Hey, no need to panic over this, man.
Just try pm'ing her to say hello and welcoming her to your parents' church (I assume you saw her in person there at least once even if you weren't able to talk?), and try not to stress out just because she seems like such a magical creature at first glance, okay? With the girl I now have a crush on, and intend to keep crushing on for a long while, I noticed she was cute and was eager to begin conversing with her while at work. But I treated her as a friend who at best I simply liked being around at first, and did not even seriously start feeling romantic inclinations towards her until at least six or seven months since she first arrived at my workplace. There was no need to for me to stress out until the day I finally asked her out and confessed to having a crush on her (and that was at least another three or four months later after beginning to feel more romantically inclined instead of just the same kind of fondness for her that I would any one of my friends who are women). As romantically idealistic as I am, I must concede that in today's society it really is likely for the best to not come on strong right off the bat no matter what you are personally feeling towards her - even
if she seems like a dream come true or some great goddess of love who will haunt your daydreams for years to come ^-^ - especially if this is your very first meeting with any measure of conversation with her. Treat her as an acquaintance you'd like to simply get to know better and in time genuinely befriend; it probably will never pay off to let her know in any way that she already clicks with you romantically when you haven't even really talked with her yet. Just take it slow and easy.