Poll: What is Scott Roeder guilty of?

[EvangelicalChristian]

no, it was quite right, quite logical.. unlike many of the comments here at this forum.. Yikes..!

lack of logic is SO boring.. among other things..

So ... you agree that what tiller did was wrong. Excellent.

\

Try this logic

It's wrong to take human life so we are going to take the lives of those who do.

Can you find fallacy?

 

[SithDoughnut]

why am i reminded of that psg in the Bible about the "accuser of the brethren"??

Whatever you do to the least of My brethren, that you do unto Me (Jesus).. St Mt 25:31

tiller is gone.. so now you all can direct your charity (assuming you're capable of it) toward those of us who wish to discuss this problem of abortion and .. etc..

​

Insults? Check. Dodging the evidence? Check.

Are you going to address the evidence now, or is your superiority complex too hard to get over? Your Catechism, your bishops and your church says the murder was bad. You're free to hold your own opinion but please don't lie and pretend that other people agree with you.

 

[SithDoughnut]

already have, since you haven't been paying attention..

imagine that.. 2 people read the same thing & come up with 2 totally different POVs... hmmm.. where have i seen this kind of thing b4??

hmmm... let me see....

Oh, yea... i know where!!!

45,000 Christian (and "christian) denominations... yes... now i remember...

45,000 different interpretations of the Word of God...

and only one right one... that coming from the Roman Catholic Church, founded by Jesus Christ ..

...Which says that what Roeder did was wrong. You've now successfully started to argue against yourself.

 

[Rilke's Granddaughter]

all liars will have their part in the lake of fire...

Bring a life-preserver. I suspect you're going to need it.

But the fact remains:

You say that murder is wrong.

Roeder committed murder.

Therefore you say that Roeder was wrong.

The Magisterium says Roeder was wrong.

The Catechism says Roeder was wrong.

And you're a hypocrite, since you do nothing whatsoever to help prevent abortions except whine about it.

 

[outOftheLoop]

\

Try this logic

It's wrong to take human life so we are going to take the lives of those who do.

?

so if someone killed one of your loved ones (or lets say more than one) just for kicks, you wouldn't want that person executed?

i belive in captial punishment for serial murderers (Bundy, Dahmer, Tiller)

 

[pgp_protector]

this is what i would have done if i had been Roeder. i would have asked Tiller to go out for a cup of coffee. Then i would try to convert him to the truth that babies are human and c reated in God's image and ask that he please stop murdering them... words to this affect..

If he didn't listen to that... & continued to abort well, what Roeder did was logical and lawful in the eyes of God..

i am too much of a coward to do soemthing like that.. but at least i ADMIT it..

others just hide behind the "it wasn't legal" nonsense...

& come across as though the unborn are less than fully human...

so how long tell fstdt?

 

[SithDoughnut]

so if someone killed one of your loved ones (or lets say more than one) just for kicks, you wouldn't want that person executed?

i belive in captial punishment for serial murderers (Bundy, Dahmer, Tiller)

That's nice. What Roeder did wasn't Capital Punishment though. Capital Punishment involves a trial, for a start.

 

[pgp_protector]

.

naa to easy, not worth the warning

 

[EvangelicalChristian]

already have, since you haven't been paying attention..

imagine that.. 2 people read the same thing & come up with 2 totally different POVs... hmmm.. where have i seen this kind of thing b4??

hmmm... let me see....

Oh, yea... i know where!!!

45,000 Christian (and "christian) denominations... yes... now i remember...

45,000 different interpretations of the Word of God...

and only one right one... that coming from the Roman Catholic Church, founded by Jesus Christ ..

Both your Catechism and the Bishops of your Church have condemned what Roeder did. It seems to me you are the one opposed to Catholic teaching not the denominations represented in this discussion.

 

[outOftheLoop]

Bring a life-preserver. I suspect you're going to need it.

But the fact remains:

You say that murder is wrong.

Roeder committed murder.

Therefore you say that Roeder was wrong.

The Magisterium says Roeder was wrong.

The Catechism says Roeder was wrong.

And you're a hypocrite, since you do nothing whatsoever to help prevent abortions except whine about it.

you really need help..

You need Jesus... Only he can heal you of your hatred of me.. exhibited through your accusing me of things you know to be untrue.. putting words in the mouth of a Church you don't begin to understand or belong to... I could go on and on... but you really do need ... something...

you need someone... Jesus...

 

[outOftheLoop]

Both your Catechism and the Bishops of your Church have condemned what Roeder did. It seems to me you are the one opposed to Catholic teaching not the denominations represented in this discussion.

totally untrue but you can go on believing lies if you want.. free country

 

[EvangelicalChristian]

so if someone killed one of your loved ones (or lets say more than one) just for kicks, you wouldn't want that person executed?

No I wouldn't.

i belive in captial punishment for serial murderers (Bundy, Dahmer, Tiller)

You are welcome to believe what you wish but don't complain when your illogical conclusions are exposed as they have been several times.

 

[SithDoughnut]

you really need help..

You need Jesus... Only he can heal you of your hatred of me.. exhibited through your accusing me of things you know to be untrue.. putting words in the mouth of a Church you don't begin to understand or belong to... I could go on and on... but you really do need ... something...

you need someone... Jesus...

Come on, if you're going to keep attempted to dodge the evidence then we'll be forced to conclude that you've conceded the argument. Which would be interesting, as that rarely happens with these discussions.

 

[SithDoughnut]

totally untrue but you can go on believing lies if you want.. free country

Paragraph 2263. You going to address it yet?

 

[outOftheLoop]

You said that the Catholic Church was the right church. The Catholic Church disagrees with you. Therefore, you just said that you are not in agreement with what is correct, ergo, you are wrong.

?

quit spreading lies. the Catholic Church does not disagree...

and you haven't even attempted to prove otherwise..

even you don't believe your own nonsense..

 

[EvangelicalChristian]

totally untrue but you can go on believing lies if you want.. free country

The Catechism has already been shown to you several times so this one will suffice for your Bishops.

Catholic bishops condemn Tiller slaying :: Catholic News Agency (CNA)

 

[ChrisBot]

This thread was split automatically after 1000 replies and this thread has been automatically closed.
The new thread automatically created is here: "Poll: What is Scott Roeder guilty of? (2)"