Search results

  1. DRobert

    Are Protestants dead?

    This calls for discernment. We would be wise to assume OP’s intention was pure, sincere and honest, unless proven otherwise.
  2. DRobert

    Catholic way

    Well I can't speak for you, Albion, however it seems critical discernment is needed. May I know where you got this idea from. I'd like to give you the benefit of the doubt here and assume your good name and intention so as to avoid rashly judging you, especially in case if what you say is...
  3. DRobert

    Catholic way

    Thanks be to God!
  4. DRobert

    Catholic way

    Gladly, although I kindly request we carry it back-and-forth PM conversation. It is easier and more leisurely to carry on so as not to be boggled down by other people's converations and replies within the topic discussion. Let me know what you think. I also tend to reply less frequently. I don't...
  5. DRobert

    Catholic way

    However once you are aware of the claims of the Catholic Church, it becomes sin to resist the Holy Spirit whom is leading you into full communion with the Catholic Church as a Catholic Christian. This would also be a sin of pride I'd say.
  6. DRobert

    Catholic way

    St. Joseph's intercession is said to be never known to fail. I suppose I'll pray for your conversion now, OP, to the Catholic faith.
  7. DRobert

    Catholic vs. Protestant – why is there so much animosity?"

    Jesus Christ is a God-man, so therefore I truly follow a man-made tradition. What's the big deal?
  8. DRobert

    Catholic vs. Protestant – why is there so much animosity?"

    Battle against what is called the three-fold conspicupance: The flesh, the world and the Devil. There is excellent Catholic material based on the Science Of The Saints that deals with this exact subject :) St. Ignatius, St. Teressa of Avila and Saint John of the Cross, St. Francis De Sales are...
  9. DRobert

    Catholic vs. Protestant – why is there so much animosity?"

    Have you read the daily missal? Mine ends on this note: "When we pray, the voice of the heart must be heard more than that proceeding from the mouth." - St. Bonaventure
  10. DRobert

    Mary

    Show me where the Catholic Church teaches that Mary is the Holy Spirit?
  11. DRobert

    Applying common literary rules to Matthew 26:26 and John 6:51

    Saint Irenaeus(who lived before the canon of the New Testament was established which you cannot discern using only The Bible) teaches that the bread and wine are really the Lord’s body and blood. His witness is, indeed, all the more impressive because he produces it quite incidentally while...
  12. DRobert

    Applying common literary rules to Matthew 26:26 and John 6:51

    God created the heavens and the earth. He changed water into wine. He rose from the dead. Surely you are not saying God's power is limited in what he can do, are you?
  13. DRobert

    Applying common literary rules to Matthew 26:26 and John 6:51

    You mean the Protestant Revolt (The Reformation was the Council Of Trent).
  14. DRobert

    If men are justified by faith alone (Sola Fide)...?

    My first question is are you EVEN interested in the claims of the Catholic Church on the matter or will you just dismiss anything that differs from your view? Here are two links that you may find helpful on the subject of Purgatory. Purgatory | Catholic Answers Is Purgatory in the Bible? |...
  15. DRobert

    If men are justified by faith alone (Sola Fide)...?

    This should be worth looking at on Catholics and Lutherans making a joint statement on justification: Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification
  16. DRobert

    If men are justified by faith alone (Sola Fide)...?

    Justification by faith does not equate justification by faith alone. argumentum ad ignorantiam: Lack of evidence for the labels "transubstantiation" and "purgatory" does not prove your position. Here I quote evidence to support my position: ""Take note of those who hold heterodox opinions...
  17. DRobert

    If men are justified by faith alone (Sola Fide)...?

    It's relevant; Sola Fide is unbiblical---it's a protestant tradition invented by Luther. That's the claim. Evidence for this is that Sola Fide was not a christian belief before the time of Luther. Sola Fide also gutted the Deposit Of Faith---Sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture---into half. By...
  18. DRobert

    If men are justified by faith alone (Sola Fide)...?

    We are fallible; Christ's Church is infallible. The Gates Of Hell will never prevail against it and it is the pillar of spirit and truth. It is guarded by the Holy Spirit.
  19. DRobert

    If men are justified by faith alone (Sola Fide)...?

    Sola Fide is not able to affirm which books belong in the Canon Of Sacred Scripture, which ironically, protestants use to prop up the doctrine of Sola Fide. Why would you put your trust in a man who gutted the Bible and wanted to also gut the New Testament as well?
  20. DRobert

    If men are justified by faith alone (Sola Fide)...?

    Oscarr's understanding about the Catholic Church is fallible.