You know, I find that fascinating because statistically, you are much more likely to be wronged by someone who believes in some kind of God (probably your same God), just by the shear number of people who do.
Personally, I don't trust anyone outside my family and the few other people I know well. Theist or not, you shouldn't trust random people just because they belong to your same group.
Oh I don't take anything on here personal. I have very little confidence you know enough about evolution to try and explain atheism or theism from such a POV.