I've Blashphemed the Holy Spirit. What now?

bathelter01

Active Member
Apr 21, 2019
46
15
33
Tennessee
✟19,406.00
Country
United States
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Single
Repentance is not something we produce.

I agree totally. It is a work of the Holy Spirit in us. So what then does it mean when it is not being produced in us? Because there is a difference between godly and worldly repentance. Godly repentance is produced by the Spirit.
 
Upvote 0

rockytopva

Love to pray! :)
Site Supporter
Mar 6, 2011
20,046
7,673
.
Visit site
✟1,063,017.00
Faith
Pentecostal
Marital Status
Single
It is the devils job to accuse and lay such grievous charges....

And I heard a loud voice saying in heaven, Now is come salvation, and strength, and the kingdom of our God, and the power of his Christ: for the accuser of our brethren is cast down, which accused them before our Gfod day and night. - Revelation 12:10

Can you still say Jesus is Lord?

Wherefore I give you to understand, that no man speaking by the Spirit of God calleth Jesus accursed: and that no man can say that Jesus is the Lord, but by the Holy Ghost. - 1 Corinthians 12:3

Well, then, you have not sinned against the Holy Spirit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: friend of
Upvote 0

GraceBro

Eternally Forgiven, Alive, and Secure.
Dec 24, 2017
702
588
Central Coast
Visit site
✟102,674.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
So I know this is probably not a shocking title and that it's probably common to see a post like this. However, I've been struggling for some years over my possible loss of salvation. You may have seen my posts in the past. I'll link them below for those who would be interested. They may give a more robust explanation of what has happened.

Has my sin killed me spiritually? Loss of salvation
What to do when you are beyond repentance?

The short of it is as follows:
I became a believer around the age of 10 and saw a stark change in my life and desires. Hatred towards sin and love and desire for Christ. Shortly after I was exposed to inappropriate contentography and formed an addiction. The following 17 years were an up and down dealing with addiction and the Lord drawing me back to repentance.
Until 2 years ago. I had been in a pit of sin and despair hating my sin and crying out to the Lord to free me from it but being, seemingly, unable to escape it for long. I had good moments of repentance during that time but I would always inevitable fall back into my sin. I would like to point out that this was not a time of me walking away from Christ in a knowing sense. It was a time of gripping Christ, struggling/falling, repenting, gripping Christ and struggling/falling. During that time I had just started seminary but was still struggling in my thought life and occasionally on the internet.
One night I fell to temptation and felt no remorse or brokenness. It was shocking and horrifying. I sinned and felt no conviction over it. I spent the rest of the night in prayer trying to repent and felt that I could not. Unable to feel broken over sin or that what I had done was a problem.
The next morning I woke up and began seeking the Lord about what had happened filled with an intense sense of deep, deep anxiety about my relationship with the Lord. During a time of prayer I felt, what seemed to me, the departing of the Holy Spirit. The reason I believe this to be true is because of the state of my heart and mind afterwords. My heart felt like a stone in my chest and I felt no love or desire for the Lord. My sin didn't seem to be a big deal to me anymore. I opened my bible and it looked like words on a page. It seemed that I no longer believed the Scriptures anymore no matter how hard I fought to. I knew experientially that they were true but there was not heart level belief. It was like I had undergone a de-renewing of my mind and heart. My thoughts were wicked and I had no regard for the Lord. It seemed as though he had left me completely. There was no work of the Holy Spirit occurring in my life. The Word was not illuminated, I was not convicted of sin and I felt a horrible fear of destruction. The most visceral fear of condemnation.
Two years later nothing has changed. At that time this began I had resolved that I would not continue in sin and that I would continue to submit to the Lord even if he had left me. I resolved to live what was rest of my life to the glory of God but that has become difficult in the lack of desire to do so. It does not seem possible to remain faithful to the Lord apart from the Holy Spirit's work to impart those desires. I have no desire to run head long into sin but I also do not desire the Lord.

I ran across these 2 articles last night and I believe they speak to my situation. I'm not sure what to do now.
What Is the Unforgivable Sin?
Beyond Forgiveness: Blasphemy Against the Spirit

The thing that stuck out to me was,
"The unforgivable sin is when you have resisted him so decisively that he has forsaken you and you can no longer repent. You try to repent and you can't repent. You can't be genuinely sorry for your sin or turn away from it. That is a horribly frightening situation to be in."

RC Sproul quoted a theologian saying, "To be sure, hell will be awful for both, but as one theologian has noted, all the sinners in hell would move heaven and earth if they could remove but one transgression from their record and have their punishment even barely alleviated."

Everything in my life points to this reality and I'm not sure how to move forward. My desires to remain faithful to the Lord have departed and I cannot continue if the Spirit does not empower. If there is no returning of the Holy Spirit because I have blasphemed though persistence in sin, what then should one do? Would it not be most profitable in my situation to remove myself from this life for the sake of my eternity?
The bottom line is that you need to clear the deck and start over in your understanding of the Gospel, salvation, and your identity in Christ. This fear you have that has you talking about the "unforgivable sin" and being "beyond forgiveness," is clear evidence that you are not operating in the love of God. Once you get a solid understanding of those things I mentioned the answers will reveal themselves to you. If you want resources to help you, I can provide them. Grace and peace.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dms1972
Upvote 0

bathelter01

Active Member
Apr 21, 2019
46
15
33
Tennessee
✟19,406.00
Country
United States
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Single
Can you please tell us what you feel the unforgivable sin is?

That's where I would start anyway.

Definitely. I think the commentator Henry Alford explains it well:
“It is not a particular species of sin which is here condemned”—like, oh, have I done that one thing?—“it is a definite act showing a state of sin, and that state a willful, determined opposition to the present power of the Holy Spirit; and this as shown by its fruit, blasphemy. The declaration, in substance, of what the New Testament often says.”
 
Upvote 0

Kenny'sID

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Feb 28, 2016
18,185
7,003
69
USA
✟585,394.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Definitely. I think the commentator Henry Alford explains it well:
“It is not a particular species of sin which is here condemned”—like, oh, have I done that one thing?—“it is a definite act showing a state of sin, and that state a willful, determined opposition to the present power of the Holy Spirit; and this as shown by its fruit, blasphemy. The declaration, in substance, of what the New Testament often says.”

OK, great.

Next step, verify that with the bible...have you done that?

EDIT: Hint, it has nothing to do with opposing the power of the Holy Spirit, and I assure you, if you will do yourself the favor of looking it up, you will find just that.

Once you do that, we can go from there, or while you're there, you can take the last step and see what it actually is. Almost, if not always, you will find it is something you haven't done and your actions were something normal and a prime candidate for the forgiveness God set up for just these type things.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: dms1972
Upvote 0

Mozex

New Member
Dec 10, 2019
3
10
39
Begijnendijk
✟592.00
Country
Belgium
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Single
The only unforgivable sin is not to keep on sinning but to say that the Holy Spirit is satan. In scripture Jesus said this to the pharisees I believe because they accused him of being of satan. He did miracles and they said: ofcourse he can do them, he comes from satan. So Jesus answered: all sins can be forgiven but the blasphemy of the Holy Spirit can never be forgiven. That is the unforgivable sin. Jesus does not leave you because you sin. He knew you would sin, thats why He went to the cross. Jesus has not forsaken you but you have lost your faith in Him. In a way, you have forsaken Jesus.
The only thing you have to be carefull of is willingly accusing someone of being of satan, knowing its not true. Because if the things he does comes from the Holy Spirit, you have done the unforgivable sin. The key word is WILLINGLY here. Knowing good enough that it is the Holy SPirit and then accuse it of coming from satan. In my opinion this is the unforgivable sin Jesus talks about. I would not worry to much and go back to having faith in Jesus that He died for your sins on the cross.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Olmhinlu
Upvote 0

danielmears

Active Member
Site Supporter
Jan 30, 2018
266
156
Phelan
✟132,918.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
So I know this is probably not a shocking title and that it's probably common to see a post like this. However, I've been struggling for some years over my possible loss of salvation. You may have seen my posts in the past. I'll link them below for those who would be interested. They may give a more robust explanation of what has happened.

Has my sin killed me spiritually? Loss of salvation
What to do when you are beyond repentance?

The short of it is as follows:
I became a believer around the age of 10 and saw a stark change in my life and desires. Hatred towards sin and love and desire for Christ. Shortly after I was exposed to inappropriate contentography and formed an addiction. The following 17 years were an up and down dealing with addiction and the Lord drawing me back to repentance.
Until 2 years ago. I had been in a pit of sin and despair hating my sin and crying out to the Lord to free me from it but being, seemingly, unable to escape it for long. I had good moments of repentance during that time but I would always inevitable fall back into my sin. I would like to point out that this was not a time of me walking away from Christ in a knowing sense. It was a time of gripping Christ, struggling/falling, repenting, gripping Christ and struggling/falling. During that time I had just started seminary but was still struggling in my thought life and occasionally on the internet.
One night I fell to temptation and felt no remorse or brokenness. It was shocking and horrifying. I sinned and felt no conviction over it. I spent the rest of the night in prayer trying to repent and felt that I could not. Unable to feel broken over sin or that what I had done was a problem.
The next morning I woke up and began seeking the Lord about what had happened filled with an intense sense of deep, deep anxiety about my relationship with the Lord. During a time of prayer I felt, what seemed to me, the departing of the Holy Spirit. The reason I believe this to be true is because of the state of my heart and mind afterwords. My heart felt like a stone in my chest and I felt no love or desire for the Lord. My sin didn't seem to be a big deal to me anymore. I opened my bible and it looked like words on a page. It seemed that I no longer believed the Scriptures anymore no matter how hard I fought to. I knew experientially that they were true but there was not heart level belief. It was like I had undergone a de-renewing of my mind and heart. My thoughts were wicked and I had no regard for the Lord. It seemed as though he had left me completely. There was no work of the Holy Spirit occurring in my life. The Word was not illuminated, I was not convicted of sin and I felt a horrible fear of destruction. The most visceral fear of condemnation.
Two years later nothing has changed. At that time this began I had resolved that I would not continue in sin and that I would continue to submit to the Lord even if he had left me. I resolved to live what was rest of my life to the glory of God but that has become difficult in the lack of desire to do so. It does not seem possible to remain faithful to the Lord apart from the Holy Spirit's work to impart those desires. I have no desire to run head long into sin but I also do not desire the Lord.

I ran across these 2 articles last night and I believe they speak to my situation. I'm not sure what to do now.
What Is the Unforgivable Sin?
Beyond Forgiveness: Blasphemy Against the Spirit

The thing that stuck out to me was,
"The unforgivable sin is when you have resisted him so decisively that he has forsaken you and you can no longer repent. You try to repent and you can't repent. You can't be genuinely sorry for your sin or turn away from it. That is a horribly frightening situation to be in."

RC Sproul quoted a theologian saying, "To be sure, hell will be awful for both, but as one theologian has noted, all the sinners in hell would move heaven and earth if they could remove but one transgression from their record and have their punishment even barely alleviated."

Everything in my life points to this reality and I'm not sure how to move forward. My desires to remain faithful to the Lord have departed and I cannot continue if the Spirit does not empower. If there is no returning of the Holy Spirit because I have blasphemed though persistence in sin, what then should one do? Would it not be most profitable in my situation to remove myself from this life for the sake of my eternity?
The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom; and knowledge of the holy understanding. Proverbs 9:10 The fact you feel an emptiness without God/Christ reveals you are aware that real, "life", comes not from anything from the outside, whether it be inappropriate contentography, drugs, alcohol etc., but from the inside where the kingdom of God is accessed. Real peace and pure love comes from the kingdom within. Remember Jesus telling us the kingdom is within you, not lo here or there. So do what Christ said, love God with all of your heart and mind; plus one another, for we must dwell in love, because God IS love. John 4:5 Realize, once you ask for forgiveness, to be filled with the Spirit, you are to believe you receive by faith, only believe, Christ said. Everything works by faith! If we say we are Christians then we are confessing we believe what Christ said! If we believe what He said we will DO what He said; this is an interactive life! Real, "life", begins when our eyes are opened. So, the fear you felt was a good thing because it opened your eyes so now you may truly live, by faith, not by sight! Oneness is the goal as Jesus prayed in John 17:21, it is true we all have our struggles but with God all things are possible!
 
Upvote 0

Strong in Him

Great is thy faithfulness
Site Supporter
Mar 4, 2005
27,844
7,967
NW England
✟1,049,776.00
Country
United Kingdom
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
I agree.
I've been fighting to continue in prayer and in Scripture reading for the last 2 years. Nothing has changed though. Not a bit. That's why I've been so confident that I've crossed to the point of no return.

If you HAD, I do not believe you would have joined a Christian forum to ask for help. You wouldn't care.
You may not have feelings of being saved; that doesn't mean you aren't. Feelings can change and be affected by illness, depression, bad circumstances etc.

If you are convinced you have reached the point of no return and are totally lost, you have nothing to lose. So why not try reading a passage like Romans 8:31-39 and thank God for his love - ask for more of it, thank him for the cross and that he loves you unconditionally. Even if you don't feel anything, keep going. The devil doesn't want you to feel anything; he wants you to do just what you have done, give up and not think about God.
The devil has already been defeated by Jesus on the cross. He has no power over you. Jesus said that he is the Good Shepherd and NO ONE can snatch us from his Father's hands.
Again, don't trust in feelings, trust in Jesus who tells the truth.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dms1972
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

zoidar

loves Jesus the Christ! ✝️
Site Supporter
Sep 18, 2010
7,206
2,615
✟883,834.00
Country
Sweden
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
So I know this is probably not a shocking title and that it's probably common to see a post like this. However, I've been struggling for some years over my possible loss of salvation. You may have seen my posts in the past. I'll link them below for those who would be interested. They may give a more robust explanation of what has happened.

