GW said:
FREE:
Not true - it just means the Second coming has been imminent for 2000 years.
GW:
The apostles' first-century expectation means they knew nothing of "1948," "computer chips marks of beast," the Church age, etc. etc. Since they didn't know of these things, they are not part of the apostolic doctrine.
You may think you are making a point, but you aren't. It was not necessary that they know. And the information given to John in Revelation was not given til 95 A.D. - almost 30 years after Peter and Paul died. But I strongly believe that John was aware of the Church age. He wouldn't have understood computer chips (if that is the mark - I don't know).
FREE:
And the thessalonians wouldn't have known about the mark, for of 'mystery Babylon', etc, because those things were revealed to John in 95 A.D. - a good 30 years after the letters to the Thesalonians were written.
GW:
First, Revelation was written in AD 68. Next, you are arguing that Paul and Peter didn't know the doctrine of eschatology. Strange.
I don't think you are getting it; if the apostles believed in a first-century coming of Christ, then they did not believe or even know about "1948", the Church age, etc. etc. Thus, those things cannot be true.
No, it was written in 95 A.D. John was on the island of Patmos because he had been banished there. Nero did not banish anyone, he tortured and killed them for fun. Roman historians documented that Dominitan did banish to Patmos. The early church believed that it was during the reign of Dominitan, and all of them saw the Second coming as still future - ALL. Iranaeus, who was taught by Polycarp who was taught by John himself wrote that the Revelation was received during the reign of Dominitan - 27 years after Nero died.
And according to Polycarp, bishop of Smyrna, the church at Smyrna was not in existence in 65 A.D. And Laodicea was far from wealthy, having been flattened by an earthquake in 62 A.D.
The Antichrist of the final hour had come as of the time 1 Jn 2:18-19 was written. John was writing during the tribulation period at the Day of the Lord (Rev 1:9). His vision was about things obligated to come to pass shortly for the time was then at hand (Rev 1:1,3). You deny it, but I am fully content letting our readers here see who is right by reading the passages themselves.
I am sure that those who don't have to change the meaning of scripture to fit their endtime view, or spiritualize away all the details, will understand what John was writing about. It really is very plain.
You haven't written a thing to show that I am wrong.
I reject the preterist viewpoint for a multitude of reasons. Here's some:
1) The entire early church still saw the Second Coming as future.
2) The events of 70 A.D. do not fit scriptural account of the Second Coming.
3) it is those who worship the beast that are defeated...and Israel did not worship Nero. Yet they were defeated.
4) Nero never sat in the temple of God declaring himself God.
5) The 2 witnesses - so WHO was killed and resurrected 3 1/2 days later in front of those celebrating their deaths?? And what about that earthquake?
6) There was no earthquake that flattened the mountains of the entire earth, not even those in the Roman Empire. Pliny, writing in 77 A.D. missed the greatest earthquake ever if it had occurred in 70 A.D.
7) Roman never had an army 200,000,000 and neither did Jerusalem
8) The seas of the world did not turn to blood - Jerusalem is landlocked.
9) 1000years means 1000 years. 3 1/2 days means 3 1/2 days, 1260 days means 1260 days.
10) Zechariahn prophecies the destruction of the army that came against Jerusalem by Christ- Titus went home victorius.
11) Nero, the preterist 'beast', died before Jerusalem fell...doesn't fit the description of events in Revelation, where the beast is destroyed AFTER the battle.
12) So when did darkness cover the kingdom of the beast - the Roman Empire?
13) False prophet?
14) Joel 3: 1-2 -
15) "and every eye shall see" - yet the whole world missed the Second coming - including the church which had been looking for Christ! The writers of the oldest extraBiblical document, the Didache, still saw the Second Coming as future...and they would have been alive for 70 A.D.
I could mention much more, but need to go to sleep.