Oh that is easy. It gets into the whole issue of "the construction of reality". A broad topic.
But the basic idea is we humans do not really see reality purely as it is, but we interpret it and we also construct it (we try to figure it out like amateur scientists). Which kind of is a "no duh statement" for some folks (steeped in epistemology, postmodernism etc.) but not so much for other people. I'm talking about Naive Realists.
(In
social psychology,
naïve realism is the human tendency to believe that we see the world around us
objectively, and that people who disagree with us must be uninformed,
irrational, or
biased.).
Naïve realism (psychology) - Wikipedia
The whole logic thing I'm sure work good for you. There are certain personality types given to that. I am a big fan of the the Myers Briggs Personality Indicator as a general . There are certain personality types very given to making logic thee driver for everything. For simplicity sake we will just say you are an INTP, even though you may be more about "the facts", details etc. (using sensing rather than intuition, being an ISTJ, ISTP etc.)
Introduction | Logician Personality (INTP-A / INTP-T) | 16Personalities
But other folks don't think that way, and to insist that they do, or should start's to get into the territory of naive realism. For example, at least half the world are feelers who base there decisions not on logic but moral values that they believe in some way are intrinsic. Then there are people like me, I'm an INTJ a close relative to the INTP, but I base my reasoning on a kind of internalized Utilitarian philosophy. Rather than thinking in terms of Logic which can be a dead end in many situations one can talk instead on things based on how useful a idea or a model is, does it allow you to account for the data, and serve in other ways.
But its not just about how we are wired in terms of personality, it gets into our whole past, etc. kind of like the famous work "The Politics of Experience" by Scottish psychiatrist, R. D. Laing (1967). Which a Marxist website kindly has been hosting for the last few years for those that would like to read the opening chapter.
The Politics of Experience