a "Christian" nation?

Not_a_fundie · Jul 9, 2002

I was appaled reading the article "Where should Christians draw the line in trying to make the U.S. a Christian nation?" on this site.

In terms of religion, it is not a matter of "trying to make" the United States a Christian nation. The U.S. has always been a Christian nation from the earliest colonial settlements. It remains a Christian nation today. The vast majority of U.S. citizenry claim at least a nominal adherence to Christianity, and, amazingly enough, the majority of our new immigrants make a similar claim -- even those from Asian countries. The U.S. was founded upon Christian principles and beliefs.

How can you say this? Yes, the majority may be Christian, but FOUNDED on Christianity? I think not. Washington, Jefferson, and Adams, just to name a few, were Deists. Franklin was an athiest.

In America, this "line" has shifted over the years. In other words, as the definition of a "religious establishment" has changed, the concept of America as a Christian nation has also changed.

Yes, the concept has changed. Now it exists. America wasen't meant to be a Christian nation.

In America, it has become politically incorrect to refer to the U.S. in religious terms according to the religion of the majority.

Was it ever not?

Such was not always the case. Historically, throughout the world, America has always been considered a Christian nation. Why? Because Christianity was the dominant religion of the land. Christianity shaped the thinking of America's forefathers and informed the making of public policy and law. Christianity was a part of the common law; it was woven throughout the fabric of American life.

As I already said, the majority of the founding fathers were Deists.

Look, nobody is trying to take away your religion. You are free to practice it as you wish. But you CAN NOT impose it upon others, and you CAN NOT force it into a mandatory pledge.

strathyboy · Jul 9, 2002

Who said the pledge was mandatory? I was under the impression that it was an optional thing.

Not_a_fundie · Jul 9, 2002

Who said the pledge was mandatory? I was under the impression that it was an optional thing.

In some places(ergo:where I went) it is mandatory.

Raging Atheist · Jul 9, 2002

Originally posted by strathyboy
Who said the pledge was mandatory? I was under the impression that it was an optional thing.

Doesnt matter. The fact that it is the teacher, the authority in such a setting, leading the pledge makes it unconstitutional. Besides, you did NOT want to be the poor kid who sat it out or just didnt say anything when it got to "under god"... good way to be an outcast.

PS -
GREAT post, btw, I could hug you for making those points.

I love the new design. I have a question though. Whats with the blessings? I have 7 of them and I dont know where, how, or why I got them. Much less what Im supposed to do with them. I don't intend to purchase any of god's armor.

Mallory Knox · Jul 9, 2002

Originally posted by Raging Atheist

Doesnt matter. The fact that it is the teacher, the authority in such a setting, leading the pledge makes it unconstitutional. Besides, you did NOT want to be the poor kid who sat it out or just didnt say anything when it got to "under god"... good way to be an outcast.

PS -
GREAT post, btw, I could hug you for making those points.

I love the new design. I have a question though. Whats with the blessings? I have 7 of them and I dont know where, how, or why I got them. Much less what Im supposed to do with them. I don't intend to purchase any of god's armor.

Did you start a thread? You get 7 for starting a thread. And people can just give them to you. If you don't want yours you can give them to me. Just click my "bless" button at the top of my post and enter the number 7. Glad I could help you out.

Raging Atheist · Jul 9, 2002

aaah... yes, I started a thread... that would be why... thank you for clearing that up... you already have 600... you dont need any... I'll give 'em to someone deserving... hm... who do I know that needs the armor of god?

Not_a_fundie · Jul 9, 2002

Oh, and I feel like I missed something there. The Church is trying to gain political influence while not paying taxes. Isn't something wrong there?

Raging Atheist · Jul 9, 2002

Originally posted by Not_a_fundie
Isn't something wrong there?

Yes.

9-iron · Jul 9, 2002

"I don't know that Atheists should be considered as citizens, nor should they be considered patriots. This is one nation under God." -- George Bush

Hey Raging, did Bush SR. or JR. say that????

Not_a_fundie · Jul 9, 2002

Hey Raging, did Bush SR. or JR. say that????

I happen to know, it's a Sr. quote.

Raging Atheist · Jul 9, 2002

yupperz... I think of it as a monument to ignorance and prejudice... kinda like the confederate flag...

Not_a_fundie · Jul 9, 2002

Don't forget the guys who tattoo swasticas on their arms(oh yeah, they do).

a "Christian" nation?

Not_a_fundie

Active Member

More options

strathyboy

Well-Known Member

More options

Not_a_fundie

Active Member

More options

Raging Atheist

god told me he doesnt exist

More options

Mallory Knox

Well-Known Member

More options

Raging Atheist

god told me he doesnt exist

More options

Not_a_fundie

Active Member

More options

Raging Atheist

god told me he doesnt exist

More options

9-iron

Football Fan

More options

Not_a_fundie

Active Member

More options

Raging Atheist

god told me he doesnt exist

More options

Not_a_fundie

Active Member

More options

Similar threads

a "Christian" nation?

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

god told me he doesnt exist

Well-Known Member

god told me he doesnt exist

Active Member

god told me he doesnt exist

Football Fan

Active Member

god told me he doesnt exist

Active Member

Similar threads

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency