Heard on NPR yesterday: "What's Behind Romania's Church Building Spree?"

Barky

Member
Site Supporter
Mar 21, 2008
867
87
37
Philadelphia, USA
✟24,242.00
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
hello all.

I heard this segment yesterday on NPR and was quite shocked. Article here: What's Behind Romania's Church Building Spree? : NPR

Is there any proof connected to this man's claim about Romanian Orthodox Clergy? Or is it hearsay?

snippet from the article:

ANDREI CODRESCU, BYLINE: Romania's phony tumble from communism to something called first, democracy, then original democracy, then just plain old Balkan morass, looks like it has finally found its form by adding churchness to the mix. Romanian Orthodox churches and priests are perfect exemplars of their country's past. In the fascist era before the Second World War, the priests were enthusiastic boosters of dictators and haters of all minorities, especially Jews and gypsies. In the communist era, a good many priests became willing collaborators of Securitate, the dreaded secret police, by reporting what they heard at confession.

Far from being the honorable opposition to communism that was the Catholic church in Poland, the Romanian church served its temporal masters with eagerness. Religion that Karl Marx called the opium of the people did its best here to live up to its name. After the revolution of 1989, the church started campaigning for a national cathedral intended to rival Nicolae Ceausescu's grandiose House of the People, the grand kitsch palace that bankrupted Romania in the 1980s.

Among the charges leveled against that dictator was his architectural megalomania that demolished old neighborhoods of Bucharest to make room for monuments to his power. Opposition to that project came from intellectuals who hoped that Romania's joining the European Union would bring with it a sense of proportion. As it turns out, joining the EU did not bring with it either architectural taste or a substantial change in living standards.

Instead, a growing mass of newly impoverished people turned to the church for miracles and comfort. Opinion polls showed that the church and the army were the most trusted institutions of post-communist Romania. So here come the monuments again and the parades. But these are not the old days. There are new opportunities: building contracts to be awarded, politicians to reward. The Orthodox Church gives the masses what they crave: churches on every block and renewed sermons about the grandeur of the nation, liberally sprinkled with good old anti-Semitism and anti-Roma sentiment and, for something extra, a dash of anti-European, anti-enlightenment propaganda. It's the unbeatable formula of post-communism: high-grade opium.
 

isshinwhat

Pro Deo et Patria
Apr 12, 2002
8,338
624
Visit site
✟13,555.00
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Well, the Romanian Priest who Chrismated my family is one of the most kind, open, and caring, yet also authentically masculine men I have had the pleasure of befriending. His wife's father was a priest during the Communist era, and Presbytera has told stories of the police coming to visit the house to interrogate her father, and of him sneaking to perform Sacraments. Did priests break the seal of Confession and were there some who were in reality government agents instead of agents of God? I am sure, but I also know there were many faithful men who gave their lives or otherwise suffered for Christ's Church. As a Jew growing up in Communist Romania, I'm sure he was privy to mostly the bad. May God show him the good.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

AV1

Junior Member
Jul 25, 2013
164
14
Michigan
✟15,355.00
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
Always consider the source. NPR has certain leanings politically and socially.

Having said that, look at the material. Ceausescu is being lumped in with Orthodox Church...on what manner of standards?! The House of the People and its construction is the same as a fundraiser for a Church? Absolutely ridiculous analogy.

As for his "architectural megalomania" which is accurate, how is the Church's desire for a beautiful Church related to self edification? It is for God's glory, not man's.

Here is the crux of the analysis:

"Instead, a growing mass of newly impoverished people turned to the church for miracles and comfort."

and

"The Orthodox Church gives the masses what they crave: churches on every block and renewed sermons about the grandeur of the nation, liberally sprinkled with good old anti-Semitism and anti-Roma sentiment and, for something extra, a dash of anti-European, anti-enlightenment propaganda. It's the unbeatable formula of post-communism..."

The idea being that turning to religion in general is foolish for an enlightened and free people, and specifically...that if that religion is Christian, it is by default anti-semetic, anti-intelligent (because it doesn't like the European model of governance), if it is Orthodox it is anti Roman-Catholic, and if it is former Eastern Block...it will revert to totalitarianism via a theocracy.

So you see, the idea is that only western thought, free of Christianity, is the way to run a country, and the people cannot be "right" if the majority of them are believer's in anything but the trends of the day.

Absolute hogwash.
 
Upvote 0

E.C.

Well-Known Member
Jan 12, 2007
13,761
1,279
✟136,658.00
Country
United States
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Single
I'm beginning to adopt more of the mind of one of my classmates that NPR is run by Communists.

If the people want churches let them build churches. If they believe in miracles than good. Just because it is not of the same militant secularism (I'd dare say anti-Christian) mindset as the rest of the EU doesn't make it "wrong".
 
Upvote 0

buzuxi02

Veteran
May 14, 2006
8,608
2,513
New York
✟212,454.00
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Single
Perfect example of propaganda. During communism attempts were made with some success to infiltrate the church with secret government agents t co-opt it. In Russia for example KGB agents were placed as priests, this happened to all religous organizations. Thats why there was a thriving catacomb church. Even the protestants such as the Pentecostals secretly met in forests to avoid infiltration.

The legitimate clergy were victims of the pseudo priest agents being spied on to make sure they didnt partake in anti-government activities.

As far as the rest of the article we have already dscussed this ad nauseum. That in traditional Orthodox countries seperation of Church and state is not the ideal and is rejected by the majority . That its not viewed as a virtue but as a vice, and its basically unheard of. In fact, in Orthodoxy democracy is not viewed in a positive light neither.

As you can see, the article is quite arrogant, as the author automatically assumes "his way" is the only right way. That the way of life that he is accustomed to and conditioned to believe is the only right way, and should be forced upon every European nation even though they are radicaly different culturally. Through the prism of traditional Orthodox nations the western practises are absurd an something not ideal in emulating.
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums