You are saying it is possible that Christians wrote the Quran when the Quran saysActually I could at least consider it as a working hypothesis. There is nothing historically strange about it. After all:
1. Islam is younger than Christianity
2. Large part of Qur'an is based on the Bible and other Christian literature
3. Christians lived in that time in that place
(i) Jesus was NOT crucified
(ii) Jesus was a slave of God and Not the son of god
(iii) not to associate anything or anyone with God
You will then have Applepie changing the verses and words of the Quran to say otherwise. We went through this before and I do not wish to continue with this argument.
However, if you wish to make the same stand as Applepie, I am willing to discuss with you alone.
Jews who followed the teachings of Christ will more likely wrote things that glorify Christ and his techings. If follows that if Christians wrote the Quran, they would not wrote about Jesus denying being divine or that Jesus was not crucified.So, what is strange about that? The New Testament was written, at least in great part, by Jews.
Applepie does not read or speak Arabic. He only used some lexicons to change the words to suit his purpose. I leave it to you to read and judge by yourself.What do you mean? Did he change the Arabic text? I sincerely doubt that unless he had any manuscript evidence to back that up.
I do not expect you to automatically agreed with the date. If you think the date is not correct, give me another date.I expressed a doubt. The fact that I do not know the answer to a question does not make your answer automatically correct. It could be, but you would need some supporting evidence.
The inscriptions on the Dome of the Rock can be found in the Quran. You can also check with other ancient manuscripts of the Quran.Concerning (i) you have provided no evidence for that. Concerning Sana'a, thanks for the information. I will have to read about it. Of course if (ii) is correct, then you are correct about (i)
Upvote
0