• The General Mental Health Forum is now a Read Only Forum. As we had two large areas making it difficult for many to find, we decided to combine the Mental Health & the Recovery sections of the forum into Mental Health & Recovery as a whole. Physical Health still remains as it's own area within the entire Recovery area.

    If you are having struggles, need support in a particular area that you aren't finding a specific recovery area forum, you may find the General Struggles forum a great place to post. Any any that is related to emotions, self-esteem, insomnia, anger, relationship dynamics due to mental health and recovery and other issues that don't fit better in another forum would be examples of topics that might go there.

    If you have spiritual issues related to a mental health and recovery issue, please use the Recovery Related Spiritual Advice forum. This forum is designed to be like Christian Advice, only for recovery type of issues. Recovery being like a family in many ways, allows us to support one another together. May you be blessed today and each day.

    Kristen.NewCreation and FreeinChrist

A Problem That Is Causing Me To Worry. Can you help me?

Kostilaks

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2018
441
303
32
Macedonia
✟72,424.00
Country
Greece
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
I am writing about a problem that is causing me a lot of worrying. I know I have been posting these a lot but I just, do not get the answer I wanted. I constantly, get the advice to see a therapist. Please do not write that. just ignore me, read carefully my problem and answer the numbered questions. I am going to say my problem in a third person. and sorry for my english.

One night, the ocd guy leaves his apartment with paper napkins that he wetted before putting them in his pocket. He is outside near his apartment. Due to the water, the napkins became, you know... in his pocket. Ocd started telling the ocd guy to return home in order to get some other, clean paper napkins from his kitchen. The paper napkins were a specific brand from a super market. The guy was so dizzy, tired and anxious because of his ocd, that he did not want to do this tiring compulsion. Ocd kept insisting.

Ocd: You must return home in order to get other, clean napkins!

The ocd guy was standing in a "something like a bridge" and was trying to ignore his ocd about returning home in order to get clean napkins. He could not ignore it, so he rushly, decided to make a promise to God that would force him not to do this tiring ocd compulsion. The guy was carefull and was trying to visualise the promise while saying it, in order not to make any mistake. He cant remember exactly what his words were, but some examples of the promise could be:

a) he makes a promise about not returning home to get paper napkins.

b) he makes a promise about not returning home JUST ONLY to get clean/other paper napkins.

He canceled the promise in the last moment, but he is not sure if it was canceled.

That guy, 1 year later, is living in a different apartment, in a different area. He leaves his apartment but his ocd is telling him to return home to get some garbage bags that needed to be thrown out, because he may have made a rushed promise to God or to Gods. Since he was near, to his house, he decided to obey to his ocd and return to his apartment in order to get the garbage bags. Probably, when he entered the kitchen, he noticed some other stuff that needed to be thrown out. So, as part of the compulsion, he started searching almost, his whole apartment for stuff to put into the garbage bags. After that, he took the garbage bags and threw them into a street dustbin.

The guy started worrying that perhaps, the garbage bags contained some paper napkins from a delivery food store. He started making some connections with the napkin promise. He returned to his apartment, as part of the compulsion, in order to get some garbage bags.

1) What if the garbage bags contained some napkins? The guy is trying to calm himself down by saying that he had no intention of returning home in order to get paper napkins. He returned to get the garbage bags. But if his intention was to get the garbage and some of the garbage were paper napkins, maybe indirectly without knowing, maybe, somehow, he returned to get paper napkins? what to you think? explain your answer

2) The guy was living in a different aparment and area when he tried to make the promise about the napkins. When he was saying the promise, he was visualising it. He visualised a specific way back to his aparment from the spot where he was staning and the paper napkins that were on his kitchen. Does that mean, that the promise was valid only for that aparment and only for that specific napkins? I think, the guy visualised the promise not because he wanted to make it valid ONLY for that aparment/napkins, but because he wanted to be sure not to make any mistakes with his words. Did he, unintentionally, somehow, since he visualised the promise, made the promise valid ONLY for that apartment/napkins? what do you think? explain your answer.

3) if his promise was about not returning home JUST ONLY to get clean/other napkins, probably, he did not break it when he returned to get the garbage bags, because some keywords in his promise, mean that the promise is much more different than what he did with the garbage bags. Also, since he already had some napkins in his pocket, by saying "other napkins" probably, means that the promise was only valid for that moment in which he had the wetted napkins in his pockets. Also, probably, the promise was valid only if he was rejecting some paper napkins with clear intention to return home to get some others. That clearly, did not happen with the garbage bags. what do you think?

4) if his promise was random, about not returning home in order to get paper napkins, can we assume that the word "other" was meant without being said, since the promise was like an answer to his ocd? Since his ocd was telling him

ocd: you must return home to get other napkins.

The guy may have not said the word "other" when he tried to make the promise but it was automatically, meant. What do you think?

5) The guy probably, never specified for how long the promise is valid. He just, rushly decided to make the promise to force himself not do the ocd compulsion. Can we assume that it was only valid for the moment that he was standing on a "something like a bridge" with the wetted napkins in his pocket? explain your answer

5) If the guy did not specify anything, and he just, said about not returning home in order to get paper napkins, can we assume that all the other things that I mentioned above were somehow, meant without saying them? The guy just, wanted to force himself not to obey his ocd by returning home to get paper napkins. It was only an one moment decision. I do not think the guy wanted to make the promise to be valid forever and for everything that has to do with napkins directly or indirecrly and intentionaly or uninentionaly. what do you think?

6) The guy worries because he sees some connection between the promise ( about not returning home to get napkins) and what he did ( he returned home in order to get some garbage bags that maybe contained paper napkins) and what worries him most is that both actions are being ordered by his ocd. What if the guy promised not to obey to his ocd that has to do with a return to a home in order to get paper napkins, generally?

Please if you want to help me, do not say anything about a therapist. I get that advice a lot. so, if you only want to say that, do not say it, just ignore me. If you want to help me and make me feel better, you can spend some time to answer the numbered questions 1 by 1 or at least, say your opinion generally. I worry because I stopped believing so much to Jesus. What if there is an other God or other Gods that do not care about ocd? Please do not give me answers from the Bible.
 

Gregory Thompson

Change is inevitable, feel free to spare some.
Site Supporter
Dec 20, 2009
28,364
7,742
Canada
✟721,292.00
Country
Canada
Faith
Christian Seeker
Marital Status
Married
OCD impulses do not communicate God's voice. The basis of OCD is a fear that you are not important so it invents meaning in the smallest things. According to 1st Epistle of John Chapter 4, God is love and fear is incompatible with that.

OCD resembles the complex Paul describes near the end of Romans chapter 7.

OCD is the carnal nature trying to find self meaning in the smallest thing, adding fear to the mix. This degree of superstition was similar to the logical connections made by the gnostics.
 
Upvote 0

Arc F1

Let the righteous man arise from slumber
Site Supporter
Mar 14, 2020
3,735
2,156
Kentucky
✟146,863.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
The first step is to stop saying "I can't" and at least be truthful by saying "I won't". The second step is to let yourself see what is bothering you. Ocd is always triggered by something that you refuse to address. It's a way of not dealing with the issues.
 
Upvote 0

Petros2015

Well-Known Member
Jun 23, 2016
5,091
4,327
52
undisclosed Bunker
✟289,134.00
Country
United States
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
What if there is an other God or other Gods that do not care about ocd? Please do not give me answers from the Bible.

Hmm.

It sounds like the man has OCD which tries to compel him to do something

In order to fight the OCD, the man makes a promise to God that he won't do what the OCD compels him to do, because he thinks that the promise will add weight to his ability not to do it, because the man's concept of God is (or possibly was) something that will punish him for breaking the promise
(I did this too as a child and sometimes as a man)

A year later, the man is still concerned that he may have made a promise about not throwing away paper napkins and that he inadvertently broke it.

The man should consider this possibility:

that the God's promises to the man are far more important than the man's promises to the God, and that they are good ones. One time, there were a group of people who understood this, and then forgot about it. They were called "Galatians", and I read a letter to them this morning. The person writing them the letter said it was like they were locked up trying to follow some rules and regulations they thought they needed to do to keep the God happy. It was all a misunderstanding though, the God had already shown them that He loved them, even though they sometimes went back for their napkins. He was more interested in their peace out of love than they could ever be in His out of fear.

What if there is an other God or other Gods that do not care about ocd?

I think this is only a problem with the God of Napkins. If the man made a promise to God about napkins, I think it was a promise to the God of Napkins, (or possibly the God of Promises) even if he didn't realize it. And there are bigger Gods - the biggest is the God of Love. The man should know that he is loved, OCD or not, promises or not, napkins or not.

 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: KGrande
Upvote 0

Junia

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2020
2,795
1,387
42
Bristol
✟31,159.00
Country
United Kingdom
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
OCD impulses do not communicate God's voice. The basis of OCD is a fear that you are not important so it invents meaning in the smallest things. According to 1st Epistle of John Chapter 4, God is love and fear is incompatible with that.

OCD resembles the complex Paul describes near the end of Romans chapter 7.

OCD is the carnal nature trying to find self meaning in the smallest thing, adding fear to the mix. This degree of superstition was similar to the logical connections made by the gnostics.
I

as an OCD sufferer who can relate a lot To the original post, I agree with this 100 per cent. This is a mental health issue
 
Upvote 0

Mari17

Well-Known Member
Jun 17, 2017
1,490
510
Newport
✟142,902.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
I am writing about a problem that is causing me a lot of worrying. I know I have been posting these a lot but I just, do not get the answer I wanted. I constantly, get the advice to see a therapist. Please do not write that. just ignore me, read carefully my problem and answer the numbered questions. I am going to say my problem in a third person. and sorry for my english.

One night, the ocd guy leaves his apartment with paper napkins that he wetted before putting them in his pocket. He is outside near his apartment. Due to the water, the napkins became, you know... in his pocket. Ocd started telling the ocd guy to return home in order to get some other, clean paper napkins from his kitchen. The paper napkins were a specific brand from a super market. The guy was so dizzy, tired and anxious because of his ocd, that he did not want to do this tiring compulsion. Ocd kept insisting.

Ocd: You must return home in order to get other, clean napkins!

The ocd guy was standing in a "something like a bridge" and was trying to ignore his ocd about returning home in order to get clean napkins. He could not ignore it, so he rushly, decided to make a promise to God that would force him not to do this tiring ocd compulsion. The guy was carefull and was trying to visualise the promise while saying it, in order not to make any mistake. He cant remember exactly what his words were, but some examples of the promise could be:

a) he makes a promise about not returning home to get paper napkins.

b) he makes a promise about not returning home JUST ONLY to get clean/other paper napkins.

He canceled the promise in the last moment, but he is not sure if it was canceled.

That guy, 1 year later, is living in a different apartment, in a different area. He leaves his apartment but his ocd is telling him to return home to get some garbage bags that needed to be thrown out, because he may have made a rushed promise to God or to Gods. Since he was near, to his house, he decided to obey to his ocd and return to his apartment in order to get the garbage bags. Probably, when he entered the kitchen, he noticed some other stuff that needed to be thrown out. So, as part of the compulsion, he started searching almost, his whole apartment for stuff to put into the garbage bags. After that, he took the garbage bags and threw them into a street dustbin.

The guy started worrying that perhaps, the garbage bags contained some paper napkins from a delivery food store. He started making some connections with the napkin promise. He returned to his apartment, as part of the compulsion, in order to get some garbage bags.

1) What if the garbage bags contained some napkins? The guy is trying to calm himself down by saying that he had no intention of returning home in order to get paper napkins. He returned to get the garbage bags. But if his intention was to get the garbage and some of the garbage were paper napkins, maybe indirectly without knowing, maybe, somehow, he returned to get paper napkins? what to you think? explain your answer

2) The guy was living in a different aparment and area when he tried to make the promise about the napkins. When he was saying the promise, he was visualising it. He visualised a specific way back to his aparment from the spot where he was staning and the paper napkins that were on his kitchen. Does that mean, that the promise was valid only for that aparment and only for that specific napkins? I think, the guy visualised the promise not because he wanted to make it valid ONLY for that aparment/napkins, but because he wanted to be sure not to make any mistakes with his words. Did he, unintentionally, somehow, since he visualised the promise, made the promise valid ONLY for that apartment/napkins? what do you think? explain your answer.

3) if his promise was about not returning home JUST ONLY to get clean/other napkins, probably, he did not break it when he returned to get the garbage bags, because some keywords in his promise, mean that the promise is much more different than what he did with the garbage bags. Also, since he already had some napkins in his pocket, by saying "other napkins" probably, means that the promise was only valid for that moment in which he had the wetted napkins in his pockets. Also, probably, the promise was valid only if he was rejecting some paper napkins with clear intention to return home to get some others. That clearly, did not happen with the garbage bags. what do you think?

4) if his promise was random, about not returning home in order to get paper napkins, can we assume that the word "other" was meant without being said, since the promise was like an answer to his ocd? Since his ocd was telling him

ocd: you must return home to get other napkins.

The guy may have not said the word "other" when he tried to make the promise but it was automatically, meant. What do you think?

5) The guy probably, never specified for how long the promise is valid. He just, rushly decided to make the promise to force himself not do the ocd compulsion. Can we assume that it was only valid for the moment that he was standing on a "something like a bridge" with the wetted napkins in his pocket? explain your answer

5) If the guy did not specify anything, and he just, said about not returning home in order to get paper napkins, can we assume that all the other things that I mentioned above were somehow, meant without saying them? The guy just, wanted to force himself not to obey his ocd by returning home to get paper napkins. It was only an one moment decision. I do not think the guy wanted to make the promise to be valid forever and for everything that has to do with napkins directly or indirecrly and intentionaly or uninentionaly. what do you think?

6) The guy worries because he sees some connection between the promise ( about not returning home to get napkins) and what he did ( he returned home in order to get some garbage bags that maybe contained paper napkins) and what worries him most is that both actions are being ordered by his ocd. What if the guy promised not to obey to his ocd that has to do with a return to a home in order to get paper napkins, generally?

Please if you want to help me, do not say anything about a therapist. I get that advice a lot. so, if you only want to say that, do not say it, just ignore me. If you want to help me and make me feel better, you can spend some time to answer the numbered questions 1 by 1 or at least, say your opinion generally. I worry because I stopped believing so much to Jesus. What if there is an other God or other Gods that do not care about ocd? Please do not give me answers from the Bible.
So basically, what you want is reassurance. I know that's what will make you feel better temporarily, but in the long term it will only make your OCD worse. So because of that, I cannot give you reassurance. I can tell you that you are definitely overthinking and hyper-analyzing; you are thinking in a distorted way because of the OCD. I'm sorry that you do not want to treat your OCD, because I would really like you to experience freedom from it. But that can only happen if you're willing to work on it.
 
Upvote 0

Junia

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2020
2,795
1,387
42
Bristol
✟31,159.00
Country
United Kingdom
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
So basically, what you want is reassurance. I know that's what will make you feel better temporarily, but in the long term it will only make your OCD worse. So because of that, I cannot give you reassurance. I can tell you that you are definitely overthinking and hyper-analyzing; you are thinking in a distorted way because of the OCD. I'm sorry that you do not want to treat your OCD, because I would really like you to experience freedom from it. But that can only happen if you're willing to work on it.
I

Agree with this.

Regarding not wanting to treat your OCD, is it that you cannot access treatment (none available near you, cost etc) ?
 
Upvote 0

Junia

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2020
2,795
1,387
42
Bristol
✟31,159.00
Country
United Kingdom
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
I used to believe that psychiatry was of the devil . Sadly it is a false belief many churches teach and I was brought up with that.

I finally realised the Bible doesn't forbid medicine and there are scriptures that suggest God wouldn't have an issue with therapy (eg be transformed by the renewing of your mind etc) and now when Christians tell me am in sin for having treatment for my mental issues I ignore it
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mari17
Upvote 0

FixItJesus

New Member
Oct 14, 2020
2
4
29
Illinois
✟7,842.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
I have OCD and am struggling with making promises to God as well. Well, I think most of them are just unwanted, intrusive thoughts disguising themselves as my own thoughts. The Bible does say that if we make a promise to God we have to keep it, but we have a mental disorder. God understands that we're not in our right minds. I'm not sure if we have to keep these promises or not, but I feel like there's a chance we might not have to because we would never make these promises if we didn't have OCD. The Bible doesn't talk about mental illness very much, so I could be wrong, but that's just what I think. I would think that God would have mercy on us. God bless you! And don't lose your faith in God/Jesus. No other "gods" exist. He is our only hope.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mari17
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

Junia

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2020
2,795
1,387
42
Bristol
✟31,159.00
Country
United Kingdom
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
I have OCD and am struggling with making promises to God as well. Well, I think most of them are just unwanted, intrusive thoughts disguising themselves as my own thoughts. The Bible does say that if we make a promise to God we have to keep it, but we have a mental disorder. God understands that we're not in our right minds. I'm not sure if we have to keep these promises or not, but I feel like there's a chance we might not have to because we would never make these promises if we didn't have OCD. The Bible doesn't talk about mental illness very much, so I could be wrong, but that's just what I think. I would think that God would have mercy on us. God bless you! And don't lose your faith in God/Jesus. No other "gods" exist. He is our only hope.
I

yez me too
 
Upvote 0

Junia

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2020
2,795
1,387
42
Bristol
✟31,159.00
Country
United Kingdom
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Hmm.

It sounds like the man has OCD which tries to compel him to do something

In order to fight the OCD, the man makes a promise to God that he won't do what the OCD compels him to do, because he thinks that the promise will add weight to his ability not to do it, because the man's concept of God is (or possibly was) something that will punish him for breaking the promise
(I did this too as a child and sometimes as a man)

A year later, the man is still concerned that he may have made a promise about not throwing away paper napkins and that he inadvertently broke it.

The man should consider this possibility:

that the God's promises to the man are far more important than the man's promises to the God, and that they are good ones. One time, there were a group of people who understood this, and then forgot about it. They were called "Galatians", and I read a letter to them this morning. The person writing them the letter said it was like they were locked up trying to follow some rules and regulations they thought they needed to do to keep the God happy. It was all a misunderstanding though, the God had already shown them that He loved them, even though they sometimes went back for their napkins. He was more interested in their peace out of love than they could ever be in His out of fear.



I think this is only a problem with the God of Napkins. If the man made a promise to God about napkins, I think it was a promise to the God of Napkins, (or possibly the God of Promises) even if he didn't realize it. And there are bigger Gods - the biggest is the God of Love. The man should know that he is loved, OCD or not, promises or not, napkins or not.

I

As an OC D sufferer with this kind of OC?d th e book of Galatians helped me
 
Upvote 0