- Jun 5, 2017
- 22,242
- 6,634
- Country
- Australia
- Faith
- SDA
- Marital Status
- Married
Your reasoning about who is "under the law" is clearly not correct and, I confess, it is hard for me to understand how you do not realize this. Let me try to explain this as clearly and systematically as I can.
Romans 3:19
Now we know that whatever the Law says, it speaks to those who are [h]under the Law, so that every mouth may be closed and all the world may become accountable to God;
The issue here is context - ripped out of context, the above text certainly could be read as implying that all under the Law. But it doesn't have to be read that way, and both the context of Romans 3 - and even more importantly the weight of all Scripture - show that it should not be read that way.
In the first 18 or so verses, Paul clearly shows that he is trying to mount a case not simply that all are sinners, but that both Jews and Gentiles are sinners. He has clearly marked out two distinct categories of human beings in the first 18 verses - Jews and Gentiles. He is clearly trying to disabuse his readers of the error of thinking that Jews are better than Gentiles or vice versa.
So now we come the infamous verse 19 with these two categories already on the table. You either didn't realize this is where we are at the beginning of verses 19 or, worse, you have chosen to sweep that under the table. Here is the clincher: any Biblically literate person would already know that it is the Jew who was given the Law of Moses and is under its jurisdiction.
If you deny this, I will have to conclude you have simply not given the Old Testament a serious read because it is painfully obvious that this is the case.
So when Paul says that the Law speaks to those that under it, he has to be referring to the Jews since it is a Biblical fact that the Law of Moses is specific to the Jew.
Now for the key point: Having just compared and contrasted Jew and Gentile in the first 18 verses, his reference to those "under the Law" can still be specific to the Jew - as it should be unless Paul knows nothing about Judaism. He is simply saying this, in effect:
Jews sin, Gentiles sin; therefore although the Law says what it says to Jews (those under the Law), the whole world remains sinful.
On top of all this, we have this little cutie which, on its own, torpedoes any unBiblical notion that Gentiles are "under the Law":
For we maintain that a man is justified by faith apart from works of the Law. 29 Or is God the God of Jews only? Is He not the God of Gentiles also?
To deny that Paul is here implicitly saying that only the Jew is subject to the Law would be bizarre to say the least.
This should settle the matter but, alas, I am sure it won't.
Not really brother expos4ever,
CONTEXT has been demonstrated scripture by scripture. You have left this out of what you are quoting from in your post. It is you who are not showing context and your simply stating your words here over the scriptures posted in post # 518 linked click me.
The CONTEXT was shown verse by verse starting from ROMANS 2 right up to Romans 3:19. Context has been demonstrated to you in post # 518 linked click me from Romans 2:6 through to Romans 3:19. This demonstrated CONTEXT for ROAMNS 3:19 that you left out of your interpretation the Romans 3:19 which you say was only for the JEWS.
Simply ignoring what was posted and stating your own words over God's WORD does not help you case as it does not address any of the scriptures posted to you in post # 518 linked click me that disagree with your interpretation of the scriptures.
This post is sent only in love brother expos4ever. Only God's WORD is true and we should believe and follow it. I will look to address your post here a bit further but hope you can do the same and address my posts and not ignore them.
Hope this helps
Last edited:
Upvote
0