It is impossible to be obedient without Christ.
Yes! "Apart from Me you can do nothing." This is the essence of the New Covenant. And this is exactly the truth Adam missed.
So regarding salvation are you saying, as the Catholics seems to imply, that faith in Christ means trust in Christ to help you do good works which will qualify you to be saved?
If salvation is contingent upon works - yes even works of faith - then one's faith is in those works to save them. Such a soteriology is faith in works. In fact if such were the case one couldn't actually obey many of the commands. For most of the commands in the New Testament have to do with attitude. For example if you take something like "love you neighbor as yourself", if a person does so in order to be saved, as with the faith in works soteriology, one does not do so in love seeing as love is not love if self-interest is involved. Such Christians will try to appear to love, but in fact they're just acting in their own self-interest.
We need to stand back and look at the big picture in all this. What is God meaning to accomplish with His creation? In some theologies God basically created man to inevitably sin, blamed him for sinning anyway, and at some later date places some of us worthless wretches in heaven and the rest in hell. Pretty much end of story. The heaven-bound elect were the fortunate predestined ones while the reprobate obviously not so fortunate.
In Catholic theology God created man as a noble and beautiful creature made in His own image (pretty much not contradicted at this point by most theologies) who failed to live up to the potential he was made for (a failure we can all readily observe in ourselves and others in this world daily). And God, knowing this would occur of course, had an overall plan in place from the beginning. From the larger perspective He had made His world in a "state of journeying towards an ultimate perfection” as the Catholic Catechism teaches. He had a plan-to
produce something, something even better than He started with presumably. So all the intervening centuries of human joy and misery: pain and sin and suffering and death, between Eden and now make sense; it has a purpose, the purpose of helping educate us to receive Him, to develop a hunger and thirst for goodness and righteousness and for all that we missed by dismissing and abandoning
Him, when the time was ripe. Man needs to realize just how much he needs God.
So is God’s purpose really to suddenly
ignore justice in His wayward creation with the advent of Christ, by imputing that justice forensically? Or has his purpose always been to
restore that justice, but in the right way finally?
Love is the true measure of man’s justice or righteousness. So Jesus gives us the Greatest Commandments, the first echoing Deut 6:5:
“Love the LORD your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength.”
And the second applying that love also to neighbor
“Love your neighbor as yourself.”
All the other commandments are based on these two. And all the other commandments are fulfilled in these two.
And God is saying, with the Cross, “This is how much I love you, this is what I would endure for you, now do the same.”
“We love Him because He first loved us.” 1 John 4:19
And, “I forgive all, now do the same”
“For if you forgive other people when they sin against you, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. But if you do not forgive others their sins, your Father will not forgive your sins.” Matt 6:14-15
From the beginning God has been patiently working to bring man to this point, to the point of love. Had Adam been ready, had he chosen this path in Eden, perhaps characterized by eating of the Tree of Life instead of the other, our history could’ve presumably been very different. And yet we know it could’ve only gone the way it has.
Anyway, faith is meant to lead to this justice, this righteousness, this love, as faith re-establishes or constitutes communion with God who
is love. We’re saved by faith,
via faith,
through faith. James was essentially saying that if faith doesn’t lead to and produce that kind of love then it remains dormant, dead, unproductive. Because love always
acts, by its nature, producing the kind of behavior such as that which I mentioned in post #72. And Paul, likewise, understood well that love is the core and apex of the Christian faith as Rom 13 and especially 1 Cor 13 demonstrate. But love is easily overlooked and dismissed, as even God, Himself, is easily enough dismissed from Eden on, truth be known.
“These people pay Me lip-service but their hearts are far from Me.” Is 29:13
So I can be circumcised, baptized, properly catechized and finally nicely eulogized after a life of obeying the commandants perfectly and even having a faith that can move mountains but if I have not love,
I am nothing, Paul tells us. Augustine put it this way, “Without love faith may indeed exist, but avails nothing.”
And consider this interesting truth. The Greatest Commandments are the only ones that
cannot be faked, or done for the wrong reasons
. I can obey all the others for all the wrong reasons but if I truly obey the command to love then I’ve “arrived”; my justice is complete. Love isn’t love if it’s pretended. The other commandments show us what love should “look like”. They just cannot cause us to love as we should; the Law cannot justify; only God can do that. “Apart from me you can do nothing.” And Basil of Cesarea, a 3rd century bishop, had this to say:
“If we turn away from evil out of fear of punishment, we are in the position of slaves. If we pursue the enticement of wages, . . . we resemble mercenaries. Finally if we obey for the sake of the good itself and out of love for Him who commands . . . we are in the position of children.”
Anyway, we cannot assume that faith will lead to justice or righteousness without our continuous willing cooperation and participation in walking in that justice. Otherwise we’d be burying our talents. Faith does not replace righteous or justice in us, or stand in for it, or excuse us from the need for it, rather it’s the
beginning of justice, the doorway to it because it’s the doorway to God.