getting at now. Thank you!