<<< The American Idol Thread >>>

†ßorn4Worship†™ · Dec 27, 2004

The new season starts Jan.17. Are U ready??? If not, then get ready. This is the official thread for A.I. so post all comments about the show here. It's gonna be gr8.

Past A.I. Winners:

A.I. 1 (2002)--Kelly Clarkson
A.I. 2 (2003)--Ruben Studdard
A.I. 3 (2004)--Fantasia Burrino

MetalBlade · Dec 27, 2004

I started getting into it during the second season and loved it. I really liked both Clay and Rubban, and I wish Clay would have got it. During the third season I lost interest in it quick. Simon's offenses are the same, and some of those horrible singers almost seem staged. Plus it seems that if you are a white male, you have no chance of winning!

Savedsis · Dec 27, 2004

Oh, I can not wait for the next season......I am so ready for it.........

AirPo · Dec 29, 2004

MetalBlade said:
Plus it seems that if you are a white male, you have no chance of winning!

Clay came close and the marine guy went far as well.
Last year the football player blew it early. It was his genre and he picked something really lame. I told my wife he blew it as soon as he finished, and the next night Simon said the same thing.

BubblesRelena · Dec 30, 2004

You know. I can honestly say I've never watched an episode of American Idol. Heh, it seems interesting, but I'd rather listen to the winners on the radio or something. I'm much too busy to watch every episode (I know if I watch one I'll be hooked.) LoL

~BubblesRelena

col_181_rush · Jan 1, 2005

i can`t stand fantasia
she shouldn't have won
No offense but she suck's

sjpianoprincess · Jan 4, 2005

MetalBlade said:
I really liked both Clay and Rubban, and I wish Clay would have got it.

I wished that Clay had won too. I can't wait for it to start! January 18th is the 2 hour premiere.

Savedsis · Jan 4, 2005

col_181_rush said:
i can`t stand fantasia
she shouldn't have won
No offense but she suck's

I think she should have won.....She is really good...

halifaxhoney · Jan 4, 2005

Another season!! Yay!! I hope that this year will be better. I've been disappointed twice!! Ruben and Fantasia weren't the best.

I'm glad that I've had Canadian Idol to make up for the disappointment this season. Yay Kalan!!

Crystal

choop1212 · Jan 6, 2005

I dont like the actual show, I just mostly like the auditions. They are prettty funny.

†ßorn4Worship†™ · Feb 9, 2005

I dont' know what you all have been smoking but Ruben and Fantasia should have won. They deserved it. Ruben was by far head and shoulders abouve the rest. Fantasia wiped the floor with Diana Digarmo who didn't even deserve to be in the final 10 led alone the final 2.

If you really want a debate lets talk about Kelly Clarkson's title. Tamyra got screwed and Kelly had to face Justin who was by far the more inferior "talent". Not taking anything away from Kelly but lets be real, if Tamyra would have got the nod above Justin then Tamyra would have been the champ not Kelly.

P.S.-- You guys wouldn't know talent if it hit you in the head with a steel chair.

CherylNMO · Feb 9, 2005

So far I'm not too impressed with anyone just yet for this season. There are some good voices, but I think as the numbers start dwindling down it will be easier to pick one that stands out.

IrishGrace · Feb 9, 2005

§murf4Christ said:
P.S.-- You guys wouldn't know talent if it hit you in the head with a steel chair.

wow... that was rather rude... and completely uncalled for...

anyway... tonights episode was so-so... I agree with the judges on everyone who left... I don't think they should have given that one group another chance though... the ones who picked the "different" song and then went to sleep instead of practicing... it's their own faults... they screwed up and shouldn't have been given another chance...

<<< The American Idol Thread >>>

Junior Member

Defender of the Faith

Seasoned Salty Sista

with a Touch of Grey

Manager of Apostolic Love

Active Member

Sara

Seasoned Salty Sista

Senior Veteran

Active Member

Junior Member

Regular Member

Contributor

Similar threads

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency