Genetic Evidence supports Irish myth of Spanish descent

Quid est Veritas?

In Memoriam to CS Lewis
Feb 27, 2016
7,319
9,272
South Africa
✟316,433.00
Faith
Protestant
Marital Status
Married
In the mediaeval period, the Irish created a famous book of stories called the Invasions of Ireland, which had tales of 6 great takings of Ireland by various mythic peoples like the Firbolg and the Fomorians, before the last bunch, the Milesians, finally arrived. It is a fantastic mix of Christian and Pagan stories, with the penultimate race of Tuatha de Danaan likely being euhemerism of the old pagan Irish gods.

Now the story goes that the Milesians were living in Spain, in Galicia specifically, when they spotted Ireland from a tower. They then proceed to tell tales of its conquest. Earlier it tells them migrating gradually from Maeotis (roughly the Sea of Azov) around the Mediterranean to Spain. In mediaeval and early modern times it was taken as a fanciful account but with some truth to it, before we eventually discarded the whole as spurious.

Interestingly I ran across this the other day:
DNA study reveals Ireland's age of 'god-kings'

Specifically: "Ireland's Neolithic inhabitants traced their origins to an expansion of people out of Anatolia (modern Turkey) around 6,000-7,000 years ago. This migration transformed Europe's way of life from one focused on hunting to one based on agriculture. Genetically, Ireland's first farmers were most closely related to people living at broadly the same time in Iberia (modern Spain and Portugal).

Over generations, the farmers traversed the Mediterranean from Anatolia to Iberia, weaving their way up the French coast before making their way to Ireland by sea."

Generally the Spanish connection in early Irish folktales have been connected to the chance similarity of Galicia with Gael (due to the shared Celtic roots thereof), the similarity of sound between Roman Hibernia for Ireland and Iberia, that Orosius thought Ireland lay between Britain and Spain, and finally Isadore of Seville saying many peoples came from Spain.

Now it seems there is some genetics to back it up, but so far I have not seen much in the way of investigations of this. There are also some that find linguistic Q-Celtic similarities between Gaelic and the Celtiberian of ancient Hispania too, who had theorised the Invasions recorded a memory of a Q-Celtic power replacing local P-Celtic elites.

This myth had interesting after-effects, as it resulted in Irish Catholics usually fleeing to Spain (such as the Flight of the Earls) and Irishmen being readily given the rights of subjects in Spain. Likewise, remnants of the Spanish Armada were welcomed in Ireland. It drew Ireland and Spain together, so that the great fighter for Irish independance was Eamon de Valera, happily sporting his Spanish father's surname, while rejecting his original English name of Edward; and why Leopoldo O'Donnell was prime minster of Spain and a notable participant of the Carlist wars.

Now it seems, there is more to this. My interest is certainly piqued. I love a good fantastic yarn sporting an inkling of truth somewhere, so that you can spend hours rummaging about looking for it.
 

JackRT

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Oct 17, 2015
15,722
16,445
80
small town Ontario, Canada
✟767,295.00
Country
Canada
Faith
Unorthodox
Marital Status
Married
Fascinating stuff! Spanish DNA in the Irish gene pool may date much more recently. In 1588 when the Spanish Armada was defeated in the English Channel, it fled north through the North Sea with intent to round Scotland and Ireland and back to Spain. After rounding Scotland it encountered a great storm with many ships wrecked on the coasts of Ireland and the Hebrides. What followed included quite a bit of gene mixing. I carry some of that blood.
 
  • Like
Reactions: redleghunter
Upvote 0