Punishment would entail indiscriminately bombing the populace.
Collective punishment includes enforcing a blockade on Gaza which, obviously, means indiscriminately & collectively punishing the entire population for VOTING FOR HAMAS. What happened to Israel being the "only democracy in the Middle East"? On the one hand it's the only democracy, but when others try to play by the rules of the West when it comes to democracy, they're punished.
Do you realize how insane this is?
The hypocrites: "Yes, yes, please come out and vote. We love democracy and pretend to be the beacon of democracy in this region."
Palestinians: "Ok, I guess we'll give it a try."
*Hamas wins*
The hypocrites: "YOU IDIOTS. HOW DARE YOU VOTE FOR HAMAS? Yeah, we SAY we want democracy but we really wanted and expected Fatah to win. Because you democratically voted for the wrong party, we're going to punish you guys."
Bombing rocket ramps and Hamas facilities does not qualify as indiscriminate bombing.
If Hamas doesn't want to be bombed to dust and wants to help its populace, then it should cease firing rockets into Israel.
Israel should lift the siege on Gaza and stop attacking Gaza based on lie after lie.
Sure. Hamas is honest and Israel lies. You say this because Hamas is Muslim and Israel are unbelievers?
No, I say this because Israel's track record has proven that they are some of the most cunning & deceptive people I have ever seen. It would scare me if I didn't know God or His Attributes or His Words.
"And say, "Truth has come, and falsehood has departed. Indeed is falsehood, [by nature], ever bound to depart." (al-Israa 17:81)
Here are some lies told by the Israeli government just in this current massacre alone:
1.) The Israeli illegal settlers were still "missing" (they knew they were dead).
2.) That Hamas was to blame for their deaths. (It has since come to light that it was not Hamas but, instead, a few rogue Palestinians from the West Bank.)
3.) That they attacked Gaza trying to "rescue" those "missing" (they already knew the teens were found dead in the West Bank).
4.) That Hamas, by capturing one of Israel's soldiers after the start of the 72-hour ceasefire, broke the ceasefire & that's why Israel was attacking the Rafah area (Hamas right away denied this and Israel admitted that the soldier died before the ceasefire. Furthermore, why was that soldier in Gaza detonating tunnels when there was a ceasefire?)
^These are off the top of my head.
When both parties claim the truth, then it's nice to look at the actual profit of war. Israel does not profit - it's a costly operation and an economy of Israel would much rather profit from a strong economic partner in Gaza and the West Bank.
Hamas, on the other hand, uses this perpetual state of war to cool their own religious lust for death and also to keep themselves in power.
Even if there is no benefit to the massacre for the Israeli government, maybe they're just evil and bloodthirsty.
Trying to undermine the unity government is a clear benefit. Intimidating the population is another (though Israel should know by now that the Palestinian spirit can't be broken).
Hamas broke all the cease fire agreements in this conflict. Even Arab news outlets have been reluctantly reporting this fact.
...No. I believe I pasted links on this thread about how Israel itself now admits that the "captured" soldier was killed in battle before the ceasefire began so they attacked Rafah based on yet another lie.
Actually there WERE warnings asking them to clear the area and steer free from it after bombing runs.
So why did none of these people know about this supposed warning? Why did they go out running in their pajamas? Why did the woman frantically rushing from the area say that they were hit without warning?
Israel has told the populace of the North to evacuate to the South when they performed bombing runs there.
Gaza is small, but we both know it is not a "giant prison with nowhere to hide".
'There's Really Nowhere Safe To Go' In Gaza
Gaza Family Moves 2 Times, But Can't Escape The Bombs
Dad Relives Israeli Strike in Gaza That Wiped Out His Family - NBC News
The ones who moved deep into Gaza City as Israel recommends were not safe either. They were attacked. Even when they go to places that should be safe (schools designated as UN shelters, deep into Gaza city, beaches, etc), they're still not safe. So, really, it is a giant prison (Israel controls Gaza's land, air, and sea) with no where to hide.
The time will not come until Muslims will fight the Jews (and kill them); until the Jews hide behind rocks and trees, which will cry: O Muslim! there is a Jew hiding behind me, come on and kill him! This will not apply to the Gharqad, which is a Jewish tree
That's not calling for the extermination of the Jews. They're just relating a prophecy about the end times. Here are two narrations with slightly different wording about the same event from the same works that Hamas used:
Abdullah b. 'Umar reported that Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) said: The Jews will fight against you and you will gain victory over them until the stone would say: Muslim, here is a Jew behind me; kill him. [Saheeh Muslim]
Narrated 'Abdullah bin 'Umar: I heard Allah's Apostle saying, "The Jews will fight with you, and you will be given victory over them so that a stone will say, 'O Muslim! There is a Jew behind me; kill him!'" [Saheeh al-Bukhaari]
Clearly it's referring to those who are fighting against them.
2.) Obviously this is a prophecy about the end times & it's miracles because we're referring to talking trees and stones here!
In closing: free your mind. How does Israel profit from this ongoing conflict? Why disengage from Gaza and then go back in 9 years later? Why spend 100.000 on every rocket that's fired from Hamas?
Because they can?
Try to think rationally instead of swallowing what you are taught. If Allah is loving, then he would not advocate the killing of unbelievers.
I do hope you have a chance to read what Jesus teaches about those who persecute you - maybe you will find that it is more Godly than those primordial human instincts that tell us to kill those who attack us of the Mohammedan ideology.
Wasn't Jesus (peace be upon him), according to Christians since you believe he's God, the one who ordered people to destroy entire cities including children and babies as revenge for the Israelites being waylaid on their way from Egypt? Islaam does not teach this either about Jesus or God.
Islaam DOES say that we have the right to defend ourselves (thank God) but never that we can slaughter entire nations including their elderly, their women, their children, or their infants.