Actually, if you really think about it, bringing up past atrocities to point out current hyprocies is a failure of logic. Current atrocities apply to current atrocities, this would equate to current hypocriesy.
How did the american Indians treat each other? Were Indian lands decided in group hugs? If you want to throw logic out the door let's do some real research.
So while were tossing logic out the window, why dont we ignore the Hopis. If folks are throwing around the popular snide attack on islam, scare quoting religion of peace, then I am going to be less than generous in my assessment of our country's own actions. It's not like we have recognized our mistake and given back any lands that we took from the tribes. Heck, that would be impractical and, after all, that stuff is in the past!
And slavery, that has nothing to do with discrimination today, that's in the past!
And segregation, that has nothing to do with racial disparities today, that's in the past!
And extraordinary rendition of prisones in order to have lackies torture them for us, that has nothing to do with today, talk about old news!
How recent does an atrocity have to be before you admit that America has just about zero moral capital in the world? Heck, almost every other developed country in the world has outlawed the death penalty, and here we are quibbling over whether Somalia is correct in deciding what crimes deserve barbaric treatment? Sorry dude, I'm not gonna knuckle under to the argument "indians were violent too", you'll need to do a lot better.