Scary is EXACTLY the right word when supposed Christians reinterpret the Bible & promote naturalistic science, mixing truth with error. That has been called heresy since the beginning of the church & doesn't surprise spiritually discerning Christians who have the Spirit of God.
And by the way, Wheaton has not been considered a 'conservative Christian' college for a long time. They have continued to compromise, deceive & outright lie about things. Here is one such example by a gay person the administration with the president's approval hired back in 2016.
How a Top Christian School Turned Against Its Gay Leader
Here is another example from an article from the 'Chicago Tribune':
Professor Larycia Hawkins has been asked to affirm the college’s statement of faith four times since she started teaching at Wheaton nearly NINE YEARS AGO! She was first admonished for writing an academic paper about what Christians could learn from black LIBERATION theology, which relates the Bible with the often-troubled history of race relations in America. Jones said Hawkins’ article seemed to endorse a kind of Marxism.
She was called in a year later to defend a photograph someone posted on Facebook showing her at a party inside a home on Halsted Street the same day as Chicago’s Pride Parade. Last spring she was asked to affirm the statement again after suggesting that diversifying the college curriculum should include diplomatic vocabulary for conversations around sexuality.
Last month she faced questions a fourth time over her Facebook post that Muslims & Christians worship THE SAME GOD. She said she was simply reiterating that there is common ground among the monotheistic Abrahamic faiths, which many theologians have said for centuries.
Here is another excellent article by Dr. Norman Geisler, an internationally known & respected Biblical scholar & textual critic on John H. Walton's book, 'The Lost World of Adam & Eve' (he is one of the main author's of this new book at Wheaton).
Book Review: The Lost World of Adam and Eve
Here is Dr. Geisler's summary & conclusion.
Summary and Conclusion
The Biblical evidence for one man Adam being the progenitor of the entire human race is strong biblically & historically. But, motivated by a “consensus” of contemporary science, some (like Walton) have attempted to REINTERPRET the biblical data to fit into a theistic evolutionary scheme.
However, a strong group of intelligent design scientists have eroded the genetic basis for macroevolution. And an examination of the strained biblical exegesis of Wheaton’s professor Walton has left the whole Biologos evolutionary dreams (to CONVERT evangelical Christianity to theistic evolution) without biblical, historical, or scientific grounds.
The Bible is clear, Adam was the “first man” (1 Cor. 15:45). And God “made from one man every nation of mankind to live on the face of the earth” (Acts 17:26). Further, “sin entered the world through one man & death through sin, so death spread to all men…[and] death reigned from Adam” on to us (Rom. 5:12-14). This is what I was taught at Wheaton a GENERATION ago & have been teaching it ever since.
However, a new generation has arisen that knows not Kantzer, Culver & Kaiser. They have convinced themselves from EXTRA-BIBLICAL SOURCES, in whose light they reinterpret the Bible, that Adam was not the first man; that his body is genetically the same as other early hominids, that all humans are not Adam’s descendants; that human death is not the result of Adam’s sin & that Darwin was basically right about common ancestry!
All I can say is that this is not the Wheaton I knew, nor is it the one to which I can recommend my grandchildren.
So no, Wheaton college is no longer considered a conservative Christian college, due to the many compromises it has made, including those above & then this thread topic of the creation-evolution controversy, seeking to try & compromise the two different world views through compromise, re-interpretation & deception in my opinion.
This is part of the great falling away before the final Antichrist appears and unites the world against God and against His Christ, the Lord Jesus. (Psalm 2; 2 Thess 2, 2 Peter 3, etc.)
Dr. Jonathan Sarfati has written a series of books refuting this evolution/creation compromise & how evolution is directly contrary to the Scriptural account of creation not just in Genesis 1 but ITS CONSISTENT TESTIMONY THROUGHOUT THE BIBLE.
Dr Jonathan D Sarfati - creation.com
Richard Dawkins debated Jonathan Sarfati only ONCE & has avoided him ever since when Sarfati soundly refuted Dawkin's evolutionary assumptions & dismissal of creationism & the Creator.
In Matt 24:24,25 Jesus warns His disciples, “False christs & false prophets will rise & show great signs & wonders to deceive, if possible, even the elect. See, I have told you beforehand.”
Can Satan Deceive God's Elect?
Here are some key critiques of Dr. John Walton & his aberrent interpretations of Scripture--who is one of the key co-authors of this new Wheaton textbook. He & others at Wheaton has linked with BioLogic, a theistic evolutionary group that has helped fund this new book, with Dr. Francis Collins as a main proponent.
Not only have they helped fund this book, but pay for Dr. Walton to travel all over to Christian colleges & seminaries primarily, to try & convince them of this TOTALLY NEW RE-INTERPRETATION of Scripture that is radically different than ancient traditional & historical Christianity concerning Biblical understanding.
Their purpose is to CONVERT us Christians to theistic evolutionary creationism (an oxymoron) & are just as fervent in their desire to do this as we Christians are to preach the BIBLICAL GOSPEL to the LOST & blinded & deceived.
We are now to supposedly re-interpret Scripture from ancient pagan, polytheistic views of the world at that time, devoid of Scriptural truth & force their pagan understanding of the world onto the Biblical revelation of God.
Theistic evolutionists have latched onto this totally new & foreign interpretation of Scripture, so that the naturalistic (devoid of God philosophy) theory of evolution & cosmology can be 'married' to God's revelation of Himself & His creation, compromising & deceiving people & supposedly making us all happy & singing, 'kumbyah.'
Review Walton the lost world of genesis one - creation.com
The Lost World of Adam and Eve: A Response
https://isgenesishistory.com/gnostic-world-of-john-walton/
Lost World of John Walton - creation.com
https://creation.com/images/pdfs/tj/j29_2/j29_2_47-51.pdf