I have a family of tree frogs that have taken up residence in my windchimes. They often poke their heads out around dusk. Amphibians and reptiles were never animals that bothered me, as I used to catch them as a kid, keep them in this awesome terrarium that a friend and I had built out of a kiddie pool, and then release them back into the wild after a week. We did this with frogs, red eared slider & softshell turtles, and even a baby alligator once.
The animals I dislike are spiders and bats. A bat got into my room once in upstate New York and flew right at me and I freaked out, sad thing was it was probably only flying at me because it was trying to escape.