On the understanding that we are dealing here with a hypothetical, and much of how pastoral conversations unfold depends on the person concerned, I can say some things.
One is that if someone is talking about compulsion, that is a red flag around possible mental health issues. So no matter what else I did, I'd probably suggest that they see their doctor for a mental health check in general.
Another is identifying what the issue is for the person. It sounds as if their driving concern, as you have framed it, is not sex or sexuality or even questions of morality, but anxiety around feeling out of control. That would be something to explore and find out what's at the root of that.
I would probably want to explore with them - since they'd come to a priest, after all - whether they were a Christian, and how they understood this compulsion in relation to their faith. That might include any combination of prayer/exploring Scripture/pastoral conversation etc. I would be open to hearing their confession, if asked. (I don't generally suggest confession to someone in a first conversation, but it's not off the table from my point of view).
If this bill became law where I am, I do not believe it would make any difference to helping such a person, because I wouldn't see trying to "make them straight" as my aim.
That said, I have literally never had a pastoral conversation with someone which came anywhere close to this. The overriding pastoral issue I see with same-sex attracted people is a sense of shame so overwhelming that they believe themselves beyond God's love and grace. Much of my work is helping them to realise that God's arms are always open to them.
Thanks for answering, yes its a purely hypothetical scenario and I agree that how to proceed would depend to a considerable extent on how the pastoral conversation went and any leading the Holy Spirit might give. I do take your concerns on board as to the need for good practice and to remind people they can come to God in repentance through faith in Jesus Christ.
Upvote
0