amariselle
Jesus Never Fails
- Sep 28, 2004
- 6,648
- 4,194
- Country
- United States
- Faith
- Christian
- Marital Status
- Married
- Politics
- CA-Conservatives
There are certainty different ideologies within the RCC yet I would be hard pressed to say they are not in communion with each other since they share the same Eucharist and recognise each other's status as Catholics part of the Church. The same could not be said for Protestantism which divides amongst itself on principal and does not find it necessary to recognise each other or have a universal communion amongst themselves. Lutherans and Baptists within the protestant schema don't need communion, so long as both adhere to the essentials of the faith. To put it another away, communion is nice but it is not necessary.
I would agree with your assessment of Pope Francis mind you, but even he hasn't divided the Church so thoroughly as Protestantism divided itself and many Catholics have not been shy in their criticisms of his pontificate.
Also I said that Protestants ultimately listen to their conscience and i would clarify that they do this by appeal to the scripture. How is this to falsely characterise the fundamental ethos of Protestantism when Protestants prove my assertion by their divisions and refusal to submit to anything but their interpretation of the bible? They do this with direct appeal to the Spirit mind you, as if no one else has it. That might be one of the fundamental differences between the ancient approach and the protestant approach, is that the ancient recognised the Spirit in more than just the self, but in the community as a whole. Thus to submit to ecclesiastical authority or even an educated lay teacher is sometimes the best option in the mind of Catholics and Orthodox.
That may be your idea of Protestantism, and that's fine, as we are all entitled to our opinions.
As for the division within the Catholic Church, my point is that it is significant. (Examples again with Vatican II, which many Catholics reject, insisting, among other things, that the Latin Mass is essential and that all Vatican II Popes are not true Popes at all.) I'd say that that is pretty major division, yet, they still call themselves Catholic. And so, on the surface, it seems there is not as much division, when there in fact is.
Upvote
0