Red Flags? Can I do anything?

SnowyMacie

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2011
17,007
6,087
North Texas
✟118,149.00
Country
United States
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
In Relationship
I know that sounds rather weird, but I'm a little concerned for a college ministry here in my city. I have a number of friends apart of this group, and well, I often wonder if they are slowly slipping into cultism and even if they aren't, they get pretty out of line and consider it correct to do so. I'm just curios if any of these raise "Red flags" with y'all...

A few things I strange things I have noticed:

1) The main church is nothing like the college ministry. The church very much promotes unity among churches and going out, while the college ministry basically thinks that they're the only right ones and everyone should join them. The college pastor actually said this in a lesson "What I am saying right because this is what the Bible says. It doesn't matter what any other pastor has ever told you because they're not true followers"

2) They believe that if you do not share their viewpoint on everything, you are not a real follower, therefore you might as well be just be an admitting non-believe because that would be better.

3) They present themselves as "holier-than-thou" and then tell each other how the prayed for a random person or witnessed to this person. Not that there's anything wrong with those things, I don't think scripture says boast and brag about it.

4) They do not take no as an answer. If they ask you to church or one of their small groups, and you say no. They will ask you again, and again, and again, you get the point, until you say yes.

5) There's this weird hierarchy thing going on. On top you have Jeremy and Keith (the two college pastors). Then you have the section leaders, each section has several small groups in them (called Life Groups). I know a lot churches are set up this way, but you can't just start a life group without permission of our section leader and you must go through training to be a leader if they want you to (they pick and choose who). Also, they have discipleship groups, which are more informal but can't just be people one has to be a group leader.

I was apart of this group, I left because God told me to leave. It was spiritually damaging for me to be there. I noticed that when I started sharing my more liberal viewpoints, there was this growing distance between us. I finally sat down and told two of them (who I was grown closest two) that it had become spiritually damaging for me to be there, and my relationship with God was better apart from them. They understood and asked me to share it with the rest. I agreed. That was two months ago, I've asked several times to be able to do this and they either say: not now or just ignore the question and not answer back. I also have met a few people that go to the church and told me that they would never join the college ministry.

I don't know if I'm reading into things too much, I sometimes can do that. I am concerned as a friend that they are slowly walking into dangerous territory. Does any of this signal red flags to anyone else?
 

kevlite2020

rawr means I love you in dinosaur!
Sep 11, 2008
10,781
2,265
40
Florida
Visit site
✟35,700.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
A lot of Christian campus groups get very territorial. At my last college, I was somewhat active in two different groups and they both told me that the other group was a cult and that I should leave that group. I don't know what it is about the college setting, but things can get pretty weird, pretty fast.

The only advice I can give is to love everybody, tread carefully, and do what you believe is right.
 
Upvote 0
S

Sieben

Guest
Well, no point in going somewhere that's not edifying. So don't go back. You need to know their beliefs first before doing such things, annd you seem to have a problem with them now...

For me, before I would even enter such a place I would ask them questions.

- do you have sin?
- where was sin taken?
- how do you resolve daily sins?

that's my super awesome discerning questions.
do you have any you asked them? or just waltz in
 
Upvote 0

Saucy

King of CF
Site Supporter
Jul 5, 2005
46,669
19,838
Michigan
✟838,184.00
Country
United States
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Republican
that's my super awesome discerning questions.
^_^^_^


Matt, they seem to be very controlling and as Kevin said, territorial. If they are preaching that they have the one true word and everyone else is wrong, then flee as fast as you can. That's breaching cultism. We all have differences, but we're all parts of the body of Christ.

I guess my super awesome advice (^_^) would be that if you have a bunch of red flags jump up, then listen to your instinct and get out of there. Those flags pop up because they don't match what you believe.
 
Upvote 0

Amber.ly

Predictably eccentric and honestly hypocritical
Mar 1, 2010
6,591
1,799
Gone- PM if you need me
✟22,486.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
A few things I strange things I have noticed:

1) The main church is nothing like the college ministry. The church very much promotes unity among churches and going out, while the college ministry basically thinks that they're the only right ones and everyone should join them. The college pastor actually said this in a lesson "What I am saying right because this is what the Bible says. It doesn't matter what any other pastor has ever told you because they're not true followers"

2) They believe that if you do not share their viewpoint on everything, you are not a real follower, therefore you might as well be just be an admitting non-believe because that would be better.

3) They present themselves as "holier-than-thou" and then tell each other how the prayed for a random person or witnessed to this person. Not that there's anything wrong with those things, I don't think scripture says boast and brag about it.

4) They do not take no as an answer. If they ask you to church or one of their small groups, and you say no. They will ask you again, and again, and again, you get the point, until you say yes.

5) There's this weird hierarchy thing going on. On top you have Jeremy and Keith (the two college pastors). Then you have the section leaders, each section has several small groups in them (called Life Groups). I know a lot churches are set up this way, but you can't just start a life group without permission of our section leader and you must go through training to be a leader if they want you to (they pick and choose who). Also, they have discipleship groups, which are more informal but can't just be people one has to be a group leader.

#1 sounds a little off. But I have never hesitated to say that there are a lot of teachings that you need to throw out, doesn't mean I am an island unto myself, just means I value teaching only the truth.

#2 is a real issue in the church. We have so many people who profess Christ but you wouldn't know it. They basially are non-believers who grew up in church. I don't know about the whole "bleieve only what we say" thing but that could be you taking offense when none was intended. Or you could be absolutely right and their attitude needs adjusting.

#3 If you aren't excited about what you do for God, stop doing it. Maybe you are too sensitive because you aren't doing those things? Again, maybe you are correct and they do have an issue but I see the possibility for a different problem.

#4 :ahah: Persistance is key, I've been told. Sometimes annoying but hey, it worked ;)

#5 I wish my church did this. Had training and standards and you had to qualify to teach. This to me is just smart. Too many churches accept anyone who will volunteer and that is when the real problems start.




Yes, I am playing Devil's Advocate and backing them up. Because one thing stood out to me in your post

I was apart of this group, I left because God told me to leave. It was spiritually damaging for me to be there. I noticed that when I started sharing my more liberal viewpoints, there was this growing distance between us.

This is a huge flag to me because "liberal viewpoints" generally means less living what the Bible teaches and more choosing what you want to believe.

Perhaps you are right and this group is no longer Christ-centered and is spiritually damaging the members. That is not a judgement call any of us on this board can make. I think that if you feel a true conviction to effect change, go to your head pastor and share your concerns. See if can sit down before that step with the leaders of the group and see if they are open to accepting criticism, if not, go the higher ups.

Then again, you said God called you out of that group so that says to me that you aren't meant to fix the problems. After all, if He was going to use you there, would He have told you to walk away?
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

kevlite2020

rawr means I love you in dinosaur!
Sep 11, 2008
10,781
2,265
40
Florida
Visit site
✟35,700.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
aw i was serious
because usually people answer the typical way to those questions

-do you have sin? they usually say yes. strike!
-where was sin taken? they usually say the cross. strike!
-how do you resolve daily sins? they usually pray for forgiveness. strike!

all things that if said i would walk away


What would you consider the right answers to be?
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums