ukok said:
Oh, Greg, you are just so funny..(.the thought had crossed my mind though...)
Ummm...maybe I missed it but do any of you see your child's lack of compliance as rebellion?
It seems like the major method so far is either ignore it or threaten. Do any of you actually do anything to train your child to obey you? Obviously you cannot make them go to sleep but you can most certainly teach them that when it's bed time they must close their eyes, be quiet, and try to go to sleep.
My sister was having this exact same problem with her three year old. She would put him down for bed at 8 p.m. and he was still awake and running all over the house at 2 a.m. I told her she needed to be firm and tell her son that if he got out of bed, except to use the bathroom, then he would get a spanking and then, if necessary,
follow through. Of course she disregarded my advice, all the while all three of my children are sound asleep by 9 p.m., the youngest, who is 20 months old, by 8:15 p.m. Anyway, her son would constantly get up and ask for a drink, or say he couldn't find a sock or whatever he could think of to stay up. Basically, he controlled his own bedtime. Well, one day she decided she had had enough. She had him use the bathroom, gave him
a sip of a drink, and read him two stories. Then, she put him in bed with a warning that if he got up he would get a spanking. Of course, he got up. It wasn't anything important. I think it was the "sock" thing again. So, she spanked him and put him back to bed. Well, he got up again. So, she spanked him again. He got the idea. He didn't get up again and it was the first night in a year that my sister and her husband weren't fighting with him until the wee hours of the morning trying to get him to go to sleep. This process continued for about three days and by the fourth day, when it was his bedtime, she would take him to bed, read him two stories and tell him to go to sleep. He hasn't gotten out of bed when he wasn't supposed to since then.
One important thing that I still have to learn is that children often need a period of time to calm down before bed. I play with my kids alot and I used to get frustrated because they were all keyed up at bed time, even though it was my own fault. I had to learn to knock that off about ½ hour before bed time so they could calm down.
God bless