Well, I don't know what you are watching...a critique? I'm pretty sure every group has their critics. Try this short one. I have gained a lot from this guy Brad Scott of WildBranch ministry. I do not consider them to be "Judaizers".
So.... do you need to be circumcised and perform animal sacrifices because that "fills up the spirit of the law"? If you're passionate enough about it, than you've "fulfilled it in spirit"? (That's basically what he said.)
Now let's take his concept and see if it has universal application across all Scripture passages that use that word. (And we are doing this because the Scripture tells us to interpret it by using itself. "line upon line, precept upon precept...." (Isaiah 28)
The word "fulfill" in Hebrew is translated as:
fill (107x),
full (48x),
fulfill (28x),
consecrate (15x),
accomplish (7x),
replenish (7x),
wholly (6x),
set (6x),
expired (3x),
fully (2x),
gather (2x),
overflow (2x),
satisfy (2x),
miscellaneous (14x).
The word "fulfill" in Greek is translated as:
be (255x),
come to pass (82x),
be made (69x),
be done (63x),
come (52x),
become (47x),
God forbid (with G3361) (15x),
arise (13x),
have (5x),
be fulfilled (3x),
be married to (3x),
be preferred (3x),
not translated (14x),
miscellaneous (4x),
vr done (2x).
Now as we can see just by looking at all these words, "fulfill" does't universally mean "to fill up".
Let's take a look at a couple of examples:
Numbers 6:13
And this is
the law of
the Nazarite, when
the days of his separation are
fulfilled: he shall be brought unto
the door of
the tabernacle of
the congregation:
Now one of the things that happens once the Nazarite vow is "filled up" is the person cuts their hair. They no longer continue in letting their hair grow because the vow is "fulfilled". So the cease from a certain activity because it's fulfilled.
John 15:25
But this cometh to pass, that
the word might be
fulfilled that is written in
their
law,
They hated me without a cause.
Now here's an interesting example of this in the negative. What's written in the law has been "filled up" that they hated Him without a cause. Now keep in mind the passage says they are fulfilling the law with their hatred; yet are they suppose to hate Him? Is what they are doing a moral action? No, they are actually fulfilling the law by their sin!
Do they eventually cease to hate Him without a cause? Well, yeah they do. The cease when either they are converted or they face God's wrath.
So here is another example that they are fulfilling the law by something that morally they should stop doing!
Romans 8:4
That
the righteousness of
the law might be
fulfilled in us, who walk not after
the flesh, but after
the Spirit.
Here's a verse that gives us some information. Righteousness of the law is not fulfilled in the flesh but after the Spirit. The next 3 verses I'm going to put up here explain what that means.
Romans 13:8
Owe no man any thing, but to love one another: for he that loveth another hath
fulfilled
the law.
Romans 13:10
Love worketh no ill to his neighbor:
therefore love is
the fulfilling of
the law.
Galatians 5:14
For all
the law is
fulfilled in one word, even in this; Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself.
Now these three verses here all explain that if you love one another, work no ill toward your neighbor and love your neighbor as yourself; you have "filled up" the law.
Now does being circumcised, performing animal sacrifices or not eating pork have anything to do with loving someone else?
Matthew 5:18
For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from
the law, till all be
fulfilled.
Now here's my question related to this passage. Is the law "filled up" for some people and not for others? (thus the reference to heaven and earth passing away). If it's been fulfilled for a believer because of Christ, than jot and tittle does pass away, even if heaven and earth haven't yet.
Yet, note the weightier matters (justice, mercy and faith) are displayed in showing forth love as the fulfillment of the law.
It's not about following the outward sign when the substance has come and fulfilled the law.
So what happens practically speaking and how?
The guy in the video does have correct that it is God who plants the seed. What he's missing though is that the permanence of that planted seed is not nurtured in following the outward signs of the Mosaic law.
The Holy Ghost does not take up permanent residence in someone to go back to picking up the law of Moses. Those in Christ are dead to that law and in Christ are alive to the law of the Spirit of life or the law that gives life. Romans 8:2, Galatians 3:21.
Those born of the Spirit are now under a different law. And that "law of life" is still good and right and just and moral, because all those things are the nature of God the Spirit who now indwells that person. They live on a different paradigm; because the purpose of the first law was to convict men of sin.