- May 3, 2022
- 181
- 89
- 64
- Country
- United States
- Faith
- Calvinist
- Marital Status
- Divorced
I often heard this phrase on the T.V., radio, and from the pulpit. I remember hearing it at least 5-10 times a week. I can't remember the last time I heard this phrase used, at least ten years or more. This is just another example of how the E.C. world keeps moving away from Scripture and replacing Scripture truth with the "Traditions of Men."
The reality of sin and that all people, even believers, sin is now a taboo subject, to be avoided like the plague. Scripture teaches that all people are sinners and that everyone is accountable for their sins. But, the E.C. world has created the illusion that believers are a "special class" of people who are above sin or not responsible for their sin, that if you sin, it is because you have a "demon" of any particular sin and the "demon" caused your sin. Or, it is your flesh that sinned, not you, which is what Gnosticism teaches.
I have seen the movement that "Christians are not sinners" continue to grow. On the web today, 10/1/2022, I found:
The Guardian Nigeria News- A sinner is not a Christian.
Nairaland.com- A Christian is Not A Sinner, And A Sinner Is Not A Christian. "A Christian is one who does not commit sin."
The Gospel Coalition- "In Christ, I'm Not a Sinner."
Grace Harbor Ministries- "You Are No Longer A Sinner."
I have also heard from the pulpits, read articles, and watched videos teaching that living a sinless life is possible. All of this contradicts Scripture. 1 John 1:8 If we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us. Of course, some will respond with 1 John 3:6, Whosoever abideth in him sinneth not: whoever sins has not seen him nor knows him. Did John contradict himself? Of course not! Based on parsing and context, in 3:6, John taught, "Those who abide in Christ do not continue in a life of constant sin.
To say that "God hates the sin but loves the sinner" is used to convince people that God's love is "unconditional." Scripture teaches that God does hate sin and His sheep are to hate sin, but no verse reads, "God hates the sin but loves the sinner." In one sense, the phrase can be used to apply to the sheep, but in no way can it be used to include all unsaved people.
The passage used as the "proof texts" to validate the phrase is Pro 6:16-19. The phrase hinges on one word, a word not found in any original Greek text. That word is "things." In early English translations, you will find specific words in italics. This means that the words in italics are words added by translators to bring clarity to a verse. While this is mostly very helpful, it is not always correct. In this case, the word "things" changes Scripture by taking away and adding to God's Word.
The original Hebrew Scripture reads, "These six does the LORD hate, yea seven are an abomination." The KJV translators did not like what verses 17-19 taught, so they decided they needed to change the meaning. The originally written verses clearly teach that sins alone are not what God hates. By inserting the word "things," they changed the context to mean "these sins are what God hates."
Let's examine the verses. Keep in mind the Jewish people expressed themselves differently than people in the Western culture. Their choice of words is a symbolic way to describe a concrete thought. We tend to say things directly, but the Jewish people communicated with inference. If we let our dog go outside in the rain and come back in, we would say, "The dog is wet. The Jews might say, "The dog appeared as if it came out of a pond." Both come to the same conclusion but are expressed in different ways. Different cultures express themselves in different ways.
Pro 6:17 "A proud look." God does hate pride in any person (Pro 8:13). Does this verse teach that God hates a specific physical expression? Who has a proud look? Only someone arrogant. Humble people don't walk around with a "proud look." James 4:6 ...God opposes the proud but gives grace to the humble. No mention of "God hates the sin of a proud look." Neither does it say that "God hates the sin of a proud look but loves those who have a proud look."
Pro 6:17 "A lying tongue." Does this mean that God hates the physical organ known as the tongue? A tongue that tells lies? Tongues don't speak. Tongues enable people to speak. Tongues are used to speak lies. People tell lies. Liars have a "lying tongue." This is a Jewish way of saying God hates liars. This does not refer to people who tell occasional lies, lie to protect one, or not hurt another. These are ungodly people who live a life of lying, who lie to deny guilt, lie to cause harm to another or lie to start trouble. This is why there is no commandment, "Thou shalt not lie." Because in the world of man, there are times when it is necessary to lie to protect others. The midwives in Exodus and Rahab are two examples. Judges 3:12-30, 4:16-23, 1Sam 19:9-18. None of these people were condemned by God or accused of doing wrong for lying. No mention of "God hates the sin of a lying tongue but loves those who have a lying tongue."
Pro 6:17 "Hands that shed innocent blood." Again, is this verse teach that God hates the "physical hands" of those who shed innocent blood?" Or is He talking about those who use their hands to shed innocent blood, murderers?
Pro 6:18 An heart (mind) that not simply devises wicked plans but puts the plans into action. Feet that are quick to run to get involved with evil acts. All of the verses up till now show how attitude, thoughts, and the different parts of the body are all used to sin. In Mat 5:29-30, Jesus taught don't use our body parts to sin. Once again, no mention that God hates the sins of those who use their mind to devise wicked plans or their feet to run to evil but loves them. In this passage, the word "sin" or "sins" is never used. There is no mention that God loves these people.
Pro 6:19 Now the focus switches from aspects of the body to actual people, a false witness and one that sows discord among brothers! These aren't "things," and these aren't only sins! These are the people that commit these sins! You can't get around this fact! Unless you don't like or believe what Scripture says. There is a big difference between saying you disagree with or don't like what Scripture says and denying what Scripture says. These verses are in all translations.