Has my sin killed me spiritually? Loss of salvation
What to do when you are beyond repentance?

The short of it is as follows:
I became a believer around the age of 10 and saw a stark change in my life and desires. Hatred towards sin and love and desire for Christ. Shortly after I was exposed to inappropriate contentography and formed an addiction. The following 17 years were an up and down dealing with addiction and the Lord drawing me back to repentance.
Until 2 years ago. I had been in a pit of sin and despair hating my sin and crying out to the Lord to free me from it but being, seemingly, unable to escape it for long. I had good moments of repentance during that time but I would always inevitable fall back into my sin. I would like to point out that this was not a time of me walking away from Christ in a knowing sense. It was a time of gripping Christ, struggling/falling, repenting, gripping Christ and struggling/falling. During that time I had just started seminary but was still struggling in my thought life and occasionally on the internet.
One night I fell to temptation and felt no remorse or brokenness. It was shocking and horrifying. I sinned and felt no conviction over it. I spent the rest of the night in prayer trying to repent and felt that I could not. Unable to feel broken over sin or that what I had done was a problem.
The next morning I woke up and began seeking the Lord about what had happened filled with an intense sense of deep, deep anxiety about my relationship with the Lord. During a time of prayer I felt, what seemed to me, the departing of the Holy Spirit. The reason I believe this to be true is because of the state of my heart and mind afterwords. My heart felt like a stone in my chest and I felt no love or desire for the Lord. My sin didn't seem to be a big deal to me anymore. I opened my bible and it looked like words on a page. It seemed that I no longer believed the Scriptures anymore no matter how hard I fought to. I knew experientially that they were true but there was not heart level belief. It was like I had undergone a de-renewing of my mind and heart. My thoughts were wicked and I had no regard for the Lord. It seemed as though he had left me completely. There was no work of the Holy Spirit occurring in my life. The Word was not illuminated, I was not convicted of sin and I felt a horrible fear of destruction. The most visceral fear of condemnation.
Two years later nothing has changed. At that time this began I had resolved that I would not continue in sin and that I would continue to submit to the Lord even if he had left me. I resolved to live what was rest of my life to the glory of God but that has become difficult in the lack of desire to do so. It does not seem possible to remain faithful to the Lord apart from the Holy Spirit's work to impart those desires. I have no desire to run head long into sin but I also do not desire the Lord.

I ran across these 2 articles last night and I believe they speak to my situation. I'm not sure what to do now.
What Is the Unforgivable Sin?
Beyond Forgiveness: Blasphemy Against the Spirit

The thing that stuck out to me was,
"The unforgivable sin is when you have resisted him so decisively that he has forsaken you and you can no longer repent. You try to repent and you can't repent. You can't be genuinely sorry for your sin or turn away from it. That is a horribly frightening situation to be in."

RC Sproul quoted a theologian saying, "To be sure, hell will be awful for both, but as one theologian has noted, all the sinners in hell would move heaven and earth if they could remove but one transgression from their record and have their punishment even barely alleviated."

Everything in my life points to this reality and I'm not sure how to move forward. My desires to remain faithful to the Lord have departed and I cannot continue if the Spirit does not empower. If there is no returning of the Holy Spirit because I have blasphemed though persistence in sin, what then should one do? Would it not be most profitable in my situation to remove myself from this life for the sake of my eternity?

I say the same to everyone that thinks they have blasphemed the Holy Spirit. If you want to renew your relationship with the Lord you haven't done it. It's like a monk and friend told me: "If you had, you wouldn't be here in church thinking about this. You would be out playing golf, not concerned about your relationship with God."

Put your trust in God's mercy. He is merciful you know.

Christ love,
P
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

Strong in Him

Great is thy faithfulness
Site Supporter
Mar 4, 2005
27,844
7,967
NW England
✟1,049,776.00
Country
United Kingdom
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
I agree totally. It is a work of the Holy Spirit in us. So what then does it mean when it is not being produced in us?

I think it is.
You said:
The next morning I woke up and began seeking the Lord about what had happened filled with an intense sense of deep, deep anxiety about my relationship with the Lord.

You sinned, and felt very anxious about your relationship with the Lord.

Two years later nothing has changed. At that time this began I had resolved that I would not continue in sin and that I would continue to submit to the Lord even if he had left me.

Even though you thought God had left you, your aim was still to honour, and submit to, him. That's awesome. That's like Job when he said, "though he may slay me; I will trust him." You can't see it but that's amazing faith!

I have no desire to run head long into sin but I also do not desire the Lord.

You may not desire the Lord, but you don't desire to sin either - do you not think that may be repentance?

Everything in my life points to this reality and I'm not sure how to move forward.

The reality is;
- you've joined a Christian forum
- you're asking Christians for help
- you have knowledge of God and how he works; i.e "there is no empowerment without the Spirit".
- you are concerned that you have blasphemed the Holy Spirit; like I said before, if you had, you wouldn't care.

Your OP contains the word feelings a number of times; feelings are temporary and may be misleading. Paul says that "we walk by faith not by sight", 2 Corinthians 5:7. For years I relied on my feelings to tell me whether or not God loved me. I was foolish; he already showed how much he loved me by the cross, 1 John 3:16.
 
Upvote 0

A_Thinker

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Apr 23, 2004
11,911
9,064
Midwest
✟953,784.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
So I know this is probably not a shocking title and that it's probably common to see a post like this. However, I've been struggling for some years over my possible loss of salvation. You may have seen my posts in the past. I'll link them below for those who would be interested. They may give a more robust explanation of what has happened.

Has my sin killed me spiritually? Loss of salvation
What to do when you are beyond repentance?

The short of it is as follows:
I became a believer around the age of 10 and saw a stark change in my life and desires. Hatred towards sin and love and desire for Christ. Shortly after I was exposed to inappropriate contentography and formed an addiction. The following 17 years were an up and down dealing with addiction and the Lord drawing me back to repentance.
Until 2 years ago. I had been in a pit of sin and despair hating my sin and crying out to the Lord to free me from it but being, seemingly, unable to escape it for long. I had good moments of repentance during that time but I would always inevitable fall back into my sin. I would like to point out that this was not a time of me walking away from Christ in a knowing sense. It was a time of gripping Christ, struggling/falling, repenting, gripping Christ and struggling/falling. During that time I had just started seminary but was still struggling in my thought life and occasionally on the internet.
One night I fell to temptation and felt no remorse or brokenness. It was shocking and horrifying. I sinned and felt no conviction over it. I spent the rest of the night in prayer trying to repent and felt that I could not. Unable to feel broken over sin or that what I had done was a problem.
The next morning I woke up and began seeking the Lord about what had happened filled with an intense sense of deep, deep anxiety about my relationship with the Lord. During a time of prayer I felt, what seemed to me, the departing of the Holy Spirit. The reason I believe this to be true is because of the state of my heart and mind afterwords. My heart felt like a stone in my chest and I felt no love or desire for the Lord. My sin didn't seem to be a big deal to me anymore. I opened my bible and it looked like words on a page. It seemed that I no longer believed the Scriptures anymore no matter how hard I fought to. I knew experientially that they were true but there was not heart level belief. It was like I had undergone a de-renewing of my mind and heart. My thoughts were wicked and I had no regard for the Lord. It seemed as though he had left me completely. There was no work of the Holy Spirit occurring in my life. The Word was not illuminated, I was not convicted of sin and I felt a horrible fear of destruction. The most visceral fear of condemnation.
Two years later nothing has changed. At that time this began I had resolved that I would not continue in sin and that I would continue to submit to the Lord even if he had left me. I resolved to live what was rest of my life to the glory of God but that has become difficult in the lack of desire to do so. It does not seem possible to remain faithful to the Lord apart from the Holy Spirit's work to impart those desires. I have no desire to run head long into sin but I also do not desire the Lord.

I ran across these 2 articles last night and I believe they speak to my situation. I'm not sure what to do now.
What Is the Unforgivable Sin?
Beyond Forgiveness: Blasphemy Against the Spirit

The thing that stuck out to me was,
"The unforgivable sin is when you have resisted him so decisively that he has forsaken you and you can no longer repent. You try to repent and you can't repent. You can't be genuinely sorry for your sin or turn away from it. That is a horribly frightening situation to be in."

RC Sproul quoted a theologian saying, "To be sure, hell will be awful for both, but as one theologian has noted, all the sinners in hell would move heaven and earth if they could remove but one transgression from their record and have their punishment even barely alleviated."

Everything in my life points to this reality and I'm not sure how to move forward. My desires to remain faithful to the Lord have departed and I cannot continue if the Spirit does not empower. If there is no returning of the Holy Spirit because I have blasphemed though persistence in sin, what then should one do? Would it not be most profitable in my situation to remove myself from this life for the sake of my eternity?
I would say that you have seared your conscience ... regarding the sin against which you struggled for so long.

It is not uncommon in the lives of Christians.

If you desire a renewal/revival of your relationship with Christ (I assume that's why you have posted this thread), I would suggest that you seek out a new channel of fellowship with God.

My story is a bit different than yours. Though all christians struggle with sin in their lives, ... I was, most recently, significantly affected in my faith in God's sustaining power in my life ... due to family circumstances beyond my control.

For three years I struggled to continue to believe that God would rescue me (and my wife) from the sorrows and struggles with which we were facing on a daily basis. My faith ... and my fellowship with God became strained. I could not find joy or peace in the sense that I could before my struggle began.

At some point, as I simply continued to cling to God for dear life's sake, ... I was moved to turn to a different source of spiritual refreshment. I, once had been a great fan and follower of Contemporary Christian Music in my early adult life, ... but I had allowed that channel of spiritual refreshment to be replaced by marriage and family, and increased involvements at my local church. I never saw this transition as a bad thing, and I don't believe that it was even now, ... but it did not seem to be serving me as it once had.

As a result of a variety of circumstances, I was re-introduced to Contemporary christian music being produced today. I resisted for a bit (feeling that I didn't have the necessary room in my life) ... but my heart was touched and drawn by a few of the songs I was exposed to. Ultimately, I gave in ... and located my local contemporary christian music radio station.

It has been ... a balm to my soul. I am being ministered to ... in ways that I have not been for years. My soul is refreshed ... and I cannot imagine going on without CCM in my life.

Life with the Lord is a journey. Sometimes the established channels of fellowship become stale and inadequate for your current stage in the journey. Be open to ... seek out ... a new (or forgotten) way of fellowship with the Lord. Don't let your sin hold you back ... the Lord will deal with that. Make Him your current life goal. Enjoy Him and find refreshment in Him ... and watch Him change your life ...
 
Upvote 0

Norbert L

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Mar 1, 2009
2,856
1,064
✟560,360.00
Faith
Christian Seeker
Marital Status
Single
If there is no returning of the Holy Spirit because I have blasphemed though persistence in sin, what then should one do? Would it not be most profitable in my situation to remove myself from this life for the sake of my eternity?
"In struggling against sin, you have not yet resisted to the point of shedding your blood." Hebrews 12:4 CSB

"There is hope, however, for anyone who is among the living; for even a live dog is better than a dead lion." Ecclesiastes 9:4 BSB

Or as Yogi Berra said, "It ain't over till it's over."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Olmhinlu
Upvote 0

98cwitr

Lord forgive me
Apr 20, 2006
20,020
3,473
Raleigh, NC
✟449,894.00
Country
United States
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Constitution
Yeah, I don't really doubt that I was a believer. I had a false conversion experience when I was about 7 and then came to Christ when I was about 10. The reason I feel that it was a true birth is because of how deeply the Lord changed me and changed my desires. I hated sin and desired him from the heart. I don't think it's a situation of I never was a Christian, but that, like the article articulated, there is a persistence in sin that leads to spiritual death, and I did that.

WAS a believer? You don't believe in God anymore?
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

Ken Rank

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Jan 12, 2014
7,218
5,563
Winchester, KENtucky
✟308,985.00
Country
United States
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
"The unforgivable sin is when you have resisted him so decisively that he has forsaken you and you can no longer repent. You try to repent and you can't repent. You can't be genuinely sorry for your sin or turn away from it. That is a horribly frightening situation to be in."
So this is not an accurate definition. Let me show you why:

In the Greek (G987) we find:
blasphēmeō
Thayer Definition:
1) to speak reproachfully, rail at, revile, calumniate, blaspheme
2) to be evil spoken of, reviled, railed at


In Hebrew, the word is ne'âtsâh and it means to scorn, blaspheme.

Now... since this word has been in use in our bible since we began to translate them into English, we should have an understanding of how the English was understood back then. The best we can do is go to the 1828 Webster's dictionary which says this:

BLASPHE'ME, v.t. [Gr. The first syllable is the same as in blame, blasme, denoting injury; L. loedo, loesus; The last syllable is the Gr.,to speak.]

1. To speak of the Supreme Being in terms of impious irreverence; to revile or speak reproachfully of God, or the Holy Spirit. 1 Ki 21. Mark 3.

2. To speak evil of; to utter abuse or calumny against; to speak reproachfully of.


So, in each case, the word is dealing with SPEAKING. The blaspheme is TO SPEAK evil against, TO SPEAK reproachfully against. Think of the context around Yeshua saying, "he that blasphemes the Holy Spirit will not be forgiven." Those he said that to were attributing his works to satan by SPEAKING that lie to Yeshua and those around him. They were openly saying how his works were not of God.

Blaspheming the Holy Spirit isn't making a bad choice or falling into temptation... we ALL HAVE at some point and that is the point of why Yeshua had to come... we can't save ourselves! :) But the sin that won't be forgiven isn't a bad action, it is speaking evil against God but even then not by accident, but with INTENT. Those around Yeshua KNEW his works were godly and they still attributed them to satan. That is the difference, WILLFUL sin as opposed to unintentional sin.
 
  • Winner
Reactions: Bobber
Upvote 0

Jermayn

Well-Known Member
May 22, 2019
940
500
Northwest Florida
✟108,111.00
Country
United States
Faith
Pentecostal
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
So I know this is probably not a shocking title and that it's probably common to see a post like this. However, I've been struggling for some years over my possible loss of salvation. You may have seen my posts in the past. I'll link them below for those who would be interested. They may give a more robust explanation of what has happened.

Has my sin killed me spiritually? Loss of salvation
What to do when you are beyond repentance?

The short of it is as follows:
I became a believer around the age of 10 and saw a stark change in my life and desires. Hatred towards sin and love and desire for Christ. Shortly after I was exposed to inappropriate contentography and formed an addiction. The following 17 years were an up and down dealing with addiction and the Lord drawing me back to repentance.
Until 2 years ago. I had been in a pit of sin and despair hating my sin and crying out to the Lord to free me from it but being, seemingly, unable to escape it for long. I had good moments of repentance during that time but I would always inevitable fall back into my sin. I would like to point out that this was not a time of me walking away from Christ in a knowing sense. It was a time of gripping Christ, struggling/falling, repenting, gripping Christ and struggling/falling. During that time I had just started seminary but was still struggling in my thought life and occasionally on the internet.
One night I fell to temptation and felt no remorse or brokenness. It was shocking and horrifying. I sinned and felt no conviction over it. I spent the rest of the night in prayer trying to repent and felt that I could not. Unable to feel broken over sin or that what I had done was a problem.
The next morning I woke up and began seeking the Lord about what had happened filled with an intense sense of deep, deep anxiety about my relationship with the Lord. During a time of prayer I felt, what seemed to me, the departing of the Holy Spirit. The reason I believe this to be true is because of the state of my heart and mind afterwords. My heart felt like a stone in my chest and I felt no love or desire for the Lord. My sin didn't seem to be a big deal to me anymore. I opened my bible and it looked like words on a page. It seemed that I no longer believed the Scriptures anymore no matter how hard I fought to. I knew experientially that they were true but there was not heart level belief. It was like I had undergone a de-renewing of my mind and heart. My thoughts were wicked and I had no regard for the Lord. It seemed as though he had left me completely. There was no work of the Holy Spirit occurring in my life. The Word was not illuminated, I was not convicted of sin and I felt a horrible fear of destruction. The most visceral fear of condemnation.
Two years later nothing has changed. At that time this began I had resolved that I would not continue in sin and that I would continue to submit to the Lord even if he had left me. I resolved to live what was rest of my life to the glory of God but that has become difficult in the lack of desire to do so. It does not seem possible to remain faithful to the Lord apart from the Holy Spirit's work to impart those desires. I have no desire to run head long into sin but I also do not desire the Lord.

I ran across these 2 articles last night and I believe they speak to my situation. I'm not sure what to do now.
What Is the Unforgivable Sin?
Beyond Forgiveness: Blasphemy Against the Spirit

The thing that stuck out to me was,
"The unforgivable sin is when you have resisted him so decisively that he has forsaken you and you can no longer repent. You try to repent and you can't repent. You can't be genuinely sorry for your sin or turn away from it. That is a horribly frightening situation to be in."

RC Sproul quoted a theologian saying, "To be sure, hell will be awful for both, but as one theologian has noted, all the sinners in hell would move heaven and earth if they could remove but one transgression from their record and have their punishment even barely alleviated."

Everything in my life points to this reality and I'm not sure how to move forward. My desires to remain faithful to the Lord have departed and I cannot continue if the Spirit does not empower. If there is no returning of the Holy Spirit because I have blasphemed though persistence in sin, what then should one do? Would it not be most profitable in my situation to remove myself from this life for the sake of my eternity?

There is such a thing as a seared conscience. This sounds more like what's going on in your case due to the persistent sin. This can be healed. As far as how you feel, God has shown me that how I feel doesn't change his promises. Yesterday I felt like a million dollars and God's promises were the same. Today I feel miserable and his promises are the same. Tomorrow I may feel completely numb and his promises will still be the same. Look at what happened with Job. Also, remember the prodigal son.

Edit - Also, the way to get past that persistent sinning is through a very close relationship with God and having a living faith, not just saying you have faith (dead faith). If you believe what God has said in his word, then you will DO what he says. Look at it this way, I wouldn't come to work each day if I didn't have faith my employer would pay me at the end of every 2 weeks. Likewise, I wouldn't keep God's commands and deny my flesh earthy pleasures if I didn't believe he existed or is telling the truth about everything stated in his word.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: dms1972
Upvote 0

tdidymas

Newbie
Aug 28, 2014
2,323
998
Houston, TX
✟163,285.00
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Republican
So I know this is probably not a shocking title and that it's probably common to see a post like this. However, I've been struggling for some years over my possible loss of salvation. You may have seen my posts in the past. I'll link them below for those who would be interested. They may give a more robust explanation of what has happened.

