whitedove7 wrote:
To touch, there is imagination or fantacy going on the perform. Does anyone touch with an empty mind with no thought or image? I don't think so. Can you say that having your mind filled with imagination or fantacy to help you touch is of God? No!
Question: Would a person touch in front of the Lord? I'm sure everyone's answer would be no.
God made sex a private matter. But .. He's not embarrassed about it and it comes up a lot in His word. The highest concentration of sexual imagery within marriage is what some have called an R-rated book (particularly if you learn the imagery), the
Song of Solomon, but it's one intended for heterosexual married people for sure. We should all know that God blesses people with marriage and within that even commands regular sexual relations (1 Cor 7:5). Of course, He also blesses others with gifts of celibacy.
Now, given that masturbation is not specifically mentioned in the Word (unlike adultery, inappropriate behavior with animals, prostitution, debauchery, fornication and homosexuality ...), being dogmatically against (or for) it is adding to what we God has given us. The best we can do is ask questions about the heart of one doing it, as you have. But when we do that, we run the risk of projecting what we think someone is thinking or feeling into their lives without knowing that for a fact.
Without getting specific and graphic it's hard to describe situations where masturbation would not involve moral compromise, but I've known situation where they definitely existed within marriage.
While the problem is hardly a male-only one, men do have more problem with this because in their bodies is a built-in manufacturing of sperm and sperm. Some years ago, a friend and I were reflecting upon the sexual state of 16-18 year old boys and said, quite accurately, that they are (as we were) "walking sperm cells"
. The Bible is
not silent about this bodily function which God created; the Law of Moses has several mentions of male emissions (Lev 15:16, 15:18. 15:32, 22:4, Deut 23:10) and it is treated in the Law in much the same way as a woman's monthly period.
These Biblically-addressed "nocturnal emissions", which take place via so-called "wet dreams" are part of many if not most men's lives, and if that's "fantasy" then we're all accountable for our dreams. Women have dreams like this too. And, when the dreams are recalled (many are not), it's hard to distinguish the thought life and even the action from masturbation.
Now, "sexual malpractice" (for lack of better term) as a general topic has been a major problem with humankind since God created it, but He did create us man and woman, with the capacity and desire for sexual intimacy and blessed the act with great pleasure. The misuse and pollution of the pure gift we've been given is a sin, but one that can be forgiven, repented of, and blissfully redeemed in marriage.