Understanding how at the Last Supper Jesus became one with our lost and broken creation. And how by rising from the dead God demonstrated the reality of his promise of new life to the lost and broken.
I like the music in the video. The analogy to a single grain of wheat is confusing to me. Jesus said "this is my body" referring to bread. He wasn't referring to a single grain of wheat. The rest of the video is interesting but not very relevant to the verse with "this is my body" in it.Understanding how at the Last Supper Jesus became one with our lost and broken creation. And how by rising from the dead God demonstrated the reality of his promise of new life to the lost and broken.
The question is not "how" but "What is bread?" It's a deep question but worth thinking aboutI like the music in the video. The analogy to a single grain of wheat is confusing to me. Jesus said "this is my body" referring to bread. He wasn't referring to a single grain of wheat. The rest of the video is interesting but not very relevant to the verse with "this is my body" in it.
Isn't it enough that Jesus said "this is my body"? Is it necessary to know "how" in order to believe what he said?
Doubtful. When Christ instituted the sacrament he took ordinary bread and said "this" etc. He then ordered his disciples to eat it.The question is not "how" but "What is bread?" It's a deep question but worth thinking about
Bread is what people eat. It's made from flour, water, salt, and maybe some oil. Flour is made by grinding wheat. It isn't a very deep question really.The question is not "how" but "What is bread?" It's a deep question but worth thinking about
Just wondering how you know that.Doubtful. When Christ instituted the sacrament he took ordinary bread and said "this" etc. He then ordered his disciples to eat it.
He certainly was not referring to some metaphysical bread or spiritual, uncorporeal something or other, as opposed to actual bread.
OK, would it be a deep question if you had to die to be food so the wheat could live?Bread is what people eat. It's made from flour, water, salt, and maybe some oil. Flour is made by grinding wheat. It isn't a very deep question really.
In the beginning, God created seeds for the purpose of becoming a living being. Using seeds as food came later and repurposed God's original plan. A seed is designed to become a plant and every part of the seed functions for that purpose. Using seed as food disregards its purpose, takes what it can and discards the rest. God did not design life to be wasted. Can you see the parallels between the seed that died to be our food and Jesus who died for us?It's right there in the Gospel account. In fact, all of it is repeated at every Holy Communion service in quite a few churches.
Understanding how at the Last Supper Jesus became one with our lost and broken creation. And how by rising from the dead God demonstrated the reality of his promise of new life to the lost and broken.
I don't have any problem with this . . . except Jesus used the word "is". He didn't use the word "like" which he could have.The Lord’s Supper (bread & wine) symbolizes our acceptance of the body (bread) and blood (wine) of Jesus, spilled and broken for us.
Matthew 26:17-30
John 6:48-63
John 13:1-17
1 Corinthians 10:16-17
1 Corinthians 11:23-30
Revelation 3:20
It's right there in the Gospel account. In fact, all of it is repeated at every Holy Communion service in quite a few churches.
Yes . . but Jesus didn't say "now this bread is my body". That is the bread was his body before he spoke. It was his body and is his body now. Jesus was stating a fact and not working a miracle.Exactly. Christ "this" meant exactly that, that His Real Presence is in the bread
Yes . . but Jesus didn't say "now this bread is my body". That is the bread was his body before he spoke. It was his body and is his body now. Jesus was stating a fact and not working a miracle.
I'd say yes. How can I believe in what I don't know I'm believing in?Isn't it enough that Jesus said "this is my body"? Is it necessary to know "how" in order to believe what he said?
I do not know what that string of words means. I do not plan to die to be food. How would me dying make wheat live?OK, would it be a deep question if you had to die to be food so the wheat could live?
If you need to know how the bread is Christ's body before you will believe what he says about it do you also need to know how the Trinity is 3 persons and one God before you will believe it?I'd say yes. How can I believe in what I don't know I'm believing in?