Speedwell
Well-Known Member
- May 11, 2016
- 23,928
- 17,625
- 81
- Country
- United States
- Faith
- Other Religion
- Marital Status
- Married
What I'm trying to tell you that each intermediate step between forelimb and wing has to be useful in itself. The genes don't make long term plans. They produce a range of variants in the population with each new generation from which the environment selects the best adapted. The selected individuals then pass that adaptation to their progeny who reproduce it with variation for further selection. Each evolutionary step is complete and useful in itself. There is no such thing as wings evolving as useless appendages until capable of flight. Each generational step in the development of wings was useful in itself in some way in increasing the adaptation of the species to its environment.Yes I have and that's why it makes,zero sense to,me. Your answers are why.
The complexity of,life and the universe make zero sense to me as an evolutionary process. Your answers are why.
What was immediately useful for the,small step for wings,to develop. If wings started as forelimbs what evolutionary process caused something to be useful in the formation of wings? Wings,would need,to,be more useful than forelimbs of a creature that was ground bound. But the wings would not be immediately useful because the,process takes so,long. Something would have,to,cause the unintelligent gene to start to form Something so drastic as a wing.
Evolution does not start out to make a wing from a forelimb, it just takes the next step to make the forelimb more adapted to the particular situation the species finds itself in. The thing can go different ways--in the case of the penguin's ancestral line the forelimb became a wing and then a flipper. Evolution didn't "start out" to make a flipper, any more than it started out to make a wing. But it illustrates an important point: because evolution works by small steps, each one of which must be useful in itself, it may not get to its present state by the most direct pathway, or the one with the fewest number of steps.
And it all can be seen in the fossil record.
Last edited:
Upvote
0