Has my sin killed me spiritually? Loss of salvation
What to do when you are beyond repentance?

The short of it is as follows:
I became a believer around the age of 10 and saw a stark change in my life and desires. Hatred towards sin and love and desire for Christ. Shortly after I was exposed to inappropriate contentography and formed an addiction. The following 17 years were an up and down dealing with addiction and the Lord drawing me back to repentance.
Until 2 years ago. I had been in a pit of sin and despair hating my sin and crying out to the Lord to free me from it but being, seemingly, unable to escape it for long. I had good moments of repentance during that time but I would always inevitable fall back into my sin. I would like to point out that this was not a time of me walking away from Christ in a knowing sense. It was a time of gripping Christ, struggling/falling, repenting, gripping Christ and struggling/falling. During that time I had just started seminary but was still struggling in my thought life and occasionally on the internet.
One night I fell to temptation and felt no remorse or brokenness. It was shocking and horrifying. I sinned and felt no conviction over it. I spent the rest of the night in prayer trying to repent and felt that I could not. Unable to feel broken over sin or that what I had done was a problem.
The next morning I woke up and began seeking the Lord about what had happened filled with an intense sense of deep, deep anxiety about my relationship with the Lord. During a time of prayer I felt, what seemed to me, the departing of the Holy Spirit. The reason I believe this to be true is because of the state of my heart and mind afterwords. My heart felt like a stone in my chest and I felt no love or desire for the Lord. My sin didn't seem to be a big deal to me anymore. I opened my bible and it looked like words on a page. It seemed that I no longer believed the Scriptures anymore no matter how hard I fought to. I knew experientially that they were true but there was not heart level belief. It was like I had undergone a de-renewing of my mind and heart. My thoughts were wicked and I had no regard for the Lord. It seemed as though he had left me completely. There was no work of the Holy Spirit occurring in my life. The Word was not illuminated, I was not convicted of sin and I felt a horrible fear of destruction. The most visceral fear of condemnation.
Two years later nothing has changed. At that time this began I had resolved that I would not continue in sin and that I would continue to submit to the Lord even if he had left me. I resolved to live what was rest of my life to the glory of God but that has become difficult in the lack of desire to do so. It does not seem possible to remain faithful to the Lord apart from the Holy Spirit's work to impart those desires. I have no desire to run head long into sin but I also do not desire the Lord.

I ran across these 2 articles last night and I believe they speak to my situation. I'm not sure what to do now.
What Is the Unforgivable Sin?
Beyond Forgiveness: Blasphemy Against the Spirit

The thing that stuck out to me was,
"The unforgivable sin is when you have resisted him so decisively that he has forsaken you and you can no longer repent. You try to repent and you can't repent. You can't be genuinely sorry for your sin or turn away from it. That is a horribly frightening situation to be in."

RC Sproul quoted a theologian saying, "To be sure, hell will be awful for both, but as one theologian has noted, all the sinners in hell would move heaven and earth if they could remove but one transgression from their record and have their punishment even barely alleviated."

Everything in my life points to this reality and I'm not sure how to move forward. My desires to remain faithful to the Lord have departed and I cannot continue if the Spirit does not empower. If there is no returning of the Holy Spirit because I have blasphemed though persistence in sin, what then should one do? Would it not be most profitable in my situation to remove myself from this life for the sake of my eternity?

I once felt the same as you do. What brought me through it was to recognize my lack of faith, and to study the scriptures to find out what was the real faith they were talking about. In the course of my studies in Hebrews, I discovered that my persistent doubts was causing my insecurity. After surrendering my faith into God's hands, my faith was eventually strengthened to the point that I can no longer doubt Rom. 8:38-39. What I also discovered was that faith transcends feelings, and understood that I should continue trusting Christ no matter how I felt in any given moment.
TD:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: friend of
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums
Dec 6, 2019
16
5
28
Lupercalia City Blk. 496
✟1,345.00
Country
Romania
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
i've been there too...
i also did panic
i also do not know what to do
it break my heart
i regret and regretted
and it came to pass
and did betrayed him again and again
and every single day keep falling and falling

i know the real name of God but let's just forget about his name lest i say it again in vain

and yeah i keep trying again alone over and over i am not saying i don't need your help and alone i can do this just that afraid it wouldn't work but you asked me why am i saying this where would this go? that i also do not know maybe i am mentally unstabled i am just tired because i can't change my ways maybe i should just read the comments i might get something
 
  • Prayers
Reactions: Olmhinlu
Upvote 0