The KJV has influenced many other English translations. While the KJV versions and the NKJV still print "things" in italics, many different versions print "things" in regular type, leading people to believe that the word "things" is part of the original text. I find that very dishonest, don't you? In conclusion, no Scripture teaching proclaims, "God hates the sin, but loves the sinner."
The reality of sin and that all people, even believers, sin is now a taboo subject, to be avoided like the plague. Scripture teaches that all people are sinners and that everyone is accountable for their sins. But, the E.C. world has created the illusion that believers are a "special class" of people who are above sin or not responsible for their sin, that if you sin, it is because you have a "demon" of any particular sin and the "demon" caused your sin. Or, it is your flesh that sinned, not you, which is what Gnosticism teaches.
I have seen the movement that "Christians are not sinners" continue to grow. On the web today, 10/1/2022, I found:
The Guardian Nigeria News- A sinner is not a Christian.
Nairaland.com- A Christian is Not A Sinner, And A Sinner Is Not A Christian. "A Christian is one who does not commit sin."
The Gospel Coalition- "In Christ, I'm Not a Sinner."
Grace Harbor Ministries- "You Are No Longer A Sinner."
I have also heard from the pulpits, read articles, and watched videos teaching that living a sinless life is possible. All of this contradicts Scripture. 1 John 1:8 If we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us. Of course, some will respond with 1 John 3:6, Whosoever abideth in him sinneth not: whoever sins has not seen him nor knows him. Did John contradict himself? Of course not! Based on parsing and context, in 3:6, John taught, "Those who abide in Christ do not continue in a life of constant sin.
To say that "God hates the sin but loves the sinner" is used to convince people that God's love is "unconditional." Scripture teaches that God does hate sin and His sheep are to hate sin, but no verse reads, "God hates the sin but loves the sinner." In one sense, the phrase can be used to apply to the sheep, but in no way can it be used to include all unsaved people.
The passage used as the "proof texts" to validate the phrase is Pro 6:16-19. The phrase hinges on one word, a word not found in any original Greek text. That word is "things." In early English translations, you will find specific words in italics. This means that the words in italics are words added by translators to bring clarity to a verse. While this is mostly very helpful, it is not always correct. In this case, the word "things" changes Scripture by taking away and adding to God's Word.
The original Hebrew Scripture reads, "These six does the LORD hate, yea seven are an abomination." The KJV translators did not like what verses 17-19 taught, so they decided they needed to change the meaning. The originally written verses clearly teach that sins alone are not what God hates. By inserting the word "things," they changed the context to mean "these sins are what God hates."
Let's examine the verses. Keep in mind the Jewish people expressed themselves differently than people in the Western culture. Their choice of words is a symbolic way to describe a concrete thought. We tend to say things directly, but the Jewish people communicated with inference. If we let our dog go outside in the rain and come back in, we would say, "The dog is wet. The Jews might say, "The dog appeared as if it came out of a pond." Both come to the same conclusion but are expressed in different ways. Different cultures express themselves in different ways.
Pro 6:17 "A proud look." God does hate pride in any person (Pro 8:13). Does this verse teach that God hates a specific physical expression? Who has a proud look? Only someone arrogant. Humble people don't walk around with a "proud look." James 4:6 ...God opposes the proud but gives grace to the humble. No mention of "God hates the sin of a proud look." Neither does it say that "God hates the sin of a proud look but loves those who have a proud look."
Pro 6:17 "A lying tongue." Does this mean that God hates the physical organ known as the tongue? A tongue that tells lies? Tongues don't speak. Tongues enable people to speak. Tongues are used to speak lies. People tell lies. Liars have a "lying tongue." This is a Jewish way of saying God hates liars. This does not refer to people who tell occasional lies, lie to protect one, or not hurt another. These are ungodly people who live a life of lying, who lie to deny guilt, lie to cause harm to another or lie to start trouble. This is why there is no commandment, "Thou shalt not lie." Because in the world of man, there are times when it is necessary to lie to protect others. The midwives in Exodus and Rahab are two examples. Judges 3:12-30, 4:16-23, 1Sam 19:9-18. None of these people were condemned by God or accused of doing wrong for lying. No mention of "God hates the sin of a lying tongue but loves those who have a lying tongue."
Pro 6:17 "Hands that shed innocent blood." Again, is this verse teach that God hates the "physical hands" of those who shed innocent blood?" Or is He talking about those who use their hands to shed innocent blood, murderers?
Pro 6:18 An heart (mind) that not simply devises wicked plans but puts the plans into action. Feet that are quick to run to get involved with evil acts. All of the verses up till now show how attitude, thoughts, and the different parts of the body are all used to sin. In Mat 5:29-30, Jesus taught don't use our body parts to sin. Once again, no mention that God hates the sins of those who use their mind to devise wicked plans or their feet to run to evil but loves them. In this passage, the word "sin" or "sins" is never used. There is no mention that God loves these people.
Pro 6:19 Now the focus switches from aspects of the body to actual people, a false witness and one that sows discord among brothers! These aren't "things," and these aren't only sins! These are the people that commit these sins! You can't get around this fact! Unless you don't like or believe what Scripture says. There is a big difference between saying you disagree with or don't like what Scripture says and denying what Scripture says. These verses are in all translations.
The KJV has influenced many other English translations. While the KJV versions and the NKJV still print "things" in italics, many different versions print "things" in regular type, leading people to believe that the word "things" is part of the original text. I find that very dishonest, don't you? In conclusion, no Scripture teaching proclaims, "God hates the sin, but loves the sinner."