What is so disturbing? Here is some of what I read today on various sites that claimed to be about Christian DD or from people who claimed to be Christians who use Domestic Discipline or
* A husband who shared with us that when his wife needs to be disciplined, say she has a bad attitude, he makes her strip naked, stand in the corner and wait, thinking about what she has done wrong, for him to come in and administer a spanking, after which, she will stand before him naked and ask for his forgivness.
* A woman who has yet to be spanked by her husband and is fearful, everytime she makes a mistake, or makes a decision for fear that her husand will not agree with her, and that this will be the time, and she is afraid that it will hurt and afraid that she will be embarassed.
* A husband and father explaining that when he administers a punishment, which is usually a spanking in his household, for his children and his wife, he feels that he is being God to his family, correcting those he loves so that they will be better.
* A woman who will, when she has gone off her diet, which is something she is not supposed to do, wait till her husband comes home and then beg for him to spank her so she can feel better about herself.
* A woman who writes that prior to marrying her husband and their decision to use DD, she felt all adrift, sure she was going to screw things up, ruin her life and disappoint her parents. But now that he tells her what to do, structures her time, makes all the decisions, and she has only to obey, and do things his way, she feels so much happier. The spankings keep her in line, which she knows she needs.
*One wife is forced to sleep naked as punishment.
* A husband who writes about weekly sessions with his wife to discuss how she is doing. When the discussion is done, she is spanked, not as a punishment, but to keep her "focused", and then he comforts her to assure her that she is loved.
Someone on one site noted the following: " Domestic Discipline has been a part of the BDSM "scene" for a long while, but it was only recently that conservative Christian apologists began making a "Biblical" case for the practice. It falls completely in line, although to the extreme, with that faction's obsession with "authority" and hierarchy, and power and control."
Many of these postings are nothing short of erotic. So called "Christian" DD sources have names like "Power & Love", "Power Theologians" "Spankpro" "The Marriage Bed" (if this is not sexual, why the focus on the bed? This particular site is filled with information (of varying quality) on sex alongside the DD information.
(BEWARE!! If you choose to search for yourself, a lot of sites that list "Christian Domestic Discipline" in bold letters are nothing but inappropriate content.)
I object to the notion of husband as all powerful, all knowing and all wise.
Who disciplines the husband? Or are husbands somehow exempt from original sin?
I find the childlike images of the wife who needs to be corrected (often by physical punishment, often naked) insulting and perverted. Do the children have to get naked for their spankings, too? What on earth does that do to them?!
Many of the postings, from both men and women were creepy, sexually charged little stories.
Why, if this is all about discipline, for both wife and children, is there so much talk about sex on these sites?
I simply do not see DD, as so many write about it, as compatable with a Godly marriage. I see in none of this the love and sexual expression of love found in The Song of Solomon. People write on this site about the "sin" of lusting while mastrubating. What on earth do we think is gong through the mind of the husband as he undresses his wife to spank her and then comfort her?!
I have no doubt that there are couples whose DD relationship is not sexually distorted... no, sorry, I have to take that back! The more I think about it, the more I cannot seperate the spanking of the wife, the total physical control of and domination of the woman by the man from a distorted sexual relationship. I am hard pressed to see how any of this brings glory to God.
This is also not fair to husbands! Even if there are relationships where things are not a sexual peversion, why is all the burden placed upon the husband? What happened to a wife as a help suitable for man as we see in Genesis? Instead, we have the husband who has to take all the responsibility for the person who should be his partner, working with him, supporting him as he supports her.