theFijian said:
Animals have a soul?
Andy
The English word soul derives from a number of different words in the Old and New Testaments and is used in the Bible in a variety of ways. First, it is employed as a synonym for a living, breathing person. Moses wrote: All the souls that came out of the loins of Jacob were seventy souls (Exodus 1:5; cf. Deuteronomy 10:22). In legal matters also, the word soul was used to denote any individual. The Lord told Moses: Speak unto the children of Israel, saying, If a soul shall sin through ignorance against any of the commandments of the Lord concerning things which ought not to be done (Leviticus 4:2). When Jacob was speaking of himself in Genesis 49:6, he used the expression, O my soulwhich meant simply me. In each of these instances, actual peopleindividually or collectivelywere under discussion.
Second, the word soul can be used to describe the physical form of life that both men and animals possess and that ceases to exist at death. In their
Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament, Brown, Driver, and Briggs noted that the word soul (Hebrew
nephesh) often is employed to mean life principle (1907, p. 659). In Genesis 1:20,24,30, God spoke of the
nephesh hayyahliterally soul breathers or life breathers (often translated as living creatures or lifecf. Leviticus 11:10). The writer of Proverbs observed in regard to animals: A righteous man regardeth the life (
nephesh) of his beast; but the tender mercies of the wicked are cruel (12:10). Hebrew scholar Hugo McCord therefore suggested:
Then the translators realized that the first meaning of nephesh is breath, and so Genesis 1:20,24,30 and Genesis 2:7 all fit together in understanding Moses as saying that all animals and man too are breathers. Breathers, coupled with hayyah, living, the translators thought, would be well translated, in the case of animals, as living creatures, and in the case of man as a living being (1995, 23[1]:87-88).
Third, the word soul can be used to describe something that is immortal and thus never dies. In speaking of Rachels death at the birth of her son, Moses wrote: And it came to pass, as her soul was departing (for she died) (Genesis 35:18). While Elijah was at the house of a widow in the city of Zarephath, the womans son died. But Elijah cried unto Jehovah, and said..., O Jehovah my God, I pray thee, let this childs soul come into him again (1 Kings 17:21). Hezekiah celebrated the fact that the soul survives the death of the body: But thou hast in love to my soul (
nephesh) delivered it from the pit of corruption (Isaiah 38:17).
The question therefore becomes: Can the word soul be used correctly in referring to animals? The first definition obviously cannot apply to animals since animals are not persons. But the second definition most certainly would apply to animals. Compare the following passages. In Psalm 78:50 we find an example of the usage of soul as life when the writer said in speaking of the people of Egypt (who tried in vain to prevent the Israelites from leaving their countrys slavery) that God spared not their soul from death, but gave their life over to the pestilence. In this instance, the word soul (Hebrew
nephesh) is used to denote the physical life of humans. But in Genesis 1:20,24, the identical Hebrew word is employed to speak of animals as living creatures (Hebrew
nephesh hayyah). In this sense, then, yes, it is correct to say that animals have soulssince the word soul means only physical life. In responding to the question, Do animals have souls?, McCord wrote: Yes, when the word soul,
nephesh, only means breath, as in Genesis 1:20 ([size=-1]ASV[/size]), Let the waters swarm with swarms of living creatures,
nephesh hayyah, literally, living soul (1999).
Source:
http://www.apologeticspress.org/
But plants are not referred to in Scripture as having
nephesh. This distinquishes them from the life given to humans and animals, therefore they do not "die" as humans and animals do.
Therefore to answer you question, no plants did not die when they were eaten by Adam and Eve as Scripture defines life and death. Sin resulted in the death for only those to whom He gave
nephesh or breath.