Lets assume that your interpretation is right....Christmas is a pagan holiday that has nothing to do with Jesus.
Hmmm. I would say that the Lord can redeem anything....that which was meant for evil God can redeem for GOOD. Christmas offers up a time for christians to point a sin sick weary world to Christ in a way that most non christians will be able to hear. It gives us a time to reflect more attention and thought to the great gift God gave us in His Son, Jesus.
To address your issues:
"Greed where there is paucity,
gluttony where there is starvation,
giving where there is no need
and ignoring need elsewhere ,
rampant commercialism, mammon
pagan rituals to a fertility god,"
Greed is a matter of heart. You can not presume to know someone's heart. Many people give in abundance at Christmas and other times throughout the year. There is no sin in gift giving. The sin is when someone lusts, covets, or nurtures greed. It doesn't take a holiday for people to do that. Check out the sunday ads.
Gluttony is also a matter of heart. Our Christmas meal is oftentimes the same as any other Sunday meal. Thanksgiving is more a holiday about overeating than Christmas...but it is not a law that one must over indulge. Again, gluttony is not confined to one or two specific holidays. The jewish high holy days and feast days were celebrated by eating, drinking, and celebrating and you advocate them.....celebration is not a sin. God tells us to celebrate. In as far as ignoring needs, we as a family do not, and I am sure there are more that do not than that do. We assist with the soup kitchen, we give to charities, we send monies overseas to missionaries and charities that work with the children that have nothing. And we do it 365 days a year. I suppose I am guilty to an extent to giving gifts where there is no need, as very few of us have any REAL needs. We are a very blessed country in the US, so perhaps it is now a sin to live in a country that is blessed with such abundance?? Gift giving in the bible WAS done as a way to show honor, respect, and love to another person. There is nothing wrong with giving gifts.
The rampant commercialism is a problem. We attempt to stay away from it as much as possible, and give many homemade gifts, or practical gifts as possible. I will concede on the point that Christmas has become overcommercialized.
I believe if you look for evil you will find evil. If you look for good, you will find good. You talk about pagan symbols of trees, evergreens, lights. We talk about how the tree represents the cross that Christ came to die on for our sins. We talk about how the evergreen represents everlasting life, and the circle of the wreath talks of eternity. We discuss the lights that we see as being the Light of Christ, and how we are to be the light of the world. We try to honor Christ in all that we do during the holidays, ( as at all times) and to that end, we step up our giving as much as we are able to give to our neighbors who do have needs.
You presume that everyone blindly follows Christmas as prescribed by the world. I would like to submit to you that some (maybe most) celebrate Christ's birth, His gift, and His sacrifice for His children.
Its all about your heart. Where is our heart in any given matter??
Anyway, my 2c.
Blessings,
Tammy