EternalDragon
Counselor
Well, it is just not part of the theory.
Why is abiogenesis not part of the evolution theory? I say it has to be part of it but it is not.
Upvote
0
Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
Why not? It would seem to be the most significant part of the theory, if indeed the theory were to be taken seriously. Declaring that a designer was responsible invites the question of how the designer was able to accomplish his/her/its design. Not to mention the related question of where the designer came from...
Well good for you.
And while you were nosing around on an ID board to strengthen your conviction that ID isn't science, I waited for you here ... with the same conviction.
Only ... and I'm sure you won't understand what I'm about to say.
Only I'm more convinced ID isn't science than you are.
Well, it is just not part of the theory.
Why is abiogenesis not part of the evolution theory?
Why don't you pick one that you think is the strongest and we will see how it holds up.
And just by coincidence, his decision is the same as mine, right?
Now how do you suppose that happened? lucky guess on my part?
I'm two years ahead of him now, aren't I?
And for the record, how many years did you spend on an ID board, chief?
Peer-Reviewed Pro-Intelligent Design Paper Suggests "Agents" and "Choice Contingency" Needed to Explain Life's Programming - Evolution News & Views
a 2009 peer review summary in above link,
try that one.
None, but I did read books about it, including these:
Peer-Reviewed Pro-Intelligent Design Paper Suggests "Agents" and "Choice Contingency" Needed to Explain Life's Programming - Evolution News & Views
a 2009 peer review summary in above link,
try that one.
Therein lies the problem.
Because evolution deals with the diversity of life, not the beginning of it. It never claimed to deal with the origin of life. Not once.
Well, there you go. ID theory deals with the diversity of life as well as the beginning of it.
Peer-Reviewed Pro-Intelligent Design Paper Suggests "Agents" and "Choice Contingency" Needed to Explain Life's Programming - Evolution News & Views
a 2009 peer review summary in above link,
try that one.
In science we break things down to subjects that are relevant so that we can discuss them without getting sidetracked. It's why we have different fields of study, like biology and physics. It wouldn't make sense to mix the two now would it? And then we get into what we study in each discipline. It makes no sense to study gunpowder formulations and ballistics of cannonballs together even though they're both needed in the function.Why is abiogenesis not part of the evolution theory? I say it has to be part of it but it is not.
In science we break things down to subjects that are relevant so that we can discuss them without getting sidetracked. It's why we have different fields of study, like biology and physics. It wouldn't make sense to mix the two now would it? And then we get into what we study in each discipline. It makes no sense to study gunpowder formulations and ballistics of cannonballs together even though they're both needed in the function.
Abiogenesis is about how life STARTED
Evolution is about how life CHANGES
No, they're not part of the same thing.
SkaLoop said:I really can't understand why anti-evolution folks get so up in arms about how evolution can't explain where life came from, while at the same time being totally OK with gravity not explaining where matter came from.
Show me the math where charged particles obey the gravitational laws? This is why there is no gravitational model for the atom, only electrical.
No it doesn't. The Bible does but ID doesn't. In fact, ID doesn't deal with anything at all. It doesn't because it doesn't exist. Go on, look around. I'll give you some time. Please present to us the Theory of Intelligent Design. If you come up with more than "goddidit" I'll be personally amazed. There is much that's attributed to ID but has nothing to do with ID.Well, there you go. ID theory deals with the diversity of life as well as the beginning of it.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?