Why do Christians continue to celebrate Christmas?

[Jipsah]

Isn't this disingenuous?

nope. Your lot will be baying at the moon claiming that when we proclaim “He is risen!”! at Easter we’re really talking about some long-forgotten never-existed goddess who only Christians obsessed with rooting out largely imaginary paganism in the Church ever gave any thought at all. After all, who’s to keep those heathen fetishes alive if y’all don’t?

"False pride twisting what's going on and falsely stating it as fact, without knowledge"?

nah, just the observation that y’all try your very best to prevent the celebration of any Christ-centered feasts by proclaiming them “pagan”, and supporting your accusations with bogus “history”. Sorry, mate, but your made-up commandment “thou shalt not keep Christian feasts” is a crock, bought into mostly By ignorant Christians who are playing at being Jews

 

[Kerensa]

nope. Your lot will be baying at the moon claiming that when we proclaim “He is risen!”! at Easter we’re really talking about some long-forgotten never-existed goddess who only Christians obsessed with rooting out largely imaginary paganism in the Church ever gave any thought at all. After all, who’s to keep those heathen fetishes alive if y’all don’t?

Ooer, I can hardly wait. Actually, I've seen this all before in New Age discussion forums where the Wiccans and other neo-pagans come in every Easter claiming that the nasty Christians stole "their" spring festival. Funny that some Christians would rather side with them than with fellow Christians, as it seems.

nah, just the observation that y’all try your very best to prevent the celebration of any Christ-centered feasts by proclaiming them “pagan”, and supporting your accusations with bogus “history”. Sorry, mate, but your made-up commandment “thou shalt not keep Christian feasts” is a crock, bought into mostly By ignorant Christians who are playing at being Jews

Or else being anti-Catholic bigots with no idea of how to do sound historical research, as we saw with the "Two Babylons" tract.